Originally introduced in 2008 to stimulate a fledgling market, and then renewed and expanded in 2022 as part of the Inflation Reduction Act, the federal tax credit for electric vehicle purchases remains what it has been from the start: an ineffective subsidy primarily benefiting the wealthy. Congress should end it.

The Congressional Research Service study noted: “For vehicles purchased in 2021, taxpayers with adjusted gross income (AGI) greater than $100,000 represented 22% of all filers and received 84% of the credit benefits.”

A recent study finds “that 75% of the EV subsidies claimed under the IRA have gone to consumers who would have bought an electric vehicle anyway.” According to their calculation, each car sold due to the incentive (roughly 25% of the total number of vehicles sold) came at a cost to taxpayers of $32,000.

Making matters worse, in recent months, the sales of EVs have stalled. Despite the taxpayers’ help, sales remain stuck at 7% of the market, strongly suggesting that tax credits are not increasing the demand.

Advertise with us

Unclear benefits

Further, the environmental benefits of the credit are unclear. EVs are not emission-free when considering the carbon footprint of battery production and electricity generation.

EVs primarily replace the purchase of newer gas vehicles, which pollute less than older vehicles. Combined with the fact that many tax-credit recipients would have purchased an EV anyway, it’s unlikely that there’s much environmental bang for the buck.

Second, the cost of the government picking winners compounds this problem. Artificially propping up EV manufacturers and steering consumers toward one specific technology can thwart the development of other, perhaps better, technologies.

Hybrids, plug-in hybrids, hydrogen fuel cell cars, alternative fuels or other emerging innovations are penalized despite their important role in addressing environmental and energy challenges.

Yet, instead of fostering open competition and letting the best solutions reveal themselves or allowing different technologies to serve different customer needs, the tax credit creates winners and losers based on political priorities.

Advertise with us

No longer needed

Finally, the tax credits were initially sold by congressional sponsors as a means “to help get these products over the initial stage of production … to the mass production stage, where economies of scale will drive costs down and the credit will no longer be necessary.” We’ve already passed that stage.

While still small, the EV market has matured and no longer needs these crutches. Even Elon Musk, the chief executive of Tesla Motors — the leader in U.S. EV sales with 2 out of 3 cars sold and the biggest beneficiary of the credits — says that it should end. Writing in the Wall Street Journal, Toyota’s Jack Hollis also called for the end of expensive and inefficient tax credits.

It’s high time this policy goes away. The federal EV tax credit is an inefficient, regressive program that benefits the wealthy at the expense of average Americans.

Eliminating it would restore fairness, reduce government interference in the market and, by encouraging genuine competition, better allow resources to go toward initiatives that enable as many people as possible to purchase cleaner vehicles.

Better ways

There are far more effective ways to address climate change. The best is to unleash capital to fund as many green and innovative projects as possible by reducing taxes on capital gains and renewing the ability to immediately deduct 100% of capital investments.

Advertise with us

Projects like solar farms, wind turbines and grid infrastructure require massive upfront capital investments. Without full expensing, these costs must be depreciated over many years, reducing the present value of tax benefits.

In addition, better cash flows in the early years make it easier to secure financing. The clean energy transition requires rapid deployment of new technologies. Full expensing encourages companies to accelerate investments rather than delay them.

Subsidizing high-end car buyers is a poor strategy for achieving meaningful environmental progress. But we know how to do better.

Veronique de Rugy is a senior research fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University.