Whenever I feel uncertain about why some economies thrive, some stagnate and others decline, I turn to Joel Mokyr, one of three economists who won the Nobel prize on Monday. Here are his five most important lessons.
Growth is often resisted. Economic growth has been critical to prosperity. It is why people live longer, more comfortable lives that are free from the drudgery of hard labor. But it is often resisted, because it involves upheaval and uncertainty.
Mokyr once explained to me how, at first, men refused work in factories. They were used to working for themselves, as small-scale farmers or artisans, even though they were poor and it was not an easy life. It was what they knew.
The concept of modern work — being somewhere at a certain time, staying all day, taking orders from a boss you had no relation to — was so offensive and demeaning to men that for years factories had to hire women and children. It took a few generations of social conditioning for men to make the transition.
It takes time, can’t be predicted
Growth takes time. Industrialization was made possible by a few key innovations that changed the nature of work and production. But no one knew at first what to do with some critical inventions. The steam engine, which powered factories and made industrial production possible, took more than 100 years to affect the productivity statistics.
Often the most pivotal inventions take years to find their best use, and in ways no one could have predicted. It is true the speed at which innovations get adopted gets quicker each year. It’s also true that inventions that currently exist will have a huge impact on the world many years from now.
Growth is unpredictable. New innovations destroy jobs, but they also create new ones — and it is fruitless to try to anticipate what the new jobs will be. Innovations transform the economy in ways that are impossible to comprehend. As Mokyr once told me: “Imagine explaining to someone in 1920 what a cybersecurity expert is.
Requires culture of risk
Growth is cultural. One question drove economic history literature for decades: Why was Great Britain the first country to industrialize and get rich? Other countries were also inventing things, or had more wealth and natural resources, or a better climate.
The culture of growth, which is critical, comes down to an openness to risk and experimentation. This was a big part of the Scottish Enlightenment, where populations were relatively educated, their humanity was emphasized, and curiosity and individuality were valued.
It’s not enough for a nation to invest money and build infrastructure; it’s not possible for a government to central-plan its way to prosperity. The most critical innovations are often discovered through trial-and-error.
Not inevitable
Growth is not inevitable. For centuries, the economies of the world barely grew. There was some progress — but it was small, and when empires ended, often the progress did too. That’s what makes the last few hundred years so exceptional. It is true that growth does tend to accelerate, and that innovations that grow the economy beget greater inventions. But if the right conditions for growth are not maintained, it is not guaranteed.
As the world faces a future of lower growth, policymakers are tempted to give the government a more active role in the economy. Policy certainly has a role to play. But all governments should realize that abundance doesn’t come from better planning. The crucial element of growth is openness — to risk, uncertainty, change and creativity. That’sJoel Mokyr’s great lesson of Joel Mokyr, and why his work is as relevant as ever.
Allison Schrager is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering economics. A senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, she is author of “An Economist Walks Into a Brothel: And Other Unexpected Places to Understand Risk.” Her previous article was “Women will get more jobs, men will be better paid for them.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.