This is an abridged version of an interview by John J. Waters with the scholar Daniel J. Mahoney, the author of “The Persistence of the Ideological Lie.” Waters begins by asking him, “What is the “totalitarian impulse?” Mahoney responds:

At the heart of this “impulse,” as I call it, is the desire to destroy the primordial commonsense distinction between good and evil. It’s a lie, of course. Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn wrote: “The line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties either — but right through every human heart — and through all human hearts.” That remains the truth of the matter.

Group guilt

But instead of recognizing the evil inside of every human heart, the “totalitarian impulse” localizes evil in certain suspect groups that are said to be ontologically guilty, guilty for who they are and not what they have done. So instead of individual responsibility, you have group guilt.

It’s what twentieth century Communists did to justify the repression of Christians and the bourgeoise. It’s what the Nazis did so murderously with the Jews. It’s what’s been happening with a race-class-gender regime that profoundly distorts our appreciation of personal responsibility. In this new woke dispensation, you know exactly who the victims are; you know exactly who the oppressors are.

Advertise with us

The French Enlightenment first introduced this mendacious distinction between “progress and reaction” and it culminated in bloodletting in the form of Jacobin terror. But the Communists perfected it in the twentieth century with an unprecedented form of totalitarianism. Once they label you reactionary, you’re more than a political opponent — you’re a pernicious “enemy” getting in the way of the unfolding of history and the march of progress.

People are finding the courage nowadays to confront the “impulse,” to stand up to it. But the impulse is deeply ingrained in civil society. Old-fashioned liberals and conservatives always looked for despotism or totalitarianism in a centralized, self-aggrandizing state like the Soviet Union.

But what happens when this tyrannical impulse has taken refuge in journalism, education, nonprofits, and in other segments of society? What happens when these groups start imposing despotism in the name of anti-racism, anti-slavery, anti-colonialism?

In the freest society on earth, this impulse is deeply instantiated in our institutions. If this mentality wins, we end up with nihilism, contempt for patriotism, and contempt for customary morality.

The modern left

I don’t see any appetite on the Left to return to moderation. Liberalism is dead. The old Democrat party was patriotic and religious, but today’s party is militantly secular, and that’s a thoroughgoing difference.

Advertise with us

Karl Marx wanted to abolish not only the nation-state, but also the bourgeois family and religion. His project to radically change human nature and build a new society was a palpable failure.

The greatest force for murder and destruction in modern times has been politicized atheism. Communism killed up to 120 million people. Some 60 to 80 million people died from government-induced famines in China and the Soviet Union. It’s a story barely told.

Instead of saying “we won” in 1989 [when the Iron Curtain fell], we should have explained how these regimes established an unprecedented amount of control over human beings. Because we made no efforts to understand this, the progressive ideology picked up where the totalitarian regime left off.

The 19th century Russian novelist Fyodor Dostoevsky articulated the truth that some people support the destruction of the world — that nihilism is the core of the revolutionary temptation. In his powerful and prescient novel “Demons” in particular, published in 1872, Dostoevsky showed that the Left is not sentimental about people or about romantic ideals.

He dramatized the radical atheism, the zeal for destruction, the taste for violence, and the unrelenting moral nihilism that characterized the emerging revolutionary Left. It was against the grain because in Russia, serious thinkers who didn’t hate God or mock religion were not considered to be intellectuals. Demons is in my view the most prophetic book of the last 100 years.

Advertise with us

Among Solzhenitsyn’s great insights of his work was that any system that tries to get rid of evil in toto will only make it magnify in unimaginable ways. We can and ought to restrict evil through the rule of law and through self-restraint. But if we try to get rid of evil, abolish evil, we will only make evil universally triumph by scapegoating the innocent as well as the guilty.

Determined people

Václav Havel, the first president of the postcommunist Czech government, became a dissident in the communist country, was arrested, and spent hard time in prison. He saw that the regime’s systematic lies were backed up by violence, and that it ground down the people.

Even so, he made a commitment to live not by lies, to paraphrase Solzhenitsyn, and wrote forcefully about the Communist regime in “The Power and the Powerless,” among other works. He and other dissidents founded reading groups, exposed human rights abuses and aimed to create the rudiments of a “parallel polis.”

In short, Havel demonstrated that a group of determined people who say “we’ve had enough” can allow genuine moral consciousness to be restored which is a precondition for the restoration of political liberty and human dignity.

John J. Waters is author of the novel “River City One.” Follow him at @JohnJWaters1 on X. Daniel J. Mahoney is an emeritus professor at Assumption University and author of “The Persistence of the Ideological Lie.”