Stephen Colbert and Jimmy Kimmel should have been canceled long ago. Their goals are to advance progressive causes and bash anyone who disagrees, but the real rub is that their self-indulgence isn’t good for business.
In the second quarter of 2025, Colbert led late night with an average of 2.42 million viewers, followed by Kimmel with 1.77 million and Jimmy Fallon with 1.19 million. This is down a combined 43% from 2015. In the 18 to 49 demographic coveted by advertisers, the loss is a calamitous 70% to 80% (Kimmel is down 77%). According to Guideline, advertising collapsed by half over the last decade.
Colbert and Kimmel
Industry sources suggest that Colbert’s “Late Show” now loses about $40 million each year, which hardly justifies his estimated $15 million to $20 million salary and staff of 200 producers, writers, and camera operators. Strangely, there has been no suggestion that Colbert reduce his staff or take a pay cut. CBS canceled his money-loser with 10 months’ notice.
It seems likely that investor Larry Ellison, the conservative founder of Oracle, could not understand why CBS was losing $40 million a year to give a platform to a tiresome and predictably partisan late night host. Or, perhaps the change of ownership allowed CBS to do what fiscal prudence should have dictated years ago.
Over at Disney, home of 10 hours a week of Trump derangement programming (“Jimmy Kimmel Live!” and “The View”), and news programming dominated by George Stephanopoulos, a partisan Democrat whose repeated insistence that Trump had been found liable for rape cost ABC $16 million, Kimmel had every reason to believe that he could continue disparaging Trump and Republican voters indefinitely.
Kimmel might generate a small profit for ABC. Though he too reportedly earns about $15 million each year, and his audience is smaller than Colbert’s, ABC/Disney monetizes him on YouTube, in social media, on other distribution channels, and through other programming. Still, the financial picture for his show is grim.
ABC and the FCC
Disney/ABC executives with prior knowledge of Kimmel’s intended Charlie Kirk monologue begged him to change it. He refused. Apparently, when Kimmel declined to apologize the following night, Disney CEO Bob Iger suspended him. It is unclear if Iger’s decision was made before ABC’s largest affiliate groups, Sinclair Broadcasting and Nexstar, announced they would pre-empt Kimmel, though it was after FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr intemperately sought to intimidate Disney.
Facing threats of boycotts from consumers, celebrities, and creative talent, and with the left hammering it for violating Kimmel’s supposed First Amendment rights (conveniently ignoring their efforts to put Fallon in the doghouse for reaching out to Trump, and cancel Roseanne Barr, Gina Carano, and comedian Tony Hinchcliffe, among many others), Disney caved in four days. Kimmel resumed hosting with a statement of regret that mischaracterized his Kirk monologue, though some found it moving.
Neither Colbert nor Kimmel have a constitutional right to spread hate – or love, for that matter – on nightly television. The networks own that right. They can speak at events or self-publish, but neither has a First Amendment right to compel a network and its affiliates to cede 260 hours and pay him $15 million to proselytize about politics.
Kimmel’s Charlie Kirk monologue was no more contemptuous and inaccurate than his typical diatribe. It violated no FCC standards, and Brendan Carr’s imprudent venting made it more difficult for Disney to restrain Kimmel by making it appear that doing so would mean caving to the Trump administration.
The owners’ duty
Carr was wrong to get involved. ABC was wrong to single out the Kirk monologue. Colbert and Kimmel were wrong to use their platforms to spread disinformation and discord. The networks were wrong to subsidize their narcissism.
They should have replaced both hosts before they burned late night to the ground financially and artistically. Now, CBS has ended the “Late Show,” and it’s only a matter of time before Kimmel makes good on his promise to retire.
Humorless angry diatribes are not comedy and are not enjoyable. Neither are they FCC violations, however, or a constitutionally protected right of network emcees. If the Disney board remembers its duty to maximize profits, Kimmel will soon enough join Colbert in well-deserved retirement.
Kenin M. Spivak is founder and chairman of SMI Group LLC.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.