The everyday battle to get through life is drama enough for most of us. We don’t need endlessly simmering war to drain us further.
Conflict is especially wearying if it is exaggerated or flat-out invented just so our pain will become someone else’s gain.
Take the “war on women” — please. It seemed, finally, that manipulation of the ages-old battle of the sexes had perhaps whimpered its last in American politics when last-ditch appeals to it in the 2014 election failed to attract the female vote.
But fast on the heels of the election came the notorious Rolling Stone article detailing a gang rape in a University of Virginia fraternity house. The story provoked outraged demands for harsh consequences and for renewed attention to the supposed “rape culture” on American campuses.
Just as quickly, though, other journalists started digging more deeply into the alleged rape — digging that the reporter, a woman, should have done — demonstrating that many key elements of the story were false.
Also last month the U.S. Department of Justice released a report titled “Rape and Sexual Assault Victimization Among College-Age Women, 1995-2013.” Analysts had already debunked the “1 in 5 college women will be assaulted” myth, and the new report confirms the debunking: The rate of assault for female students over the 18-year study was 6.1 in 1,000, compared to 7.8 in 1,000 for non-students.
The next lurch on the gender-war roller coaster? Spring will bring the annual “gender wage gap” brouhaha from the usual suspects, who claim that women’s persistently lower overall earnings are evidence of rampant sex discrimination.
At this point we should ask whether the “war on women” is actually being waged by other women, not men, and that rather than helping women, these self-appointed warriors are actually hurting us.
The reporter who so bungled the Rolling Stone story is a woman who struck the victim’s friends — female friends — as having an agenda so pronounced it made them uncomfortable.
Rape is a very destructive, serious crime. I know firsthand: My immediate family includes a rape survivor who still struggles, at times, years after the fact.
Invented stories do not help address a grave social ill. Also unhelpful? An old, widely cited study — from the White House on down — that counted attempted kisses, nonphysical pressure to have sex, unwanted touching and alcohol- or drug-influenced sex as “sexual assaults.”
Are women not smart enough or honest enough to see differences among these actions and judge them differently?
Of course we are — except for the small band of activists whose livelihood or self-definition depends upon galvanizing political action and eliciting donations.
By the way, the December 2014 DOJ report does not use an absurdly broad definition of “sexual assault.” That’s why its numbers are much lower and somewhat reassuring. Don’t expect to see them cited by women’s interest groups.
As for the gender wage gap, statisticians have been able for at least a decade now to dig deep into income data, breaking the workforce down by industry, position, years of service and job holders’ varied experience and educational backgrounds.
When they adjust for these varying factors, the wage gap in most fields all but disappears.
A year or two into a job I once held, I realized the handful of men doing exactly the same job as mine were being paid significantly more — about $5,000 per year more. When I complained, my female manager refused to address it and threatened my position; it was her male superior who made it right.
So I know true wage disparity matters when it crops up. But telling complicated truths about these complicated conflicts — and doing it calmly — matters too.
It matters that women at the White House earn less than men, as GOP activists love to point out — but it also matters if the men who occupy more high-ranking, better-paid positions do so because they’re more experienced.
Making up stories, distorting legitimate but increasingly rare instances of unequal pay into chronic social ills, undermining the serious nature of real assault by equating it with unwanted sexual attention — all these do more harm than good to real women’s lives.
That’s because when the excesses and fabrications come to light, it makes it easier for ill-wishers or the merely battle-weary to dismiss women’s legitimate claims.
Such tactics also needlessly alienate millions of good men — people with whom most of us women would prefer to happily, respectfully get along.
Maybe in the “war on women” it’s time to declare the peace.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.