Recently, Nvidia founder Jensen Huang, whose company builds the chips powering today’s most advanced artificial intelligence systems, remarked: “The thing that’s really, really quite amazing is the way you program an AI is like the way you program a person.”
Ilya Sutskever, co-founder of OpenAI and one of the leading figures of the AI revolution, stated that AI will do everything humans can do, because “the brain is a biological computer.”
I am a cognitive neuroscience researcher, and I think they are dangerously wrong.
Human brains work differently
AI in learning is both inevitable and potentially transformative for the better, but these metaphors mislead us about our own brains. During past technological revolutions, scientists and popular culture tended to describe the human brain as analogous to one new machine after another: a clock, a switchboard, a computer.
Now, words like “training,” “fine-tuning” and “optimization” are frequently used to describe human behavior. But we don’t train, fine-tune or optimize ourselves in the way that AI does. Such inaccurate metaphors can cause real harm.
The 17th-century idea of the mind as a “blank slate” imagined children as empty surfaces shaped entirely by outside influences. This led to rigid education systems that tried to eliminate differences in neurodivergent children, such as those with autism, ADHD or dyslexia, rather than offering personalized support.
Similarly, the early 20th-century “black box” model from behaviorist psychology claimed only visible behavior mattered. As a result, mental healthcare often focused on managing symptoms rather than understanding their emotional and biological causes.
Now, new misbegotten approaches emerge as we start to see ourselves in the image of AI. I see this playing out with undergraduate students, who, for the first time, believe they can achieve the best measured outcomes by fully outsourcing the learning process — assuming that AI works the same as their own minds.
Many use AI tools to maximize efficiency, often at the expense of reflection and genuine understanding. They use AI as a tool that helps them produce good essays, yet in many cases, the process of researching and writing no longer has much connection to original thinking or to discovering what sparks their curiosity.
If we continue thinking of our brains as AI, we risk losing the vital thought processes that have led to major breakthroughs in science and art. These achievements did not come from identifying familiar patterns, but from breaking them, sometimes through messiness and unexpected mistakes, that a human mind could recognize as significant.
Alexander Fleming discovered penicillin by noticing that mold growing in a petri dish he had accidentally left out was killing the surrounding bacteria. His observation went on to save the lives of hundreds of millions of people.
Human brains are messy
This messiness isn’t just important for eccentric scientists. It is important to every human brain. One of the most interesting discoveries in neuroscience in the past two decades is the “default mode network,” a group of brain regions that becomes active when we are daydreaming and not focused on a specific task.
This network has also been found to play a role in reflecting on the past, imagining and thinking about ourselves and others. Disregarding this mind-wandering behavior as a glitch rather than embracing it as a core human feature will inevitably lead us to build flawed systems in education, mental health and law.
Unfortunately, it is particularly easy to confuse AI with human thinking. Microsoft describes generative AI models like ChatGPT on its official website as tools that “mirror human expression, redefining our relationship to technology.” And OpenAI CEO Sam Altman recently highlighted his favorite new feature in ChatGPT called “memory.”
This function allows the system to retain and recall personal details across conversations. For example, if you ask ChatGPT where to eat, it might remind you of a Thai restaurant you mentioned wanting to try months earlier. “It’s not that you plug your brain in one day,” Altman explained, “but … it’ll get to know you, and it’ll become this extension of yourself.”
The suggestion that AI’s “memory” will be an extension of our own is a flawed metaphor leading us to misunderstand the new technology and our own minds. Human memory evolved to forget, update and reshape memories based on myriad factors. AI memory stores information with much less distortion or forgetting.
A life in which people outsource memory to a system that remembers almost everything isn’t an extension of the self. It breaks from the very mechanisms that make us human. It shifts how we behave, understand the world and make decisions, because AI models can surface connections and context that our brains may have cleared away for one reason or another.
This might begin with small things, like choosing a restaurant, but it can quickly move to much bigger decisions, such as choosing a different career or partner than we would have chosen.
AI “brains” aren’t human
This outsourcing may be tempting because this technology seems human to us, but AI learns, understands and sees the world in fundamentally different ways, and doesn’t truly experience pain, love or curiosity as we do.
The consequences of this ongoing confusion could be disastrous — not because AI is inherently harmful, but because instead of shaping it into a tool that complements our human minds, we will allow it to reshape us in its own image.
Iddo Gefen is a Ph.D. candidate in cognitive neuroscience at Columbia University and author of the novel “Mrs. Lilienblum’s Cloud Factory.” His Substack Neuron Stories connects neuroscience insights to human behavior.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.