I had saved a news story on Pope Francis from mid-January, thinking that when the time was right, I’d revisit his thoughts on limitations to our freedom of speech.
This seems a good time to me, given some blowback from last week’s column, which I think was justified. The blowback, that is: How ironic to write a column on the need to choose our words carefully and fail so significantly with one careless word!
I’m afraid my clarification will not mollify some, but it’s worth the effort to reach people of good will because the subject at hand, then and now, is really critical: The narrative we construct about past failures and present perils will determine how we move forward as a people.
The pope’s January comments about voluntarily restraining our freedom of speech, even where the law doesn’t constrain us, came in the aftermath of the deadly terrorist assault on the Charlie Hebdo magazine in Paris.
If someone “says a curse word against my mother, he can expect a punch,” the pope said, with a mock-swing at the friend standing next to him.
“It’s normal. You cannot provoke. You cannot insult the faith of others. You cannot make fun of the faith of others.”
He made very clear that the satirical magazine’s cartoons taking swipes at the Prophet Mohammed did not justify in any way the murder of 11 employees. And the assailants’ killing of customers at a kosher market as their rampage continued indicates they didn’t need a specific taunt to incite them to murder.
But as I argued last week, in support of President Barack Obama’s cautious approach, gratuitously insulting Muslims won’t help build the interfaith, international coalition we need to combat the Islamic State’s extremists.
I’d saved the story on the pope because I had also just come across a brief article in a lightweight women’s magazine — a couple of paragraphs in a glorified catalogue, really— in which a fashion industry type’s comments on something like applying blush to celebrity faces opened with the exclamation, “Jesus!”
Was that really necessary? It’s not like this was an in-depth New Yorker profile where the subject’s language provides revealing insights into her character.
In a magazine piece a few years ago, a famous screenwriter bemoaned network prohibitions against using that same kind of language — words which are serious profanities to countless millions of people. Which raises the questions: Why is it so important to anyone to get to say certain words? What purpose does it serve? Is the gain greater than the goading?
There’s gratuitous provocation, and then there’s the purposeful kind. Provoking others to think, confronting someone else’s harmful speech or actions — those are sometimes necessary.
That was my goal last week in challenging those who insist President Bush knowingly lied to get the nation into war, despite the findings of the bipartisan Robb-Silberman Commission and the literal, abundant findings of WMDs by our troops. I shortened my original phrase, “the left’s lunatic wing,” to “the lunatic left,” which some interpreted as a description of the entire left-wing, rather than just those leftists who persist in their angry slander.
A year or so ago I similarly chastised the extreme right-wingers who still say Mr. Obama was not born on American soil. Why would anyone insist on such assertions, long past a reliable debunking? There are a few possible reasons: poorly processed anger, malicious intent for political gain, feebleness of mind.
Take your pick; I took mine, but I phrased it carelessly — no doubt alienating some of Pittsburgh’s plentiful, perfectly lovely left-wingers.
Mr. Bush doesn’t need my help; he’s been dealing graciously with the slander for years, as has Mr. Obama concerning his nationality. But what if these falsehoods are destructive to us as a people?
Judge Laurence Silberman, who chaired the special commission that investigated our intelligence capabilities and WMDs, recently wrote a Wall Street Journal piece deploring — correctly — that a high-profile reporter would casually assert the “President Bush lied” propaganda as fact.
He fears that the possibility of being defamed as a traitor if things go poorly may cause future leaders to hesitate before trusting our intelligence community in moments of crisis.
Do today’s leaders understand the threat of ISIS any better than our leaders understood the threat of radical Islamic terrorism in the aftermath of 9/11?
Some say not. History will be the judge, but that judgment won’t be worth much if we speak to ourselves now, and later, either carelessly or maliciously.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.