Donald Trump’s radical moves like mass deportation may pale in significance next to his use of something less showy but ultimately more far reaching: impoundment — the controversial claim that the president can “impound” funds appropriated by Congress, refusing to use them as Congress specified.

It’s akin to a line-item veto, except that instead of vetoing a specific appropriation so that the money is never spent, the executive branch confiscates the funds. The president then spends the money on another program or holds it in reserve.

Like many of Trump’s contentious policies, this one is not without precedent — which is not the same as saying that it’s a good idea.

Starting with Jefferson

The first president to try his hand at impounding was Thomas Jefferson. In 1803, he refused to spend money allocated for buying gunboats, arguing that the need for them — defending rivers against British incursions — had passed, thanks to “the favorable & peaceable turn of affairs.”

Advertise with us

Notably, Jefferson framed this decision in terms of economy and efficiency, not presidential prerogative. He was serving as a steward of taxpayer funds, refusing to spend appropriated monies that were no longer needed.

When he moved beyond this justification and tried to refuse to pay the salaries of government officials he disliked, Congress cried foul, and the president backed down.

For the rest of the century, presidents typically justified impoundment on the same grounds. The one major exception was President Ulysses S. Grant’s refusal to spend funds appropriated for harbor and river improvements, because it funded ”works of purely private or local interest, in no sense national.”

This move provoked howls of protest from Congress, with one representative declaring: “What right has this great Caesar to decide what are and what are not national, when the American Congress has decided the question by making these appropriations.” Grant’s critics in Congress warned that these impoundments signaled a dangerous attempt to undermine Congress and its power of the purse.

In 1906, Congress decided to recognize the more accepted version of impoundment by passing the Anti-Deficiency Act, which allowed the president to waive or modify appropriations if “some extraordinary emergency or unusual circumstances [occurred] which could not be anticipated at the time of making such apportionment.”

Advertise with us

For the next 60-plus years, presidents and Congress sparred over the precise meaning of these words, with each getting the upper hand at various times. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt pushed the envelope more than most, citing wartime powers as justification to prune specific programs.

Nixon challenges Congress

Presidents Harry Truman, Dwight D. Eisenhower and Lyndon Johnson did the same. These moves, though, overwhelmingly related to the president’s role as commander-in-chief and focused on defense appropriations, not other forms of spending. They provoked grumbling in Congress, but not a constitutional crisis.

In 1967, President Johnson impounded funds that Congress had appropriated for several domestic programs, on the grounds that these expenditures would contribute to inflation, which had already begun to tick upward.

Though his impoundment marked a break with precedent, it was not generally perceived as an out-of-control executive branch. First, Johnson was reluctantly holding back money for programs he supported. Second, Congress supported many of these impoundments on much the same grounds.

President Richard Nixon’s record of impoundment was the first to come close to triggering a constitutional crisis. The clash began in 1972, when Congress appropriating funds for the Clean Water Act. Nixon vetoed the legislation. Congress hit back and overrode the veto.

Advertise with us

Nixon impounded the appropriated funds, breaking with precedent by explicitly using impoundment to override Congress after the legislative branch overrode his veto. He was clearly spoiling for a fight.

Though he justified his actions on the grounds that he was fighting inflation and trying to keep taxes low, he was actually after something bigger: a permanent increase in presidential power at the expense of Congress. In a press conference in 1973, he put the matter bluntly, claiming a “constitutional right for the president of the United States to impound funds.” He went on to describe this right as “absolutely clear.”

Congress wasn’t pleased. Senator Sam Ervin of North Carolina declared: “Impoundment does not save anybody any money, nor does it lead to lower taxes. It is merely a means whereby the White House can give effect to the social goals of its own choosing by reallocating national resources in contravention of congressional dictates.”

Ervin and his colleagues decided to do something about it. In 1974, they passed the Impoundment Control Act, which barred the president from uniliteral impoundment of funds. It also established a process by which a president could propose to rescind appropriations. Congress, though, would need to pass a law approving the rescission.

Trump vs. Congress

Donald Trump, who apparently venerated Nixon (and becoming a confidant of his after Watergate) seems ready to to pick up where Nixon left off, impounding funds in the hopes that the fight will go to the courts, ultimately overturning the Impoundment Control Act.

Advertise with us

Perhaps Trump will succeed where Nixon did not. Still, Nixon’s unsuccessful gambit is a useful reminder that Congress has protected its prerogatives in the past and may do so again.

Stephen Mihm is a professor of history at the University of Georgia and coauthor of “Crisis Economics.” His previous article was “We knew lead pipes were bad 140 years ago.”