If someone promises something for nothing, be on your guard. That was a mistake of Joe Biden’s economic policy, a mistake now being made by Donald Trump.

Jason Furman, who chaired the White House Council of Economic Advisers under Barack Obama, recently criticized the former president’s economic policy. His main point is a basic principle of economic policymaking: All choices come with tradeoffs.

The Biden administration believed it could spend trillions of dollars without overheating the economy, and it got inflation, for example. It believed that the US could build a green economy to save the planet without anyone having to pay more or make do with less.

In the end, the economy recovered after the pandemic, but real wages barely improved, inflation risk returned, and the U.S. is deeper in debt.

Advertise with us

Trump’s hopes

President Donald Trump’s administration says tariffs won’t cost consumers or domestic producers — in the long run. It argues that if the government reduced regulations and operated more efficiently, economic growth would pay for tax cuts and reduce worries about the debt.

None of this is likely. Yes, the government needs to cut waste and excessive regulations, and some tax cuts will boost growth. But even in the best-case scenario, the added growth wouldn’t be enough to make them pay for themselves, let alone cover the unfunded entitlements coming due in the next decade.

Of course, politicians promising something for nothing is hardly a novel phenomenon, but the belief in a free lunch has become more common lately.

Two pieces of conventional wisdom that emerged after 2008 fed this mass delusion, both of them are wrong. One is that it is better to provide too much economic stimulus rather than too little. The other is that worries about inflation and higher interest rates were things of the past.

The 2009 American Recovery and Reinvestment Act cost more than $800 billion, but some economists argued at the time (and still believe) that it should have been bigger, saying it slowed the recovery from the 2008 recession.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, the Federal Reserve went into full-on stimulus mode for years after the crisis, continuing to expand its balance sheet. With both the added debt and the expansionary monetary policy, higher inflation and rates were expected — but they never came about.

What policymakers took away from this experience was that no amount of spending or expansionary monetary policy would increase interest rates or inflation. Ergo, they could stimulate as much as they wanted, in just about any way they wanted, without cost.

As long as interest rates are near zero, this is kind of true. After all, it is nearly costless to run up debt, and it appears to pay off so long as it produces some positive growth.

Alas, no financial condition lasts forever, and this includes near-zero interest rates. Debt, however, does tend to be forever.

Against neoliberalism

Low rates enabled this delusion. But it runs deeper: The last decade saw a backlash from the left and the right against neoliberalism, the belief that more market-based policies and freer trade would bring about better economic growth.

Advertise with us

As my colleague Clive Crook has pointed out, a rejection of neoliberalism is essentially a rejection of the principle that any policy poses tradeoffs. Neoliberalism does not promise constant growth or eliminate the possibility of job loss. On balance, however, it creates more winners and growth than the alternative.

The alternative — that if countries traded less, did all they could to boost demand and allowed the government to direct commerce — made for a much more seductive pitch. The result, so we were told, would be more certainty, more growth, more wealth and even more wealth equality.

The failure of Bidenomics demonstrated just how deluded that view is. In economies, there is no growth without risk. Every policy choice comes with winners and losers, cost and benefits, and the bill eventually comes due.

Allison Schrager is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. Her previous article was “The costs and benefits of singleness.”