The Trump administration intends to overhaul the Endangered Species Act by changing what it means to harm an endangered or threatened species, as part of the larger White House campaign to spur economic growth through deregulation.

The president has long loathed red tape of the green variety, and one White House official predicted that overhauling the act “will have a seismic, real-world effect on the ability to build.”

“Environmental is the biggest tool for stopping growth,” Trump said during an interview with Joe Rogan last October. He called environmental regulations “a weapon,” and later vowed to expedite the environmental permit and approval process for any company investing at least $1 billion in the United States.

Trump has slashed and burned his way through much of the regulatory regime of his predecessor already, rescinding nearly 80 Biden-era climate-related orders during his first day in office alone. Overhauling the ESA would easily eclipse those efforts, changing the regulatory, and perhaps natural, landscape forever.

Advertise with us

The proposed reform must still make its way through the federal rule-making process. Legal challenges are almost certain to follow, although a conservative Supreme Court may not be sympathetic.

Sweeping change would follow from redefining a single word: harm.

Do no harm

While the plain text of the Nixon-era law prohibits the harming of endangered species, regulatory agencies have taken an expansive view that also prohibits modifying or degrading habitats where wildlife resides. Now the administration intends to define “harm” as an attempt to “take” an endangered species, that is, “to harass, harm, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, kill, trap, capture, or collect” the animal itself.

The rule change runs to the heart of a longstanding debate over how the act ought to apply to private property. When the northern spotted owl was listed as a threatened species in 1990, the federal government placed millions of acres in the Pacific Northwest off limits. Logging companies filed suit. The high court ruled against them in Babbitt v. Sweet Home Chapter of Communities for a Great Oregon.

Environmentalists rejoiced in the victory. Writing for the dissent, Justice Antonin Scalia warned that an expansive definition of harm expanded the regulation’s reach and “imposes unfairness to the point of financial ruin,” not just upon businesses “but upon the simplest farmer who finds his land conscripted to national zoological use.”

Advertise with us

Conservatives argue that environmentalists and government agencies didn’t focus on bringing endangered species back from the brink so much as the left used the act to expand their power at the expense of industry. “The groups use endangered species, sometimes ones that aren’t actually endangered at all, as a fig leaf to stop all growth,” one Trump official added. “And they do the same with ludicrous arguments that habitat will be impacted, to halt development and kill the economy.”

The fish that didn’t exist

The White House doesn’t have to look far for environmental activism allegedly dressed up as conservation. Consider the snail darter.

The little freshwater fish swims in Eastern Tennessee rivers and was listed as endangered in 1973, a designation that halted construction of the Tellico Dam. Scientists now say it does not exist. “There is, technically, no snail darter,” Thomas Near, curator of ichthyology at the Yale Peabody Museum and a professor at that university’s fish biology lab, told The New York Times.

It is Exhibit A, the professor told the Times, of “the ‘conservation species concept,’ where people are going to decide a species should be distinct because it will have a downstream conservation implication.”

The administration will likely have a free hand as they seek to overhaul the Endangered Species Act. In the 1995 Babbitt decision, the Supreme Court relied on the so-called Chevron deference. When Congress has not addressed a question directly, the high court, per that doctrine, was expected to follow a federal agency’s interpretation of a given statute. In Babbitt, the Supreme Court adopted the expansive regulatory definition of harm set forth by the Fish and Wildlife Service.

Advertise with us

Fast forward 30 years, and Chevron is no more. The Supreme Court overruled it last summer when Chief Justice John Roberts ruled the doctrine “fundamentally misguided.”

Green and greed

Environmental advocates have been bracing for a deregulatory onslaught since the moment Trump won reelection. According to Noah Greenwald, director of the Center for Biological Diversity, redefining what amounts to a “harm” is the “first step toward stripping habitat protections from rare plants and animals headed toward extinction.” He called it nothing less than “a death sentence.”

“The Trump administration has been systematically killing protections for our air, water, wildlife and climate like a vicious cancer,” Greenwald said last week. “The malignant greed driving these policies threatens to greatly increase destruction of the natural world and turbocharge the extinction crisis.”

EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin said during his Senate confirmation hearing earlier this year that he believes “we have a moral responsibility to be good stewards of our environment for generations to come.” Speaking for the administration, he added, however, that “common-sense” environmental regulations were possible “without suffocating the economy.”

Philip Wegmann is a writer for RealClearPolitics. His previous article was “The Republicans won the battle over third party candidates.”