With graduation season upon us, both “NBC Nightly News” and The Associated Press just ran stories on the growing number of American high schools breaking with tradition to name more than one student as valedictorian.

At Vanguard High School in Ocala, Fla., 27 students in this year’s class of 370 share what used to be a singular honor. Colleen Wade, the International Baccalaureate Program coordinator, defended the school’s practice, saying, “[We] have 27 students who met the requirements, so they should be recognized and … honored.”

A clinical psychologist was NBC’s requisite naysayer: “The more valedictorians we have, the less meaning it has. When they get to the quote-unquote real world, they’re going to have no way to know how to handle that competition.”

And NBC reporter Janet Shamlian likened the new trend to a slightly older one in kids’ sports, “where everyone gets a trophy.”

Advertise with us

That sports practice is old enough that my 20-something kids grew up with it — and during their childhoods, I would have agreed with the naysayers. But not anymore — not after what I’ve seen of modern American high schools.

The “everyone’s a winner” approach is certainly wrongheaded. It cheapens the value of striving and achieving. It breeds both entitlement and cynicism.

My oldest child had a terrifically jaded take on it by the tender age of 7. As I drove him home from a summer day camp where adults he barely knew had just handed him a trophy with something like “Most Improved” slapped on it, he observed, “They just do this so we’ll all feel good about ourselves.”

I could only laugh — even while the anxious parent in me winced. Yes, we do want you kids to feel good about yourselves — but not too good. Not sociopath-good. Just … valued.

No volunteer can discern much about 17 crumb-crunchers in five half-days of camp, but it was different a few years later when a soccer coach bestowed trophies on my daughter’s fifth-grade team. He had worked with them for months and customized his accolades to their budding qualities.

Advertise with us

Emma’s award was “Most Tenacious!” A decade later, the coach’s insight still suits her.

And tenacious fits the seniors who toil through insane hours of homework from IB programs and Advanced Placement classes, to earn those better-than-perfect grade-point averages. There is no question that high school is a significantly harder passage than it used to be.

When I took the SAT in, ahem, 1979, I did not know what it was. I truly had almost no idea — just something required if you wanted to go to college. I was lucky I had the right pencil when I showed up half-asleep at school one Saturday morning.

These days kids are pushed and pulled and pushed some more. At Vanguard, there were 28 valedictorians last year — all of whom had straight A’s and 5.0 weighted GPAs. This year, the school made it harder, adding requirements for 100 hours of community service and high SAT scores, and they still had 27 kids surpass their requirements.

Clinical psychologist Jennifer Hartstein worried that when these legions of valedictorians enter the “real world, they’re going to have no way to know how to handle that competition.”

Advertise with us

Oh, they understand competition! The pressure is so ridiculous that this is the one time I would give every graduate a trophy just for participating. I guess that’s what the diploma is: Congratulations! You survived.

So if 7 percent of the survivors do so well that they all have GPAs above 4.0, how is it psychological sabotage to recognize their excellence?

Some districts have dealt with the situation by abolishing the “valedictorian” title altogether and instead recognizing all their highest achievers as “distinguished scholars.” It’s similar to a university’s summa cum laude.

Does having multiple winners dilute the award’s meaning? The kids didn’t seem to think so. One of Vanguard’s new grads said, “I don’t think of it as sharing. I just think of it as, ‘We all did this.’ ”

She’s much closer to a winning attitude than she would be with the winner-take-all rule. The real world probably includes as many group endeavors and team efforts as it does solo turns.

Advertise with us

And true education is about finding something deeper, richer and longer lasting than mere competition against others. The goal of education is to shape lifelong learners. If a school community succeeds in producing so many, then we all win — and so should they.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com