The latest battle in America’s woke wars featured a country-themed restaurant-and-store which gloried in the name of Cracker Barrel. The senior management of Cracker Barrel Old Country Store Inc. tried to modernize their enterprise by simplifying its logo and removing the image of an overall-clad man leaning on a barrel.

MAGA spotted a plot by woke managers to destroy another corner of Old America. Battle ensued. The company restored the overall-clad man.

MAGA is now celebrating yet another victory over the woke revolution, but the victory is not only ridiculous but Pyrrhic.

The real threat

Ridiculous because the people behind the redesign were not woke revolutionaries but paint-by-numbers managers. Pyrrhic because the corporate homogenization of American culture will continue. Cracker Barrel’s retention of its “Old Timer” will not change the numbing monotony of America’s increasingly generic and boring popular eateries.

Advertise with us

The real threat to America is not wokery. It is mediocrity.

In today’s corporate landscape, mediocrity is not so much a feature as a bug. We increasingly live in a world of corporate lookalikes. All logos have gone through the same process of simplification. All brands speak the same language of openness and inclusivity. All restaurants from the slowest to the fastest partake of the same minimalist ethic.

There is even a name for the phenomenon: “Blandification.” The critics are howling into the wind. The corporate world is in the grip of three management techniques that weave mediocrity into everything it produces.

The first is measurement and standardization. Standardization is as old as mass production, but the process is reaching hitherto protected areas of the knowledge economy. The 3M Company was once famous for giving its workers spare time to noodle away at new products, a process that produced Post-it notes as well as other innovations.

But in 2001 a new CEO, James McNerney, introduced “Six Sigma,” a data-driven methodology aimed at eliminating defects in any process, into every corner of the company, including innovation. Out went “noodling” and in came bureaucratic accountability and market segmentation.

Advertise with us

The result was a creativity crisis — at best a collection of me-to products and at worse innovation paralysis. (McNerney went on to lead Boeing Co. into a tailspin from which it has yet to recover.)

This paint-by-numbers spirit is spreading into the creative world: More and more companies are using digital tools to monitor knowledge workers, tracking their key strokes and watching their performance on Zoom, in a bid to boost productivity.

Managing and globalizing

The second is managed feedback. To buy something is to be immediately presented with a “how did we do” survey on a scale of one to five. Manage someone and you are required to produce regular reports on their performance (often, again, on a scale of one to five). But all this feedback is designed to squeeze out anything that is spontaneous or heartfelt.

Anybody who wants to make a genuine complaint about poor service, as I did recently about British Telecom, finds it impossible to get through to a live human being. Some of this managed feedback is designed to create the illusion that giant bureaucracies are listening.

One reason Netflix series are becoming so insipid is that the company cares about all those thumbs-up and thumbs-down buttons. Feedback rewards the predictable and punishes the original, squeezing shows into “categories” and then squeezing examples of these categories into rigid formulae. And one reason products are so generic is that designers are always polling their customers.

Advertise with us

The third is globalization. The more companies try to reach global markets, the more they produce generic slop impervious to the quirks of culture. Comic book heroes are much easier to export than angst-ridden characters. But what is true about cultural products is also true of car dashboards and washing-machine control panels.

Globalization may be fading. A revival of quirky national traditions is unlikely to replace it. Two of the most powerful forces in modern business are sending the mediocrity revolution into overdrive.

The most obvious is artificial intelligence. AI operates by scraping the internet for established knowledge and then serving up that knowledge in a predigested form. If the biggest money-spinner of 2025 turned out to be the latest “Fast and Furious,” AI will mechanically churn out more of them in an infinite feedback loop. Artificial intelligence is mediocrity memeified, magnified and mummified.

The other is consolidation. Over the past two decades, three out of four US industries have grown more concentrated, as giant companies have muscled aside competitors and swallowed start-ups. The biggest danger with consolidation is that it forestalls radical products that might challenge the status quo. In the shorter term it homogenizes existing products.

The deeper crisis

MAGA warriors are right to worry that something has gone wrong with corporate America and that the vertiginous stock prices conceal a reality of sloppy standards and juiced returns. But they err in obsessing over the culture wars rather than a deeper crisis of creativity.

Advertise with us

And they err, above all, in not seeing wokery for what it is: a mere symptom of the bigger problem of mediocrity.

Adrian Wooldridge is the global business columnist for Bloomberg Opinion and author of “The Aristocracy of Talent: How Meritocracy Made the Modern World.” His previous article was “Business is a great subject for literature, if the literati weren’t prejudiced against it.”