In the uninformed, preening or downright cynical outcry over Indiana’s “Religious Freedom Restoration Act,” Hillary Rodham Clinton tweeted something more profound than she probably intended.
“We shouldn’t discriminate against people because of who they love.”
I agree wholeheartedly. The pertinent question, to paraphrase her husband, is what the meaning of “who” is.
Indiana’s legislature passed a law Thursday reportedly modeled after the one that a nearly unanimous U.S. Congress passed and President Bill Clinton signed two decades ago. The 1993 act was reaction to a U.S. Supreme Court ruling against Native Americans’ use of peyote in, and access to sacred land for, their religious rituals.
It affirmed that the constitutional right to the free exercise of religion cannot be infringed unless there is a “compelling government interest.”
But a 1997 Supreme Court decision weakened the law’s applicability to states and municipalities, so over the years states have passed their own versions of the “RFRA.” Last week Indiana became the 20th to do so.
Other states have religious protections arising from state court decisions on issues ranging from Amish buggies to moose hunting for native funeral ceremonies.
Of course, today’s urgent social issue is not peyote or Amish buggies; it is same-sex marriage. At the heart of the conflict is that for the vast majority of us, marriage is inherently religious.
It is not exclusively religious, of course; it’s also about family, children, property, taxes, sharing the present and building a future. As some ceremonies warn, it is “not a state to be entered into lightly.” For those who do “enter” it, marriage frames all of life.
It is undoubtedly because of these profound ramifications, this all-encompassing quality, that most peoples throughout history have infused the marriage ceremony with sacred significance. Certainly those traditions that gave rise to our society and our form of government did.
But today the varied religions of our free society do not agree on the morality of same-sex marriage.
What religious conservatives must recognize is that whether they approve or not, same-sex relationships and families do exist, and the state does have a compelling interest in ensuring that these marriages and families enjoy the same liberties and protections that heterosexuals and their children do.
And what same-sex marriage supporters must recognize is that the state has no compelling interest in choosing one religious doctrine over another or in forcing people to participate in religious ceremonies with which they disagree.
Here’s where Mrs. Clinton’s accidentally profound tweet re-enters the argument: “We shouldn’t discriminate against people because of who they love.”
But that’s already happening to people whose religious convictions prevent them from participating in gay marriages.
Florist Barronelle Stutzman is the latest. She was fined $1,001 Friday by the state of Washington for refusing to provide flowers for a same-sex wedding in 2013. But that fine is just the beginning of her financial woes.
Mrs. Stutzman had been serving customer Rob Ingersoll for nine years, knowing he was gay and providing the flowers he sent to his partner. But when he decided to marry and asked her to do the floral arrangements for the wedding, she hesitated.
“As much as I love Rob, I just couldn’t,” she said.
As much as Mrs. Stutzman loves Rob, she loves her God more. In her strict Southern Baptist religion, “marriage is a sacred covenant” that represents the holy union between Jesus and the church. She “couldn’t be part of” a wedding that would not conform to that model.
Mr. Ingersoll’s partner shared the story on social media, prompting the state attorney general to seek the fine. But the couple have also sued — both her business and her personally, putting everything she owns at risk.
“Coercing someone to engage in expression,” noted her attorney Kristen Waggoner, is unconstitutional.
Even though there are florists whose God does not require abstaining from same-sex weddings, the number of cases like Mrs. Stutzman’s continues to grow, involving bakers, photographers and even ministers.
They illustrate why state laws like the federal one Ms. Clinton’s husband long ago signed are necessary. If the Indiana law goes farther than protections for religious ceremonies and allows discrimination against gays in normal business exchanges, then the law needs to be revisited — and its Christian supporters, at least, need to think hard on the “What Would Jesus Do” theme.
Wherever we stand and whomever we love — human or divine — we should be mature and open-minded enough to allow diversity of views on such a fundamental matter as marriage.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.