Every time there’s fresh evidence of labor market softness, as with the July jobs report, economists and employees now ask: Are we seeing the impact of artificial intelligence on knowledge workers?
AI is making the job market tougher for young college graduates, but wage growth has accelerated over the past year the 22 million people with jobs in professional and business services to levels above pre-pandemic rates. This suggests that the state of the labor market for white-collar workers is bifurcated — one where there are both winners and losers rather than one where most workers are worse off.
The youth are worse off
Despite the overall unemployment rate being a solid 4.2%, only 65.3% of 20 to 24 year olds were employed last month, nearly three percentage points lower than the post-pandemic peak in January 2024, and roughly the same perecentage as that in December 2008 following Lehman Brothers’ collapse.
For the millions of college graduates in the 22 to 29 age group, the unemployment rate stood at 3.7% in the first six months of the year, compared with 2.8% in 2019, according to Current Population Survey data.
Such numbers are backed up by numerous news reports as well as comments from corporate executives on how they see AI transforming labor needs. Internship postings this spring were down. A recent Wall Street Journal report noted that the share of entry-level hires relative to all new hires has slumped by 50% since 2019 among the biggest technology companies, while another pointed to consultancy firm McKinsey putting together smaller but more experienced teams as it adds AI to the mix.
It’s also becoming more common for CEOs to talk about AI eventually leading to significant layoffs. At Meta Platforms Inc., Alphabet Inc. and Microsoft Corp., employee headcount grew 64% between 2019 and 2022 but just 3% over the past three years.
But wages are up for some
This comes at a time when the three tech juggernauts collectively plan more than $250 billion in capital expenditures over the next 12 months, suggesting that there’s a tradeoff between investing in AI and hiring workers.
While the number of jobs in the professional and business services’ category of the non-farm payrolls data shrank slightly over the past year, wage growth accelerated to just above 5% in July. Compare that with 2019, when employment growth averaged 1.3% while wages rose 3.7%.
One explanation for this is that there are composition effects at work. If companies aren’t hiring young workers, who tend to be lower paid, we’re going to get lower employment growth in professional and business services along with increasing average compensation levels, which could overstate the extent to which older, more experienced workers are getting raises.
Some workers really are gaining from this phase of the AI boom. The select few engineers building new AI models are getting pro athlete-type offers. Outside the tech sector, companies such as McKinsey, specialized expertise becomes more valuable in combination with AI agents while where “mediocre expertise” is going away. That dovetails with Nvidia Corp. CEO Jensen Huang’s prediction that workers who use AI will be fine in this transition.
A boom that generates fear
It’s reasonable for all workers to be uncomfortable with a technological innovation that hasn’t disrupted most workers yet but where the ultimate outcome is so uncertain. There’s no guarantee that the next generation of AI models won’t come after workers with more advanced skills.
With the AI boom, it feels like the bigger it gets, the more losers there will eventually be, either from workforce disruption or a malinvestment-induced bust. Unless there are signs that it’s leading to more winners than losers, this is a boom that understandably generates as much fear as it does optimism.
Conor Sen is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist and founder of Peachtree Creek Investments. His previous article was “Old people are sustaining the economy.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.