Americans in their 50s — the heart of Generation X, people born from 1965 to 1980 — are working like never before. Their employment-population ratio hit an all-time high in September and remained pretty close in February, while the ratio for so-called prime-age workers 25 through 54 remains quite high, too, but below the record levels of the late 1990s.

Why is this happening?

Boomers vs. Gen X

Workers older than 65 left the labor force in large numbers during a pandemic that was especially dangerous for them. Those just younger than 65 might have been more likely to stick with their jobs because employers were suddenly short on experienced workers. The low-hire, low-fire labor market of the past couple of years also rewards experience.

Other possible causes of Gen X labor-market outperformance include early exposure to labor market instability that may have made them better at bouncing back from setbacks than earlier generations were, and rising medical costs and Obamacare cutbacks that have made it ever more important to hold on to jobs that offer health insurance until they turn 65 and can go on Medicare.

Advertise with us

Finally, the rise of defined-contribution retirement plans brings incentives for working longer (to make sure your money doesn’t run out) that old-style pensions did not, although most baby boomers don’t have pensions either.

Stagnant wages

Generations are admittedly somewhat dodgy concepts. Still, if you look at the population of Americans in their 50s, which the US Bureau of Labor Statistics estimates on a somewhat herky-jerky monthly basis, there was a pretty significant trend reversal about a decade ago when members of Generation X began turning 50. There are nearly 5 million fewer people in that age group now than in early 2016.

One key concept here is substitutability. Few if any jobs are only held by people in their 50s. The question is whether there’s a shortage of people who can do the jobs that people in their 50s tend to be doing.

In a paper published in 2020, two University of California economists  found that it was the size of older cohorts (50–59 and 60–69) relative to the youngest cohort (16–24) that seemed to matter, possibly because older workers often transition into “more flexible, lower-paying work” that can also be done by new entrants to the labor force.

The estimated US 16–24 population fell during the 2010s but has risen since, so it’s a little hard to know what to make of that. The impact of the departure of 65-and-older workers from the labor force during the pandemic seems clearer.

Advertise with us

But if it’s relative scarcity that’s driving up employment for Generation X, you’d think their wages would be rising, too, and BLS statistics on median weekly wages for the 45–54 age group (it doesn’t publish them for ages 50–59) show a smaller wage premium since Gen Xers began entering that age group than before.

Women in the workforce

Another important variable is gender, with the huge increase in women’s labor-force participation from the 1950s through 1990s doing a lot to shape overall employment and labor-force participation rates. The employment to population ratio for women in their 50s is higher than ever. For men, it’s higher than it has been in quite a while but still markedly lower than in the 1970s.

Because of some combination of lower working hours, different kinds of jobs and unfair discrimination, older women workers earn 20% to 25% less per week than older men, so part of what we’re seeing with the declining wage premium may just be the shifting gender composition of the older workforce.

Another possibility is that Gen Xers’ low expectations explain both their impressive employment rates and less-impressive pay. “McJob” was another durable term to emerge from Coupland’s novel. But today’s Gen-X-led households are much wealthier on average than baby-boomer-led households were at more or less the same age, but today there’s still a nearly $200,000 per individual estimated wealth gap.

A National Institute on Retirement Security study based on 2020 survey data found that the median Gen X household had just $40,000 in retirement savings and 28% had none at all. Many Gen Xers may be staying in the workforce because they can’t afford not to.

Advertise with us

Whatever the cause, it’s a generation that is undeniably still hard at work.

Justin Fox is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist and the author of “The Myth of the Rational Market.”