Older people dominate American politics to the point that many now refer to the country as a gerontocracy, ruled by older people. Among the 38 members of the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, the U.S. has the biggest age divide between elected officials and constituents and the highest share of representatives over 60 years of age.
While older age comes with experience, the exclusion of young people from politics means the country is missing out on the talent, ideas, and energy of younger generations, and risking that young voters turn their backs on democracy.
Democratic youth
In democracies around the world, young people have started new political parties whenever the establishment has sidelined their views or excluded them from policymaking. These parties have sometimes reinvigorated political competition, compelled established parties to take previously neglected issues seriously, or encouraged incumbent leaders to find better ways to include and reach out to young voters.
In Europe, a trio in their twenties started Volt in 2017 as a pan-European response to Brexit, and the party has won seats in the European Parliament and in some national legislatures.
In Chile, leaders of the 2011 student protests won seats as independent candidates and then created political parties like Revolución Democrática and Convergencia Social to institutionalize their movements. In 2022, one of these former student leaders, Gabriel Boric, became president at 36 years old.
But young people in the United States can’t do this. This is not because they are uniquely apathetic or disinterested in politics. It is because the winner-take-all electoral system makes it nearly impossible to create new political parties in the U.S.
In a winner-take-all system, only the one candidate with the most votes wins the representation of the entire district, so voters and parties organize around the two candidates that have a shot at winning, resulting in a two-party system. Voters, wary of wasting their votes, vote for the candidate who might win, even if it means not voting for their preferred candidate.
Third parties don’t enter races because they know voters won’t waste their vote on them or because they could spoil the election for one of the two main candidates.
Proportional voting
With proportional representation, even if a party or candidate doesn’t come up at the top, they can still win a seat, so voters are more likely to vote sincerely, and smaller parties are more likely to be created and participate in elections.
Chile began using proportional to elect its legislature in 2015. Forty of the 43 nations in the European Union — all but the U.K., Belarus and France — also use some form of it to elect their legislatures.
Besides making it easier for young people to start a party, proportional systems can also improve the participation of young people in politics in other ways. In winner-take-all systems, electoral victory depends on swing voters. In proportional systems, parties can win more seats with additional votes, so they have incentives to include young candidates on their candidate lists to appeal to young voting groups.
Moreover, because multiple candidates can win in a district under proportional representation, parties can run young candidates without necessarily displacing older politicians. This makes it easier for parties to invest in young political talent while keeping experienced incumbents.
Without a proportional electoral system, young political entrepreneurs don’t have the option of creating partisan alternatives. Instead, they have to work within the parties and dislodge incumbents if they want to win a seat and have real influence. Needless to say, older incumbents are in no rush to step aside for young politicians.
Alienating youth
Young people who do not feel represented by the two parties and who feel that politics is not working for them may disengage from politics. But if young people don’t participate as much in elections, candidates don’t seek out their votes, which further alienates young people from politics, and so on.
Electoral reforms, like the adoption of proportional representation, can bring young people back into politics and improve politics for all. So while organizing around a new party is a fool’s errand right now, organizing around electoral reforms may be a winning strategy for disaffected young people and for the country overall.
Oscar Pocasangre is a senior data analyst at New America.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.