The choices on display in this year's presidential campaign represent factions as old as the European colonists' arrival in North America. It's the Puritans vs. the Liberals all over again.
But that's only among the Republicans. The few true liberals remaining in the Democratic Party -- people who believe in the rights of the individual and fight against an all-powerful state -- are the "blue dogs" who haven't been heard from since their anti-Obamacare whimpers died away.
The ongoing triumph of the leftist, statist wing in driving the Democratic agenda is a given -- given the incumbency of Barack Obama. With his "affordable" health care reform and unprecedented use of policy czars, President Obama leads the march to a vast nanny state. The road to serfdom is apparently a shovel-ready project.
No, the real contest of visions is on the right, where the two frontrunners, Mitt Romney and Rick Santorum, have galvanized interest in areas of personal liberty -- economic, moral and cultural -- with their mishmash of positions and personas.
Mr. Romney is a religious conservative with a big-government, big-business past. He's a devout Mormon who governed the left-leaning state of Massachusetts with a big-government agenda, after making his fortune in private equity.
Mr. Santorum is a religious conservative with small-government leanings and almost no business past. He's a devout Catholic who worked briefly as a lawyer before running for Congress and whose 16 years of service in the U.S. House and Senate segued smoothly into work as a D.C. lobbyist.
So which man is the Puritan candidate and which the Liberal? (I'm using "liberal" in its noble, classical sense, before it became a dirty word.) Though they share some ideals, Mr. Santorum has emerged as the Puritan candidate -- he just makes it so easy -- and Mr. Romney as the Liberal (in both the classical and the modern, twisted meaning).
Puritans and liberals started out as co-religionists, coming to the New World on the same ships. They split within years of arriving, though, because the Puritans who'd fled religious persecution in England soon began practicing it here -- punishing colonists for working on the Sabbath and denying nonbelievers the right to vote.
Roger Williams, a disillusioned Puritan, bought land from the native tribes, rather than seizing it, and established a colony (the future Rhode Island) to provide a sanctuary for those fleeing the Puritans or any other oppressor.
America has fitfully followed Mr. Williams' lead. His books, the first to envision a "wall of separation" between church and state, were published in London and influenced John Locke, Thomas Jefferson's guiding light. American liberalism sprang from these twin sources, Reformation and Enlightenment.
While the goal of liberty and justice for all has inspired battles across the political spectrum -- for abolition, desegregation and workers' rights, for instance -- Puritanical tendencies still crop up, also across the political spectrum.
Mr. Santorum proposed contraception as a source of social decay months before the contraception-mandate conflict, making concerns about his devotion to personal liberty far-fetched but not groundless. His recent claim that he "almost threw up" when he read John F. Kennedy's pivotal 1960 speech on the separation of church and state virtually invites opponents to claim he'd seek to impose his religion on others.
But what about the Puritanism of the Left? At February's National Prayer Breakfast, President Obama cited Jesus' teachings as inspiration for raising taxes on the rich. This did not surprise those already wary of the 20-some years he spent under the Rev. Jeremiah Wright's Marxism-infused "black liberation theology."
And who can ignore the religious subtext of aggressive environmentalism? The sun is god, the heat of its wrath envelops the globe and it must be appeased by recycling, simpler living and the purchase of conscience-clearing carbon offsets.
"Puritanical" is shorthand for oppressive, and it comes in many guises. Whether the inspiration is old-school religion or new-age, whether the policy involves social values or tax rates, overbearing politicians make live-and-let-live Americans -- the election-deciding center -- uneasy. The candidate who can persuade voters that he fully understands and embraces liberty on every front is the one who can win centrist voters and thus the White House.
Mr. Santorum's economic prescriptions lean toward Main Street and the little guy, while Mr. Romney can better reassure voters that his religion will not dictate his policies. Take the liberty-loving half of each man, put 'em together and the GOP would have one strong candidate.
Failing that, the eventual nominee will be selecting a running mate who gets the area of liberty he doesn't -- a person he can introduce to the public by saying, "You complete me."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.