Another elec­tion cy­cle, an­other round of hys­teria. Yester­day’s elec­tion was the “most im­por­tant elec­tion of our lives.” Reread this ar­ti­cle in 20 years, and that elec­tion will be the new “most im­por­tant elec­tion of our lives,” when half the na­tion pre­tends to know pre­cisely what’s best for the na­tion.

When was the last time an elec­tion was just an elec­tion? When the can­di­dates were just can­di­dates, not God’s can­di­date against the devil’s?

Po­lit­i­cal hy­per­bole is on a per­pet­ual rinse-and-re­peat cy­cle, and Amer­ica is ex­hausted.

Fa­tigued elec­tor­ate

A Pew Re­search Center sur­vey found that a sig­nifi­cant part of the Amer­i­can pop­u­la­tion feels ex­hausted and an­gry when think­ing about pol­i­tics, with 65% re­port­ing fre­quent feel­ings of fa­tigue re­lated to po­lit­i­cal dis­course. This emo­tional toll can re­sult in a sense of help­less­ness, where in­di­vid­u­als feel their par­tic­i­pa­tion in the elec­toral pro­cess is fu­tile, fur­ther ex­ac­er­bat­ing po­lit­i­cal ap­a­thy.

Advertise with us

This rhet­o­ric makes vot­ers feel a sense of ur­gency and ex­is­ten­tial threat. This has led to sen­sa­tion­al­iza­tion fa­tigue, where the elec­tor­ate be­comes de­sen­si­tized to the hy­per­bolic claims about the sig­nif­i­cance of elec­tions.

The phrase “the most im­por­tant elec­tion of our lives” can be traced back to at least the early 19th cen­tury, with its first no­ta­ble use in 1805 dur­ing a Penn­syl­va­nia gu­ber­na­to­rial race. Since then, it has been re­cy­cled in var­i­ous forms, of­ten dur­ing piv­otal elec­tions (which ev­ery elec­tion seems to be these days), to gal­va­nize voter turn­out by sug­gest­ing that the fu­ture of de­moc­racy hinges on the out­come.

The con­tin­u­ous use of this phrase cre­ates a cy­cle of sen­sa­tion­al­iza­tion that leads to voter fa­tigue. Each elec­tion cy­cle, vot­ers are bom­barded with mes­sages that im­ply dire con­se­quences if their can­di­date does not win.

This rhet­o­ric of­ten over­shad­ows sub­stan­tive dis­cus­sions about pol­icy and gov­er­nance, as the fo­cus shifts to apoc­a­lyp­tic sce­nar­ios rather than con­struc­tive di­a­logue. As a re­sult, vot­ers feel over­whelmed by the con­stant bar­rage of high-stakes nar­ra­tives, lead­ing to emo­tional ex­haus­tion and dis­en­gage­ment from the po­lit­i­cal pro­cess.

Anx­i­ety and stress

The psy­cho­log­i­cal ef­fects of sen­sa­tion­al­iza­tion fa­tigue are pro­found. Re­search in­di­cates that the stress as­so­ci­ated with po­lit­i­cal anx­i­ety can lead to var­i­ous health is­sues, in­clud­ing sleep dis­tur­bances and chronic ill­ness.

Advertise with us

The im­pli­ca­tions of sen­sa­tion­al­iza­tion fa­tigue ex­tend be­yond in­di­vid­ual well-be­ing; they threaten the demo­cratic pro­cess. When vot­ers be­come de­sen­si­tized to the ur­gency of elec­tions, they may choose to dis­en­gage en­tirely, think­ing their votes do not mat­ter.

This dis­en­gage­ment can lead to lower voter turn­out, which un­der­mines the demo­cratic prin­ci­ple of rep­re­sen­ta­tion. His­tor­i­cally, U.S. voter turn­out has been lower than that of many other de­moc­ra­cies. The sen­sa­tion­al­iza­tion of elec­tions may con­trib­ute to this trend by fos­ter­ing a be­lief that ev­ery elec­tion is a cri­sis, re­sult­ing in burn­out rather than mo­bi­li­za­tion.

Foster­ing a more bal­anced dis­course around elec­tions is es­sen­tial to com­bat­ing sen­sa­tion­al­iza­tion fa­tigue. Pol­i­ti­cians and news out­lets should strive to pro­vide con­text and nu­ance in their mes­sag­ing, fo­cus­ing on the is­sues at stake rather than re­sort­ing to hy­per­bolic claims.

En­cour­ag­ing civic en­gage­ment and civil dis­course through com­mu­nity in­volve­ment and lo­cal ini­tia­tives can shift the fo­cus from na­tional cri­ses to ac­tion­able steps in­di­vid­u­als can take to ef­fect change in their com­mu­ni­ties.

An un­prom­is­ing ap­proach

Pro­mot­ing a more mea­sured ap­proach to po­lit­i­cal dis­course can help re­store faith in the elec­toral sys­tem and en­cour­age mean­ing­ful par­tic­i­pa­tion in de­moc­racy.

Advertise with us

The like­li­hood of a more mea­sured ap­proach isn’t prom­is­ing. Can­di­dates in dif­fer­ent par­ties aren’t as dif­fer­ent as they claim to be, and thus they have to ap­peal to the elec­tor­ate’s emo­tions in­stead of its in­tel­lect.

Elec­tion cy­cle af­ter elec­tion cy­cle, bro­ken prom­ise af­ter bro­ken prom­ise, ev­ery­thing seems to stay the same, as we kick sub­stan­tive pol­icy and gov­er­nance mat­ters down the road un­til the next elec­tion cy­cle, then the next, then the next.

Not to worry, this elec­tion is dif­fer­ent. This elec­tion is the “most im­por­tant elec­tion of our lives,” just like the last one, the one be­fore that, and the one be­fore that.

Nafees Alam is a professor in social work at Boise State University.