In case you missed it, Don­ald Trump has been try­ing to ex­ploit the nat­u­ral di­sas­ter for po­lit­i­cal gain, claim­ing he heard that the fed­eral gov­ern­ment — Pres­i­dent Joe Biden — and North Car­o­lina’s Demo­cratic gov­er­nor are “go­ing out of their way to not help peo­ple in Re­pub­li­can ar­eas.”

This claim has no ba­sis: Ma­jor res­cue and re­cov­ery op­er­a­tions are un­der­way, and sev­eral gov­er­nors of the af­fected states — in­clud­ing Re­pub­li­cans — have praised fed­eral ef­forts. Trump said that Geor­gia’s Re­pub­li­can gov­er­nor, Brian Kemp, was “hav­ing a hard time get­ting the pres­i­dent on the phone.” Kemp said that Biden told him “that if there’s other things we need, just to call him di­rectly.”

But then, at this point, Trump’s cam­paign rests heav­ily on made-up stuff. And he clearly seems to be­lieve that he needs new ma­terial, be­cause the old ma­terial seems to be los­ing some of its ef­fec­tive­ness.

A dys­to­pian fan­tasy world

Lots of pol­i­ti­cians have mis­rep­re­sented their per­sonal his­to­ries or the con­tent of their pol­icy pro­pos­als — Trump does that, too. But he has also con­structed a whole dys­to­pian fan­tasy world, try­ing to per­suade vot­ers that Amer­ica is a na­tion with a col­laps­ing econ­omy over­run by vi­o­lent im­mi­grants.

Advertise with us

In re­al­ity, Amer­ica has low in­fla­tion and low un­em­ploy­ment, and the av­er­age worker’s pur­chas­ing power is higher than it was five years ago. Yes, some Amer­i­cans are strug­gling, but that was as true when Trump was pres­i­dent as it is now.

At the same time, vi­o­lent crime, ho­mi­cides in par­tic­u­lar, which rose sig­nifi­cantly dur­ing Trump’s last year in of­fice, has come down and ap­pears to be con­tin­u­ing to fall.

What’s new is that Trump’s vi­sion of Amer­ica-as-hells­cape seems to be los­ing its po­lit­i­cal mojo. For ex­am­ple, a new Cook Po­lit­i­cal Re­port poll of swing states, while still show­ing Trump with some ad­van­tage on the econ­omy, showed Kamala Har­ris tied on the is­sue of who can best deal with in­fla­tion and the cost of liv­ing, and barely trail­ing on who can best deal with crime and vi­o­lence.

So it must be time to con­jure a new fake source of fear and out­rage.

Where does the in­sin­u­a­tion that Biden is de­ny­ing aid to po­lit­i­cally un­friendly di­sas­ter ar­eas come from? In part it’s pro­jec­tion: Trump was found to have done some­thing akin to that when he was in the White House. In part it in­volves con­demn­ing Biden and Har­ris for not im­me­di­ately vis­it­ing the stricken ar­eas.

Advertise with us

Re­spon­si­ble Har­ris

Biden and Har­ris, though, were just act­ing re­spon­si­bly. In the im­me­di­ate af­ter­math of a nat­u­ral di­sas­ter, a high-pro­file po­lit­i­cal vis­i­tor with a huge se­cu­rity de­tail is the last thing you want — I mean, pol­i­ti­cians aren’t much help res­cu­ing stranded res­i­dents and re­pair­ing roads, while ac­com­mo­dat­ing their visit would di­vert per­son­nel and equip­ment away from the ur­gent task of sav­ing lives and re­stor­ing es­sen­tial ser­vices.

Former FEMA of­fi­cials ex­pressed skep­ti­cism about Trump’s visit to Val­dosta, Geor­gia, soon af­ter the storm passed, not only be­cause he used the visit to po­lit­i­cize a trag­edy, but be­cause such a visit “does eat up re­sources on the ground.”

But the temp­ta­tion for Trump to sug­gest that Biden was play­ing pol­i­tics with his hur­ri­cane re­sponse must have been ir­re­sist­ible, be­cause it so closely fits the tem­plate of many of his other claims.

The key to Trump’s tall tales is to tell his sup­port­ers that ter­ri­ble things are hap­pen­ing some­where out there, even if those things aren’t hap­pen­ing to them or where they can see them. He and JD Vance keep per­pet­u­at­ing claims that Hai­tians are eat­ing pets in Spring­field, Ohio; not many peo­ple have been there them­selves to see that this isn’t true.

He also says that im­mi­grant “thugs” have taken over Aurora, Col­o­rado, and have taken over hun­dreds of towns and cit­ies across Amer­ica, “in­clud­ing the big ones,” he says. “Look at New York.”

Advertise with us

Well, I look at New York — where im­mi­grants are around 36% of the pop­u­la­tion — all the time, and what I see is con­sis­tent with of­fi­cial crime data: It’s one of Amer­ica’s saf­est big cit­ies, a place where peo­ple, in­clud­ing me, walk the streets and take the sub­way ev­ery day. But many Amer­i­cans don’t ex­pe­ri­ence daily life in New York and are pre­pared to be­lieve that it’s a crime-rid­den night­mare — part of a pat­tern in which peo­ple say crime is a se­ri­ous na­tional prob­lem, just not where they live.

Views of the econ­omy show the same pat­tern. This year a Wall Street Jour­nal poll found res­i­dents of seven swing states be­liev­ing that the na­tional econ­omy was do­ing poorly — but that their own states’ econ­o­mies were gen­er­ally do­ing OK.

Fail­ing fear­mon­ger­ing

Un­til re­cently, Trump’s trash-talk­ing of Amer­ica ap­peared to be work­ing po­lit­i­cally. As I said, how­ever, at this point his fear­mon­ger­ing over crime and the econ­omy seems to be los­ing trac­tion.

So now he’s claim­ing that he’s hear­ing the feds have aban­doned hur­ri­cane vic­tims, which may per­suade vot­ers who aren’t in a po­si­tion to wit­ness the huge ef­forts be­ing made, un­der dif­fi­cult con­di­tions, to de­liver es­sen­tial sup­plies and re­store com­mu­ni­ca­tions.

Will it work? I have no idea. What I do know is that it’s more of the same. Trump is prom­is­ing to res­cue us from dire threats that ex­ist only in his mind.

Paul Krugman is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “No, Trump and Vance: Immigrants are good for small cities.”