In his first days in office, President Donald Trump announced a crackdown on immigration. What will happen to the economy if many of the immigrant workers (who are also consumers and taxpayers) who fill many jobs in the construction, restaurant, health care, agriculture, and elder care industries, suddenly are whisked away?
Study after study clearly shows that large increases in immigration tend to lower wages in the blue-collar jobs where many of those immigrants work. But those same studies also show that most of the effects are temporary. Over the longer term, new workers provide employers with opportunities to expand their businesses and increase production.
Demographers believe roughly 8.3 million undocumented immigrants are working in the U.S., accounting for about 5% of the total workforce.
That’s not huge, but with Americans angry about grocery prices and housing affordability, economists warn that expelling all those workers in such crucial industries will likely cause grocery prices and housing construction costs to climb. Existing staffing shortages at nursing homes and home health businesses will increase, leading to reduced services and higher costs.
Republicans against crackdowns
In fact, some of the biggest opponents of immigration crackdowns in the past have been Republican business leaders in places like Texas, Arizona, and California who need to hire lots of blue-collar workers. For them, immigrants are usually a blessing because labor shortages make it difficult to fill many positions, and immigrant workers will work at prevailing wages.
Sensationalized headlines about the small number of lawbreaking immigrants will not change the fact that entire industries, from construction and health care to agriculture, restaurants, and elder care, rely on immigrant labor, which accounts for anywhere from a quarter to half of certain occupations.
For example, immigrants increasingly fill a job gap in the healthcare industry. Nearly 2.8 million immigrants account for more than 18% of that industry’s workforce. Millions of them fill critical roles for physicians and surgeons (26%), registered nurses, dental hygienists, and home health aides (the latter estimates range from 27% to almost 40%).
Immigrants make up enormous shares of the labor pool for construction jobs, from 33% of carpenters to 37% of brick masons, 47% of roofers, and 64% of plasterers. National Association of Home Builders CEO Jim Tobin warns that policies targeting working immigrants could further weaken the construction industry’s already depleted labor market.
Migrant workers also represent about 40% of all crop farmworkers, according to the USDA, and their share of the workforce on dairy farms in certain states could be even higher.
Former Trump adviser Stephen Moore, from the conservative Heritage Foundation, pointed to the “strain” deporting eight to 10 million people would put on the economy: “You could see an inflationary impact to getting rid of some of these workers. So Trump’s campaign promises for mass deportations directly conflict with his pledge to reduce inflation.”
Domino effects
Nebraska is one of the top meat producers in the U.S., with one of the worst labor shortages in the country. For every 100 jobs, there are only 39 workers, according to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. “People say, ‘Well, just double or triple the pay (and) you’ll get United States citizens to work.’ No, you won’t,” says Al Juhnke, executive director of the Nebraska Pork Producers Association.
In fact, the expulsion of these workers will likely have another domino effect — reducing the number of jobs for native-born Americans. Economist Michael Clemens from the Peterson Institute has found that unauthorized workers are critical ingredients in the overall production process, and their removal has “ripple effects for the jobs of everybody else in the sector — including authorized immigrants, including natives.”
A recent study in the Journal of Labor Economics found that, for every 450,000 immigrants removed from the labor force, employment of complementary production jobs for U.S.-born males also declined by approximately 300,000, many of them high-skilled occupations.
Immigrant workers also contribute some of their wages to Social Security and Medicare, even though they do not receive benefits from those programs. The Social Security Administration has found that deportations could cut annual cash flow by $20 billion.
In 2022, immigrants living illegally in the U.S. paid $25.7 billion in Social Security taxes and $6.4 billion in Medicare taxes. The loss of this tax revenue concerns many economists since the Social Security fund is already expected to experience shortfalls by the mid-2030s.
Indeed, studies show that many children of immigrants (the second generation) go on to achieve higher education and elevated incomes, eventually contributing more in taxes than native-born Americans. Across the generations, immigrants provide a favorable net return. Indeed, the face of immigration itself has changed, with nearly half of new immigrants having college degrees.
Disruptive raids
Immigration will always be a challenge for a modern democratic society. A country can only absorb so many newcomers so fast. But removing millions of existing workers could very well shrink the U.S. workforce, drive up business costs and consumer prices, reduce the economy’s productive capacity, and widen the deficit.
In places where raids have been occurring, including Pittsburgh, as many as 75% of immigrant workers, including legal ones, have stopped showing up for work, fearful of getting swept up in the ICE net. This already has been hugely disruptive to individual workplaces and the nation’s economy.
Steven Hill was policy director for the Center for Humane Technology, co-founder of FairVote and political reform director at New America.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.