Hard on the heels of the free contraception controversy comes news on another "culture war" battlefront: same-sex marriage. The conflict could roil the 2012 presidential campaign and test national civility for years to come. But it doesn't have to be this way.

Gov. Christine Gregoire signed a bill last Monday making Washington the seventh state to legalize gay marriage. But on Friday in New Jersey, Gov. Chris Christie vetoed a bill passed by the Democratic-controlled Legislature that would have made his state the eighth.

Instead, the eighth state to legalize same-sex marriage may soon be Maryland, where former vice president Dick Cheney reportedly lobbied Republican state legislators to help pass the bill Friday -- a similar version of which passed the state senate last year.

While the Obama administration's not-really-revised policy on faith-based institutions and "free" contraception trained a spotlight primarily on the Roman Catholic Church, the ongoing debate on same-sex marriage cuts across religious and political lines. Govs. Gregoire and Christie, for instance, are both Catholic, but Mr. Cheney is Methodist; Ms. Gregoire is a Democrat, but the two men are Republicans.

Advertise with us

With allegiances on the matter often unpredictable and with 30 states having passed constitutional amendments defining marriage as heterosexual only, plenty of conflict is yet to come. If the nation is lucky, many citizens will soon conclude that both sides in this particular conflict are wrong.

There is an alternative approach to the issue -- an approach that avoids unequal legal status on one hand and religious oppression on the other. The discussion in New Jersey -- and experience in California and D.C. -- together point the way.

With his veto, Mr. Christie made two interesting proposals: that citizens decide, via statewide ballot, whether to permit same-sex marriage and that the Legislature, in the meantime, appoint a "strong ombudsman for civil unions."

The Garden State already offers civil unions to same-sex couples, but a review commission has found the law less than effective, and several couples have sued, contending it does not deliver the "marriage equality" that the state Supreme Court had mandated.

While demonstrating problems with how the civil union law is put into practice is certainly a strong strategy, the point of a same-sex marriage bill is that no matter how carefully civil unions are observed, a "separate but equal" approach to marriage is not, in the end, equal at all.

Advertise with us

But some jurisdictions that have passed same-sex marriage laws have created a new group of second-class citizens -- religious conservatives.

When the District of Columbia's council took up a same-sex marriage bill in 2009, the American Civil Liberties Union joined others in urging the council to provide a religious exemption, but the council refused, insisting their intent was to require that "every third party" recognize same-sex marriage as legitimate.

Although black Protestants had also prominently opposed the law, the consequences are easiest to measure through the experience of the Catholic Church. Catholic Charities had to end its 80-year-old foster care program rather than be forced to violate its doctrine by placing children with gay couples, and it discontinued health insurance for its employees rather than be required to extend benefits to gay spouses.

New Jersey's vetoed bill did have an exemption clause -- no clergy would be required to perform gay marriages and places of worship would not have to allow same-sex weddings at their facilities -- but situations such as Catholic Charities faced in D.C. (and in Boston) would not have been prevented.

The way out of this irreconcilable conflict between individual liberty and the free exercise of religion is for government to offer civil unions only, for all citizens, regardless of their sexual orientation, and to leave "marriage" to the church, temple, synagogue or mosque -- where it has been administered for millennia.

Advertise with us

The Catholic Church's experience in California indicates that this approach will work. When San Francisco passed "domestic partnership" legislation a decade before the D.C. bill, the diocese simply offered insurance to a "second adult" in the household, regardless of relationship.

It is some governments' insistence on forcing religious institutions to redefine "marriage" -- which is either a rite or a sacrament of the church, predating any nation's existence -- that violates the Constitution's "free exercise" clause. "Civil unions" for all would sidestep most, if not all, of these conflicts.

The desire to force others to assent to one's version of the truth is a stubborn human trait. It's also a hallmark of the intellectually or emotionally insecure. Whether Americans embrace this mutually respectful solution to our conflict of visions will test our civic maturity.