Just days before 17-year-old Malala Yousafzai won the Nobel Peace Prize, some well-known Americans tested the modern limits of civil discourse: They argued on a prominent TV show, to considerable pushback, about whether it’s possible to criticize bad ideas (specifically, “bad” Muslim teachings) without being accused of bigotry toward those (that is, Muslims) who espouse those bad ideas.

For merely discussing the matter, some have called them racists.

The Nobel Committee sidestepped such an argument and simply, powerfully proclaimed the supremacy of noble ideals when it announced the Peace Prize on Friday. Sharing the prize with Malala, a Pakistani Muslim, is Kailash Satyarthi, 60, an Indian Hindu who campaigns against child trafficking and labor.

The Nobel Committee “regards it as an important point for a Hindu and a Muslim, an Indian and a Pakistani, to join in a common struggle for education and against extremism,” its chairman said.

Advertise with us

That is, they applauded people of different faiths and nationalities for espousing the same principles of human liberty.

But there’s an important difference in the prize winners’ work: While Mr. Satyarthi’s 35-year-long effort seeks to counter destructive forces of international commerce, Malala’s struggle is very close to home and pits her against the religious practice of some of her own fellow Muslims.

Two years ago this month, Malala was shot in the head by a gunman who asked for her by name as she boarded a school bus in northwest Pakistan. The local Taliban were trying to bar girls from school and targeted her for leading the resistance.

Is it possible to condemn a tenet of radical Islam (or any other belief) without being accused of bigotry? It should be, but it probably doesn’t help matters when someone opens the dialogue by calling Islam “the mother lode of bad ideas.”

Aside from that inflammatory remark from renowned atheist Sam Harris, however, the recent discussion on HBO’s “Real Time With Bill Maher” — one week before Malala became the youngest Nobel Prize winner ever — was a mesmerizing example of colliding values being publicly dissected. It’s worth looking up and watching online. It will have you talking back to the screen.

Advertise with us

The show brought host Bill Maher and Mr. Harris together with New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof, former National Republican Committee chairman Michael Steele and actor/​director/​activist Ben Affleck.

Mr. Harris noted early on the “intellectually ridiculous” fact that “every criticism of the doctrine of Islam gets conflated with bigotry toward Muslims as people.” Protecting the right to engage thorny issues is, these days, no small thing.

But the conversation reached a weird dead-end when a consensus seemingly emerged. Mr. Kristof said, “The great divide is not between Islam and [other religions], it’s rather between the fundamentalists and moderates in each faith.” He and Mr. Steele spoke forcefully of the brave moderate Muslims who are risking their lives to publicly oppose murderous radicals.

Mr. Maher noted that in our day it is only radical Muslims who want to kill those who disagree with them, but 400 years ago the practice was still commonplace in so-called “Christendom.” What happened to change that reality? The answer points to a modern solution for Islam’s great divide.

Mr. Harris said, “There are hundreds of millions of Muslims who are nominal Muslims who don’t take the faith seriously, who don’t want to kill apostates, who are horrified by ISIS. We need to defend these people … and let them reform their [unintelligible].” Their faith? Their nations? Yes, and in that order.

Advertise with us

What changed death-for-dissidents in Christendom was that passionate Christians — from John Wycliffe to Martin Luther to Roger Williams — who took their faith very seriously indeed found within it the sanctity of individual conscience. From Luther’s “liberty of conscience” came Williams’ “wall of separation” between church and state.

Even Bertrand Russell, godfather (forgive me) to today’s professional atheists, argued that Christian reformers gave birth to the Enlightenment. In other words, John Locke, Thomas Jefferson and others borrowed Christian ideas and stripped the Christian vocabulary so as to offend none, least of all themselves.

Muslim reformers must find the seeds of liberty inside their own scriptures and persuade, not just vanquish, the opposition. They must separate mosque from state.

The human impulse to force others to conform to one’s beliefs respects no dogma: Today’s secular Puritans want to punish you for driving too big a car or biggie-sizing your Coke.

If the Muslim world discovers liberty within its own faith tradition, it will find — as we have — a less bloody but never-ending battle.