As necessary and welcome as Rush Limbaugh's apology to Sandra Fluke is, there's a bigger victim of his ill-chosen remarks still waiting for the situation to be set right -- if it can be.

This victim is not an individual but a potentially huge group: It's the broad, diverse coalition of citizens worried about the loss of liberty, whether economic or religious, that a second term for Barack Obama will undoubtedly bring.

Even before Mr. Limbaugh's tasteless tirade on Ms. Fluke's sexual activities, it had been an uphill battle to frame the federal mandate for employer-provided birth control as the assault on liberty that it is. That's partly because the visuals were wrong: The conflict pitted the relatively young, attractive Obama administration against the older, scandal-plagued, all-male leadership of the Roman Catholic Church.

And it's partly because most individuals, regardless of their religious inclinations, appreciate the availability of modern birth control and find it difficult to passionately defend a philosophical principle when they can't defend the real-world practice it supports.

Advertise with us

Organized religious conservatives, however, could be counted on to see the constitutional principle now at risk and to speak up for the Catholic Church's right to practice its own doctrine. In an age of one-minute network news stories and cable television's distortion-as-debate, the nuance of shared principle but different practice would be lost, and all the big, bad Puritans and Inquisition throwbacks would be melded into one scary, woman-hating monster.

As Mr. Limbaugh himself had pointed out, that's exactly what the White House wanted. It can't defend its economic record -- the recession and jobless numbers now belong solely to Mr. Obama -- so it needed to shift the campaign focus to social values.

The Obama administration engineered the conflict, Mr. Limbaugh argued, to shape the Republican primary, knowing it could rely on its media handmaidens to frame the issue in its favor -- to turn the conversation away from Obamacare's real threat to liberty and toward the Republicans' fantastical one.

And the mainstream media complied, with George Stephanopoulos at the forefront grilling Rick Santorum on whether he approves of contraception, not on whether anyone should be forced to buy someone else's birth-control pills.

Days later, despite Mr. Limbaugh's astute analysis of the situation, he fell into the very trap he'd described the White House laying.

Advertise with us

Due to partisan wrangling over rules, a young, female Georgetown law student named Sandra Fluke was denied the opportunity to address the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform in mid-February. When she did give her testimony later to a Democrats-only hearing, she described a friend's need for oral contraception to fight ovarian cysts and argued that the Catholic university should have to cover the $1,000-per-year, per-student cost.

The unremarkable episode quickly passed from the political scene but was revived when Mr. Limbaugh called her a "slut" and challenged her to tape the sex that taxpayers would now be subsidizing. That's how he cast himself in the role of scary, woman-hating monster -- without any help from the Left.

Why take that route when tongue-in-cheek barbs could have been launched from many angles? He could have conducted a fundraising drive for Ms. Fluke -- to prove that liberty-loving conservatives can always be counted on to meet human need through private charity! "Coins for Condoms," "Pennies for Pills," "Freebies for Fluke" -- silly slogans sure to paint the Left's insistence that free birth control is a fundamental right, trumping the free exercise of religion, as the ridiculous assertion it is.

Instead, Mr. Limbaugh made it about himself. He provided the Left with the mean, right-wing bogeyman it always needs. And he may have done long-lasting damage.

Who pays the price if the debate over the free contraception mandate doesn't return to its crux of religious and economic liberty?

Advertise with us

Ms. Fluke won't suffer at all. She's a left-wing heroine!

Mr. Limbaugh has paid -- through lost advertising and widespread rebuke.

But the biggest victim in all this is the broad coalition of fiscal conservatives -- whether independents, tea partyers or Republicans -- who fear the Obama administration's oppressive over-reach. To win re-election, the president must split this coalition. His task becomes much easier when fiscal conservatives can't stand to be associated with the "scary, woman-hating monsters" on the right -- an old smear that Mr. Limbaugh just reinforced.