President Donald Trump’s comments on the Hyde Amendment, which bars federal funds from being used for abortion, is a historic departure for a Republican president.
“You have to be a little flexible on Hyde, you know that,” Trump told congressional Republicans at a retreat, urging them to make a deal with the Democrats. No Republican president has ever waffled on his support of it — until now.
Regardless of whether you find yourself on the pro-choice or pro-life side of the aisle, these are big and weighty issues dealing with vulnerable people that should not be decided on the back of budget deals or on political whims.
Trump’s new flexibility
For fifty years, the Hyde Amendment has stood as a bipartisan bulwark on abortion. It’s been the area — however humble — of deep political agreement on the emotional and divisive issue of undesired or untenable pregnancies.
It has remained constant as pro-lifers and pro-choicers sorted themselves into rival parties, as the Supreme Court did an about-face on Roe v. Wade, as states have adopted radically different abortion policies, through the advent of social media and polarization.
The amendment prevents federal funds from being used for abortions, save for a few exceptions: rape, incest and the mother’s life. It has been law since 1976, when following the 1973 Roe decision, federal Medicaid funds were being used to pay for around 300,000 abortions annually. Because the Hyde Amendment sits as a “rider” or an amendment to the annual appropriations bill for the Department of Health and Human Services, it must be passed every year.
And each year, Congress and the sitting president have done so without fail. President Obama and his trifecta Democratic government adhered to it. The Democratic-led Affordable Care Act explicitly stated that federal funds for insurance subsidies could not be used to pay for abortion, except in the standard Hyde exemptions.
To be sure, some blue states have created workarounds, allowing state taxpayer funds for abortions.
The reversal
Talk about a reversal. In 2022, thanks largely to Trump-appointed justices, the Supreme Court overturned Roe. Trump declared himself “proud to be the most pro-life president in American history.”
Pro-lifers understandably thought that they had won. Instead, the number of abortions post-Dobbs increased by 12%, reaching a decade high in 2023, according to the Guttmacher Institute.
For the first time, most Americans began identifying as pro-choice, increasing from a historic average of 41–50% to 55%. And in 2024, 23% of registered voters reported they would only vote for a pro-choice candidate, relative to 8% who would only vote for a pro-life candidate — a historic flip from pro-lifers being the most energized voters.
One thing that did not reverse following Dobbs is that most voters still oppose taxpayer funds for abortive procedures.
But under Trump 2.0, the GOP began creating distance from the pro-life causes they had long championed. Long-standing pro-life language in the Republican platform was removed in 2024. Trump spoke out against the heartbeat law in his home state of Florida. And during his third presidential campaign, Trump said on Truth Social: “My administration will be great for women and their reproductive rights.”
Not that many conservatives seemed to mind. White evangelicals congregated in their support of Trump in record numbers in 2024, the biggest constituency bringing him to power. That’s because the GOP’s saving grace on abortion has been that politics is a game of comparisons.
Democrats have had their own evolution on the issue, from “safe, legal, and rare” during the Clinton era to “shout your abortion” today. The party’s resistance to any restrictions on abortion is out of step with the American public, the majority of whom oppose abortions performed after the first trimester.
A political mess
My personal views on the issue: I’m Anglican and believe in the innate value of every human life. I am pro-life, although my beliefs on life extend beyond the womb to a whole-life ethic.
I believe we could do a better job as a nation supporting mothers and children, especially in the wake of Dobbs. We also could do a better job caring for the vulnerable of all ages, races, and economic conditions.
This is the holistic, cross-partisan (and largely Democratic) way that the pro-life movement began, as documented by the historian Daniel Williams in “Defenders of the Unborn,” before the pro-life movement in the later part of the 20th century became largely a Republican and evangelical effort.
My beliefs on life aren’t represented in our two-party system. I don’t expect them to be any time soon. The tiny upside of this political homelessness is that this provides the freedom to look at when the political parties get it wrong (or right) on dignity-of-life issues.
The Hyde Amendment is the longest-standing and most bipartisan policy we have on abortion. What an irony if it’s lost by the very “pro-life” Republicans.
Abby McCloskey, former director of economic policy at the American Enterprise Institute, is a podcast host and consultant. Her previous article was “A case for childlike wonder in a grown-up world.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.