The furor in Indiana has forced me into a position that I saw coming a decade ago and devoted all the energy I could, in however modest a capacity as a writer and speaker, to try to prevent.

My “aha!” moment came when George W. Bush said during the 2004 presidential campaign that he was in favor of civil unions for gays. The first words out of my mouth — because I talk back to the TV — were “Separate but equal will not stand.”

I have argued publicly and often that gay Americans need and deserve the right to marry on equal footing with their straight fellow citizens.

Knowing very well, however, that many religious traditions view marriage as a sacred act and thus would not accept the government or the courts redefining the term “marriage,” I argued that we could finesse our irreconcilable differences by empowering the state to license “civil unions for all.”

Advertise with us

Such an accord — one which separates the inherently religious aspect of marriage from the legal contract — would preserve the fundamental right to the free exercise of religion while extending to all two-person relationships the equal protections of the law.

And my sincere hope was that if Christians demonstrated good will and respect in this way, it would open a door to serious, loving dialogue about grace and faith. Too often the church has treated gays with distance or disdain, a tragic failure I hoped could be addressed through this live-and-let-live embrace.

But I was urging action on people who, as conservatives in both their religion and their politics, are by nature and nurture disinclined to be “proactive” on such a transformative issue.

I also think this idea’s “failure to launch” is due to the now-reflexive polarization of our public discourse and to the fact that it’s easier for special interest groups to raise funds and turn out their “political base” when they can stir up anger and fear. We ordinary citizens are the losers.

The opportunity to work out a broad and inclusive accord having apparently passed, centrists and “conservatarians” — who are today’s true liberals — are forced into a primarily defensive posture. But as the right to dissent is the hallmark of a free society, defend it we must.

Advertise with us

Since Indiana, like a majority of states, does not have strong anti-bias laws on the books, its “Religious Freedom Restoration Act” was not worded strictly enough, some legal scholars say, to prevent routine discrimination against gays. The same concern quickly arose last week in Arkansas.

Those problems can and should be quickly remedied.

But here in Pennsylvania, Gov. Tom Wolf, other Democrats and gay activists called for new laws to prevent discrimination — just as Pennsylvania was being singled out for praise in national forums for already having a strong law.

That’s just partisan opportunism.

Celebrity hypocrisy is rampant as well, with famous bands and comedians canceling their Indiana gigs, even while keeping dates in states that do not allow same-sex marriage. (Indiana does.)

Advertise with us

Mozilla CEO Brendan Eich was forced from his job last year as gay-marriage activists uncovered his 2008 contribution to California’s Proposition 8 campaign, which sought to ban same-sex marriage. Andrew Sullivan, the intellectual who in 1989 launched the entire gay-marriage movement, wrote strongly in Mr. Eich’s defense.

“A civil rights movement without toleration is not a civil rights movement; it is a cultural campaign to expunge and destroy its opponents.”

Similarly, as gay-rights supporters now tweet, post and phone in death threats against various Indiana businesses, gay talk-show host Tammy Bruce has likened them to fascists:

“If there’s anyone in the world who should understand the vulnerability of being a minority … and being able to live your life as you see fit, it’s the gay community,” she said on a Fox News program.

Whether traditionalists will be able to live as they see fit will probably turn on whether the U.S. Supreme Court adheres to the anti-coercion philosophy it expounded in the Hobby Lobby decision last year. In that case it found that for-profit businesses can express their owners’ religious views — specifically the right not to provide birth control and abortifacients to employees (who remain free to get them on their own).

Advertise with us

I happen not to agree with the florists and bakers who believe they must decline to supply flowers or food to gay weddings. And I believe that if they are Christians, they have lost a crucial opportunity to demonstrate a sacrificial love.

But regardless of how you and I feel about it, in a free society their religious decisions are not ours to make.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com