Here’s the only thing most citizens can probably agree on in these early days of chewing over Gov. Tom Wolf’s proposed state budget: Imposing a tax on catalogs wouldn’t be too terrible.
They say we wind up with less of anything we tax, so most of us wouldn’t mourn a heavy levy on junk mail. (Or committee meetings.)
That’s just about it. Oh, there probably wouldn’t be much opposition to a tax on the sale of racehorses either, since that affects, what, maybe seven or eight people statewide?
Racehorses and catalogs — yes, by all means, go ahead and tax those.
Of course, the catalog lobby will oppose this idea, just as the newspaper industry will oppose taxes on newspapers and the funeral industry will denounce taxes on caskets, tombstones and “death care.”
But one way or another — through category expansion, rate increase or both — we can be reasonably certain our taxes are going up, and we have no one to blame but ourselves.
It’s what we asked for last November.
Poor Tom Corbett spent four years being reviled for the cuts he and the Legislature imposed in an attempt to reverse the state’s serious fiscal woes, but he touched the untouchable — education — and let the fracking frackers off too easy.
But just because Gov. Corbett got it wrong doesn’t mean this new direction gets it right. In Mr. Wolf’s approach there are the tax traps we see and more we don’t.
For starters, the education industry has risen up as one to applaud the restoration of education spending — as if inadequate funding were the primary cause of poor student performance anywhere.
Adequate funding and fair funding do matter — very much — but they are no magic bullets. It matters greatly how school districts spend the money they do get, and it matters even more what’s happening in our students’ homes.
Those are both highly local challenges.
In Mr. Wolf’s vision, the way we fund education — not just the amount — would be radically altered, shifting away from property taxes to state income taxes (which would rise) and to taxes on goods and services (which would increase both in rate and in number of items taxed).
Such a significant change will require long and detailed discussion, of course, but the early sales pitch from the Wolf administration is that the new approach would be fairer. It would lessen the burden on low- and fixed-income people, who are hit harder than others by high property taxes.
The big problem is that the state can’t control what millage our local school districts impose — and decades of experience should have taught us by now that any reprieve we get from our school districts, in response to the state’s increases would be short-lived.
There are other ways in which the Wolf proposal fails its own progressive-versus-regressive test.
Taxes on diapers and child care? Those hit low-income and young families especially hard, and taxing day care, in particular, almost seems like a disincentive to work.
Taxes on personal hygiene items and non-prescription medicine also hit low-income people harder, and those are very nearly as necessary to life as untaxed foods are.
The new taxes have another enormous downside: They favor big corporations over small businesses.
Large enterprises of all kinds — big law firms, accounting outfits, funeral home chains — are far more likely to already have the staff capacity to process taxes for the state.
For the small Main Street businesses that are the backbone of the American economy, though, the hiring of one new employee can be a make-or-break decision. The need to collect, report and forward taxes to the commonwealth is an as-yet unconsidered administrative cost — one that will have to be passed on to us consumers.
No matter how big or small the company we use, we can count on paying more for those services — and the new taxes on them, too.
The biggest long-term cost to taxpayers, however, is hidden in Harrisburg: Expanded and higher taxes will necessarily increase the government’s size, since the Department of Revenue would need many new employees to handle all those new taxes.
And once it’s expanded, state government pretty much never shrinks.
This budget may be “dead on arrival,” but by asking for so much, Mr. Wolf has given our weak-willed Republican Legislature plenty of room to maneuver. They can do less than proposed and still increase the funds flowing to Harrisburg.
We don’t stand a chance.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.