The floor of the gymnasium at the Harry S. Truman Elementary School was dusty brown. Or so I seem to remember.

You'd think I'd have a clearer picture of it fixed in my mind since I spent so much time sitting there cross-legged -- 45 minutes every Friday, during winter, for six years. Alone.

Monday to Thursday, we had music or gym on alternate days, but on Fridays we spent that period either outside playing, if the Great Plains' weather allowed, or inside square-dancing, which my father did not.

I was the child of religious dissenters. Dancing of any kind was forbidden. So each fall, on the first foul-weather Friday, I'd submit the letter from my parents requesting that I be excused from all dancing for the rest of the year.

Advertise with us

The punishment varied. My favorite gym teachers -- they came and went -- let me climb the stairs to the library that filled the gymnasium's stage. That wasn't punishment at all.

But some teachers couldn't abide my nonparticipation: They seemed to interpret any difference of opinion as condemnation of their own, and they reacted angrily. One year I was required to spend dance period copying all the rules of every game children might conceivably play -- dodgeball, kickball, softball, tetherball -- from a hefty tome onto endless 3x5 cards.

The worst was the year I was forbidden to do anything but stare into space. That was torture. But I had it easy compared with my big sister. As a first-grader, she'd been forced to jump rope in the hall for an hour while the older kids on their way to lunch taunted her mercilessly.

When she finally told my parents about it, after coming home crying for the umpteenth time, my dad sped to the school, confronted the gym teacher and principal, and gave them quite a piece of his very considerable mind.

Five years later that gym teacher was my principal. He went easier on me than on my sister, but at every annual Pancake Breakfast day, he stepped around our family to avoid shaking my father's hand.

Advertise with us

•

All this dusty history sprang back to life when I heard about "N.B.," the 13-year-old student in the Brownsville Area School District who was punished for refusing to stand and recite the Pledge of Allegiance.

One morning in mid-April, when N.B. first chose to sit quietly during the pledge, the homeroom teacher asked her to stand and then "admonished [her] in front of the entire class, with references to her disrespect for all the soldiers dying for her overseas," according to a lawsuit filed on her behalf by the American Civil Liberties Union.

N.B. was given a lunch detention and in-school suspensions. Her mother protested, but the principal and then the school board upheld this discipline. The lawsuit was settled the day it was filed -- as soon as the school solicitor became involved.

I'm amazed anyone could become an administrator without studying something as important as students' constitutional rights. The Supreme Court decision protecting N.B.'s dissent has been around since 1943 -- a West Virginia case involving the right of Jehovah's Witnesses not to say the pledge.

Advertise with us

Some of my classmates were Witnesses. I don't remember if they sat or stood each day, but they remained silent, and they weren't harassed. (Not dancing is apparently a far worse crime than not saying the pledge.) We talked on the bus from time to time, comparing notes, answering other kids' occasional questions.

That's one of the gifts of dissent, even if it springs from your parents' choices: You learn far earlier than your peers to reflect upon belief, the nature of authority, the role an individual plays in shaping the surrounding community -- and how that community shapes, and perhaps scars, the individual.

N.B.'s choice to abstain is apparently not religious. Though she wants to keep her reasons personal, an ACLU legal fellow said, "Due to the state of the country right now, she doesn't feel she can stand for the pledge."

It's sad that disappointment with our nation prevents a profession of allegiance to its ideals. With government as with religion, we uphold the ideal while we sometimes deplore current practice -- including our own.

Ironically, N.B.'s lawsuit demonstrates the strength of our system. Despite some individuals' failures, she received due process -- with reassuring speed. The only issue left unresolved is "monetary damages."

Advertise with us

Dear N.B., unless you need counseling -- and I know firsthand this stuff is painful -- don't ask for damages: That punishes the whole community, not the officials responsible. You have the moral high ground. Stay there.

You're a 13-year-old who's already thinking for herself: Even before the settlement, you had already won.