Like it or not, parts of the US economy depend on undocumented and other low-wage immigrant workers. The system has evolved to assume they would always be here, especially in areas such as agriculture, hospitality and construction.

The U.S. has built a system reliant on low-wage labor — in many cases undocumented workers — and it can’t You can’t strip them of their status, deport them or scare them into the shadows without large economic costs.

Inherently impossible

It’s no wonder that President Donald Trump is second-guessing his immigration policy, with enforcement guidance changing erratically every few days.

One week, he’s announcing enforcement carve-outs for key industries and political constituencies, like farmers and hotels. The next, his administration is reversing its own guidance. The mixed messages point to the inherent impossibility of delivering on nativist political promises without shooting oneself in the foot economically.

Advertise with us

Consider agriculture, where Trump has long courted votes and where somewhere close to 40% of crop farmworkers are thought to be undocumented. Any sharp drop in the availability of immigrant labor could meaningfully reduce farm profits and raise prices.

Farmers and venture capitalists have been gradually moving toward more mechanized production, but face daunting engineering challenges, especially with fresh produce, some of which grows on trees that are hard for robots to navigate.

A third option exists to meet demand at low prices, of course: importing more from trading partners. But doing so would be in tension with Trump’s goal to close the trade deficit and produce more domestically. In fact, the government is actively pursuing new protectionist measures in agriculture.

Then there’s hospitality and restaurants, where undocumented workers perform key roles as gardeners, housekeepers and kitchen workers. Technology may change the business model’s reliance on low-wage labor one day, but some hotels have been experimenting with robots for a decade already, and they’re still far from replacing the human workforce.

Housing and health aides

Construction was conspicuously absent from Trump’s short-lived carve-out, but by one set of estimates, the undocumented population makes up 38% of drywall and ceiling tile installers and tapers; 32% of roofers; and 28% of painters and paperhangers.

Advertise with us

By and large, the residential construction business is built to accommodate this arrangement. It has evolved into a multitiered system of contractors and subcontractors that gives developers and general contractors plausible deniability against immigration violations — an arrangement that’s peculiarly American. Curbing the flow of new workers will make it difficult for the industry to meet the 4.5 million-home housing deficit that has created an affordability crisis in the country.

Of course, the US housing industry can evolve. Scandinavia, Germany and Japan have managed to build homes with less low-cost labor by leaning heavily into offsite construction techniques. A recent report by UBS Group highlighted the productivity-boosting potential of using more wall panels — essentially factory-built pieces of wall that can even come with insulation, wiring and plumbing installed.

Germany also has a well-organized development program through its Berufsschulen, or vocational schools, that feeds a pipeline of skilled construction workers. Unfortunately, the US housing deficit is such that the nation needs all of those things at once: more US-educated vocational workers, more productive construction methods and immigrant labor. It’s not an either/or situation.

Finally, I’d be remiss not to mention home health and personal care aides, jobs that are becoming more in-demand as the population ages. The report cited government data showing that immigrants constituted 40% of home health aides and 30% of personal care employment, though it wasn’t clear how many were undocumented.

With Trump using raids in part for publicity with his base, it seems unlikely that we’ll see the sector caught up in high-profile enforcement actions. The optics would be horrendous. But Trump has been hitting that workforce through other attacks on work authorization, hurting a sector that’s already struggling to fill vacancies and retain workers.

Advertise with us

Deportations, after all, are just one small part of the administration’s approach to immigration. Tom Homan, Trump’s border czar, told Reuters late last month that the administration had deported around 200,000 people over four months, less than the Biden administration in the same period a year earlier — and a pace that would fall well short of the 15 million to 20 million deportations that the president teased during his campaign.

Slowing economic growth

I don’t doubt that influential voices like Stephen Miller’s would like to really deliver on those numbers. But, in all likelihood, legal and economic constraints will prevent Trump from ever getting close.

Still, new immigration is down. Morgan Stanley now thinks that net immigration of all kinds, which totaled an estimated 2.9 million in 2024, will probably collapse to about 0.3 million this year and 0.2 million in 2026. That also factors in the administration’s termination of the Temporary Protected Status and parole programs for Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans and Venezuelans, which provided work status to more than a million people.

The slowdown could dampen economic growth when the outlook is already shaky. Even if the reduced labor supply truly lifts wages for lower-income Americans (which is hardly guaranteed), it may drive up prices of the food and housing that those same people consume. What’s more, with 4.2% unemployment rate, there aren’t a lot of Americans available to take jobs like these.

Jonathan Levin is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist.