Which party do likely voters prefer in next year’s midterm elections? The four founding firms of the National Association of Independent Pollsters joined in a national survey on this question.
Each surveyed the exact same questions nationwide and the results were combined and then weighted. The survey included 2,071 likely voters. It was conducted Sept. 6-13, 2025. The margin of error is plus or minus 2%.
The answers
The two generic ballot tests were as follows:
In the 2026 midterm congressional elections next fall, for whom would you most likely vote? The answers were: Democrat candidate, 45%; Republican candidate, 43%; and undecided, 12%.
If the 2026 congressional elections were held tomorrow, for whom would you most likely vote? The answers were: Democrat candidate, 47%; Republican candidate, 46%; and undecided/Would Not Vote, 5%.
Here are our major collective thoughts based on the survey and the demographic breakdowns:
While Democrats are in many national surveys polling poorly as a party, Republicans would be unwise to assume that will translate into a winning year in 2026. At this point prior to the 2022 midterms (Sept. 2021), most polls showed Democrats leading somewhere between one point and eight points. That narrowed before the actual contest with the pollster’s last pre-election polls showing Republicans leading in the generic ballot test.
As most will recall, 2022 turned out to be less spectacular than predicted for the GOP. Republicans would be wise to recognize that despite perceived Democrat weakness, without Donald Trump on the ballot their task is more difficult than most might believe.
The youth vote
Our poll did, however, show a narrowing of the gap versus the average of all recent polls. As our survey was set prior to the event, we did not survey reaction to Kirk’s murder. However, the bulk of our time surveying occurred after Kirk’s death.
It is speculative to link the incident to Republicans reducing the Democrats’ lead. But the survey does show that Kirk’s efforts to reach the youngest of voters is still needed by the GOP. Our survey showed voters age 18 to 29 favored the generic Democratic candidate by some 10 points or more in both ballot questions we asked of them.
For both parties there was some good news when it came to the racial demographic breakdown. Republicans continued to hold on to their advantage among white voters and are receiving support from African American voters in the mid-30 percentile range — a number once thought of as impossible for the GOP. But Democrats continue to have strong support among Hispanic/Latino voters as well as among Asians and respondents of other races.
A likely GOP surge
Turnout and voter intensity are crucial in determining the outcomes of tight races for the House and Senate in midterm elections. Our collective experience suggests that if the midterms were held tomorrow, there would likely be a significant surge in GOP motivated voters due to the recent events.
The reaction to Charlie Kirk’s assassination has sparked a national expression of grief and a renewed determination among younger voters to continue his efforts on college campuses. However, with over a year until the elections, the Democrats currently hold a very slim advantage. This small lead appears to be diminishing as the actual contests approach.
The authors represent the four founding organizations of the National Association of Independent Pollsters: Matt Towery (Insider Advantage), Mark Mitchell (Rasmussen Polling), Robert Cahaly (Trafalgar Group) and Rich Baris (Big Data Poll).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.