Our politics are widely declared to be polarized — “polarization” was Merriam-Webster’s 2024 word of the year — but I don’t think that’s true. A few years ago, I engaged cross-sections of Americans from all across the country in 16 in-depth focus groups about how they were feeling about their lives, the country, and our future.

I discovered something more profound than polarization. The findings reflected years of larger, underlying societal shifts taking root in society. And they were consistent across the country from rural Kansas to urban New Orleans to suburban Connecticut.

Americans are not so much polarized as separating and segregating themselves from one another due to unrelenting fear and anxiety about what’s happening around and to them.

Manufactured divisions

Many leaders and media are intentionally manufacturing and stoking divisions for their own self-interest, with social media helping create and amplify these divisions. This is producing a ceaseless surround sound that subjects people to an alternative reality that confuses, disorients, and destabilizes them.

Advertise with us

Seeing no way out, people are in an instinctive fight-or-flight mode. Some fight, as we see on social media. But many fly. Some break up into smaller groups and camps to protect themselves and gain validation, while others retreat from engaging at all.

Notice the term “fight-or-flight.” That isn’t a phrase I chose to describe what people told me during our Civic Virus study. It’s one that Americans from across our conversations repeatedly used themselves.

It’s not that people don’t care about what’s happening in their communities and the country. They care deeply, intensely. As one Nebraska woman shared, “People do want to come together and help each other, but they don’t really know how anymore.”

Moving forward

If we’re serious about moving forward today, we must recognize that the divisions in the country are intrinsically about social and psychological conditions — such as fear, anxiety, alienation, and a lack of empathy and belonging — rather than about political polarization. We’re facing a particular human dilemma.

As a result, so many people of good faith have thrown up their hands in frustration and retreated from public life. They’re fearful of raising hard issues, disagreeing with others, and being cut down for what they say. Others have decided that the way forward is to come out fighting and seek to win for their side at any cost.

Advertise with us

So what’s the answer to this dilemma? I believe what we’re missing today in American society is a way in which people can come together, figure out what they can agree on amid our real differences, and take action.

We must build together; talk alone is not enough. This very act of building generates a sense that we’re in something together, we have a shared humanity, and we each hold a sense of agency in moving forward. As we take shared action, we can demonstrate proof that progress is possible — because belief is based on proof — and that we have the capacity to step forward and get things done together.

A new civic path

This missing piece is what I have come to call the new civic path and I believe it must begin in our local communities, where so much of the significant change in American history has originated. In its absence, we will remain a splintered, divided nation.

How we move forward is not easy. But the choice is basic. Surrender to fight-or-flight. Or come together and get things moving again by taking action on issues that matter to people in their daily lives.

Rich Harwood is president of The Harwood Institute and the author of “Civic Virus: Why Polarization is a Misdiagnosis,” the book that resulted from his in-depth focus groups.