Most of us know what it means for something to be unconstitutional, but you can ask a different question: not whether an action is constitutional, but whether it is anti-constitutional.

The defining attribute of the new president’s administration thus far is its anti-constitutional orientation. Both of its most aggressive and far-reaching efforts — the impoundment of billions of dollars in congressionally authorized spending and the attempt to realize the president’s promise of mass deportation — rest on fundamentally anti-constitutional assertions of executive authority.

Government under law

The project of constitutionalism, historian Henry Steele Commager wrote, is the project of “government under law, by law, through law, in conformity with law.”

It is, to borrow from John Locke, “to have a standing rule to live by, common to every one of that society, and made by the legislative power erected in it.” And in the American political tradition, it is the central principle that “governments are not omnipotent,” but of “only limited authority.”

Advertise with us

Part of the conceptual basis of constitutionalism is a division between sovereignty and government. Sovereignty is the possession of supreme authority over the polity, and government is the instrument of that sovereignty.

An anti-constitutional act is one that rejects the basic premises of constitutionalism. It rejects the premise that sovereignty lies with the people, that ours is a government of limited and enumerated powers and that the officers of that government are bound by law.

The Constitution is clear. Congress holds the power of the purse. Its decisions are laws, not recommendations or advisory opinions and the executive’s duty is to “take care that the laws be faithfully executed.”

To assert, against the plain text of the Constitution, the power to seize appropriations and destroy the work of the legislature is to break a core premise of constitutionalism.

Even more egregious are the president’s efforts to ship immigrants allegedly in the country illegally to the Terrorism Confinement Center, a mega-prison in El Salvador. Over the weekend — falsely claiming wartime conditions — the president invoked the 1798 Alien Enemies Act to deport, without due process, hundreds of people the White House has accused of gang ties and criminal behavior.

Advertise with us

Government over law

There is much to say about the administration’s decision to ignore a district court order to halt or reroute deportation flights for these people. For now, let’s focus on the Justice Department’s initial defense of the president’s order.

The government lawyers argued: “Beyond the statute, the president’s inherent Article II authority is plainly violated by the district court’s order. As a function of his inherent Article II authority to protect the nation, the president may determine that [Tren de Aragua, a criminal gang] represents a significant risk to the United States … and that its members should be summarily removed from this country as part of that threat.”

In other words, according to the Justice Department, the president of the United States has an “inherent” power to summarily deport any foreign national accused of membership in any gang without so much as a hearing. What’s more, under this logic, the president can then direct his administration to send that person, without due process, to prison in a foreign country.

This is a claim of sovereign authority. This is a claim that the president has the power to declare a state of exception around a group of people and expel them from the nation — no questions asked.

It is anti-constitutional. It is a negation of the right to be free, in Locke’s words, of “the inconstant, uncertain, unknown, arbitrary will of another man.”

Advertise with us

There is nothing in this vision of presidential power that limits it to foreign nationals. Who is to say, under the logic of the Department of Justice, that the president could not do the same to a citizen?

The president’s general claim of “inherent” power derived from the Article II vesting clause is, by itself, something that teeters along the edge of an anti-constitutional assertion of authority. The Constitution provides for express and implied powers and is explicitly designed to limit the ability of any one branch of government to exercise tyrannical power over the others or the people themselves.

The notion of “inherent” powers confounds this arrangement for the simple reason that they are broad, ill-defined and seemingly unaccountable to either Congress or the courts. As a trio of political scientists put it in their book-length critique of the “unitary executive” theory, “When presidents claim inherent powers, they are operating outside the Constitution and are not restrained by it.”

A rejection of the law

When the president claims sovereign power to ignore Congress or deport foreign nationals without due process — when he treats the law as a suggestion, rejects any limits on his authority and makes the government his personal fief — he is both degrading the constitutional order and abdicating his responsibility to future generations of Americans.

He is rejecting the obligation we have, as citizens, to carry on the effort to “form a more perfect union” and ensure that “government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.”

Advertise with us

He is selling our birthright so that he might enjoy a bit more power for the time he has left in office, indifferent to what it might mean for Americans yet to be born.

Jamelle Bouie is a columnist for The New York Times.

Thankfully, Trump’s anti-constitutionalism is not the last word. How can it be otherwise? “It is the people who make constitutions work,” Commager wrote. “Where people are ignorant or apathetic, where they distrust democracy and are frightened by liberty, constitutionalism will fail and tyranny will take its place.”

But, he said, “Where people are enlightened and alert, where they are inspired by faith in themselves and in democracy, where the spirit of liberty flourishes, constitutionalism will succeed.”

Where all this goes is still up to us.

Jamelle Bouie is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article originally appeared. His previous article was “Donald Trump will end the Republic as we know it.”