“You get 100 police officers in a room, and 95 of them will be very good.”

These are the words of a retired Pittsburgh detective — an African-American — but anyone who’s ever held a job knows he could be talking about almost any organization, anywhere.

Most of us are trying to play by the rules, be decent people and accomplish something good, whatever our pursuits, but there’s always a bad egg or two to contend with.

When those bad eggs happen to wear badges and carry guns, the implications for society are deadly serious.

Advertise with us

The retired detective’s words, heard in a public forum last month, sprang to mind as I watched the controversy unfold over Pittsburgh Police Chief Cameron McLay’s social media dust-up.

Those words returned because when Brian Johnson uttered them, my first thought was, “What’s being done about those five bad cops?”

Part of the answer might have been on Chief McLay’s sign. It was a protester’s sign, actually, that the police chief agreed to hold for a photograph on New Year’s Eve after he’d spent some time talking to activists. The sign read, “I resolve to challenge racism @ work” and “#end white silence.”

The photo hit social media, including Mayor Bill Peduto’s Facebook page.

“When I saw it on Facebook,” Mr. Johnson, the retired officer, told me when I called him Friday, “I thought it meant, ‘As a Caucasian, I will not be silent if and when I see racism.’ That’s it.”

Advertise with us

I had the same reaction, but I also thought, “Uh oh — here we go.”

And indeed, once the police union pushed back, asserting the chief’s action painted all cops as racists, the conflict got coverage locally, and then from New York and Washington, D.C., newspapers to Fox News and MSNBC.

On Thursday night, Mayor Peduto appeared on Bill O’Reilly’s Fox News show to address the matter. Both men did their respective jobs very well, our mayor being particularly skilled in reframing questions on his terms and articulating the complexity of the challenges our city and country face.

Fortunately, this isn’t “A Tale of Two Bills.” Despite the point-counterpoint — or, more encouragingly — perhaps because of the point-counterpoint, the two men found much to agree on.

As the mayor said early on, “For many white people, including myself, talking about race issues is sometimes difficult.”

Advertise with us

It is difficult because it’s fraught with so much emotion and so much moral weight. People come at it with highly individual mixes of guilt, anger, ideology, information, character and goodwill.

So, as the mayor and the pundit seemed to agree, Chief McLay “took a risk.” Mayor Peduto is right in saying this risk has opened a necessary dialogue and sent an important message to the city’s black community that “yes, we’re listening.”

But part of the risk has not, I believe, been fully articulated.

The sign, when held by a police chief in the context of current unrest, risks implying that racism is the only problem, or is the primary problem, in his workplace.

The region’s litany of lawsuits, expensive settlements and many sad news stories illustrate that bullying, domestic abuse, fabrication of evidence and other character flaws can be at play in any given police conflict.

Advertise with us

As Mr. Johnson observed, “Whatever frailties you have before you become an officer, those don’t go away just because you put on a badge.”

The chief’s social media moment also risks furthering a controversial narrative that racism is the primary problem behind disproportionately high black crime statistics, in general, and the cause, specifically, of confrontations that have ended in tragedy.

What if the problem is the failed war on drugs or too much pressure on picayune infractions? What if the bigger problem is not character but policy?

My retired officer friend urged renewed commitment to “open, clear investigations” whenever police conduct is questioned. “Ninety percent of the time it will clear the officer,” Mr. Johnson said. “Ten percent of the time it will reveal someone who should not be a cop.”

What is being done now, before there’s another tragedy, no matter the cause?

Advertise with us

“Pittsburgh is a small enough city, with only 900 officers,” Mr. Peduto said to Mr. O’Reilly, “that you can work on it on an individual basis.”

How wise! Social movements may heighten our awareness, but change is most effective and fair when the broad brush is set aside for the nitty-gritty one-on-one.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com