The teenagers, lanky African-American boys, might have lounged casually in their chairs at times during the 90-minute talk, but their attention never flagged. Their eyes remained watchful, especially when the police officers spoke.
Perhaps because the officers were black, too, and have faced the same suspicions.
Brian Johnson is a retired homicide detective from the Pittsburgh police. Two decades ago, he had already served as an Air Force firefighter and had recently taken the police academy entrance exam. He was walking the three blocks from his Homewood residence to the hospital emergency room where he volunteered when an unmarked car pulled up next to him and four officers forced him up against a wall.
“I knew who they were” — members of an anti-gang task force — “but you don’t say anything. … They never explained themselves, they just said, ‘It’s not him,’ and drove away.
“That incident shaped my career as a police officer,” Mr. Johnson said. “That kind of incident causes other people not to trust.”
He knows what it feels like on both sides of the “thin blue line.”
I don’t — white, female, a civilian — nor did the majority of those riveted by his story. It was the first thing shared Thursday night in a forum dubbed “Beyond Sound Bites” at Cityview Church of the North Side.
Co-pastors Leeann and Wayne Younger had invited a fascinating array — black and white, pastors, an athletics coach, defense attorney, cops — to lead a “conversation about law enforcement, race, class and youth,” and at least 70 people — white, black, young and old — turned out to listen.
If I could wave a magic wand, churches and town halls all over America would be filled with gatherings like this one.
Each panelist made a unique contribution, but given the recent deaths of Michael Brown, Eric Garner and 12-year-old Tamir Rice in police incidents, the black officers’ observations were particularly compelling.
Pastor Leeann asked them, “What do you wish the public knew about policing?”
Retired city police detective Sheldon Williams, an Air National Guard reservist and pastor at Allegheny Center Alliance Church, said, “It’s about three things: gaining, maintaining or regaining control of a situation.
“The average citizen hates to be told what to do,” he said. If someone resists, if the situation escalates “and an officer calls for help, the No. 1 priority of the officers who respond” is to help their colleague.
“The officer could be 100 percent wrong. … You can sort it out later on.”
“You have to make decisions in seconds,” Mr. Johnson added. “You will be second-guessed for the rest of your life.”
When asked about concerns with the “over-militarization” of the police, the officers did not regret that alleged trend.
“We have to respond to a wide range of situations,” Mr. Johnson observed, while his colleague cited the April 2009 murder of three city police officers in Stanton Heights.
“[Richard Poplawski] was armed for war,” Mr. Williams said, recalling the killer’s weaponry and the length of the siege. “I had to watch three colleagues bleed to death.”
Noting that Poplawski is white, “people ask, ‘How did he come out alive?’ Well, he surrendered.
“Listen,” he said, “every officer there wanted to put a bullet through his head, including me, and I’m a pastor, but he surrendered.”
With this raising of the ever-present issues of racism, policing and tragic outcomes, conversation moved quickly to Eric Garner, who died after police tried to arrest him for illegally selling cigarettes.
“You’ve got a guy who’s 6-foot-3 and 300 pounds, and you wrestle him?” Mr. Johnson mused. “A more effective tactic would have been pepper spray.”
Since polls show that a majority of Americans, black and white, disagree with the grand jury’s failure to indict the officer who allegedly applied an unlawful chokehold, the story isn’t likely to end there.
“I’ll be shocked if we don’t see a lawsuit” soon, Mr. Williams said, based on violations of Mr. Garner’s Fourth Amendment rights.
Both men urged their listeners to forge relationships with the officers who patrol their neighborhoods.
If we build relationships, then when there’s a controversial incident, “the reaction is not ‘Let’s protest’; it’s, ‘Let’s find out what happened,’ ” Mr. Johnson said to me later.
I looked at the diverse audience and thought, “Cityview Church is changing lives here, maybe saving some.”
“We could have talked all night,” Mr. Johnson said to me. “Those were big questions that don’t have simple answers.”
What I’ve shared, however, is the easier part. Next week, barring the unforeseen, I’ll dig into the touchier areas we covered — racism and white privilege — and, more fascinating to me, what we left unsaid.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.