Dave McCormick ad­mits he never re­ally made much of “brat sum­mer,” the amor­phous Gen Z meme that no one can ex­actly de­fine but that Vice Pres­i­dent Kamala Har­ris adopted in pur­suit of younger vot­ers.

It’s “not se­ri­ous,” said the Re­pub­li­can run­ning for Senate in Penn­syl­va­nia dur­ing an in­ter­view with RealClearPol­i­tics, when in­fla­tion lin­gers, the cost of liv­ing creeps ever higher, and the south­ern bor­der re­mains po­rous. “People are thirst­ing for a se­ri­ous dis­cus­sion about the fu­ture of the coun­try.”

Pol­icy, not vibes

Plenty of Re­pub­li­cans say they want to fo­cus on pol­icy, not vibes, com­plain­ing that Dem­o­crats have got­ten an early pass on sub­stance from the mo­ment Kamala Har­ris re­placed Pres­i­dent Joe Biden as the nom­i­nee. Many strug­gled all sum­mer to re­frame the con­ver­sa­tion.

But while the GOP has lost ground na­tion­ally, Penn­syl­va­nia’s Re­pub­li­can can­di­date for Senate, Dave McCormick, is gain­ing ground. He tied in­cum­bent Sen. Bob Ca­sey in a re­cent CNN/​SSRS poll at 46% and pulled within three points of the Dem­o­crat, who leads by just 48% to 45% in the RealClearPol­i­tics Aver­age, af­ter trail­ing in some polls by as much as dou­ble dig­its ear­lier this year.

Advertise with us

Th­ings are not as en­cour­ag­ing atop the ticket for Re­pub­li­cans. Don­ald Trump strug­gled to de­fine Har­ris. McCormick did it in less than three days.

“This is what vot­ers down bal­lot will be see­ing in ev­ery Senate race from [Ne­vada] to [Penn­syl­va­nia] un­til No­vem­ber,” a Re­pub­li­can op­er­a­tive tex­ted RealClearPol­i­tics less than 72 hours af­ter the Biden switch for Har­ris.

It was a link to a 90-sec­ond McCormick ad that was about to drop on­line. The Re­pub­li­can doesn’t say a sin­gle word in the spot. In­stead, the GOP cam­paign cut an ad to give Har­ris and Ca­sey the spot­light.

“Kamala Har­ris is in­spir­ing and very ca­pa­ble. The more peo­ple get to know her, they’re go­ing to be par­tic­u­larly im­pressed by her abil­ity,” Ca­sey says at the be­gin­ning of the ad be­fore a su­per­cut fol­lows of the vice pres­i­dent of­fer­ing some of her most pro­gres­sive pol­icy pre­scrip­tions like end­ing the Senate fil­i­bus­ter, ban­ning frack­ing, de­crim­i­nal­iz­ing il­le­gal im­mi­gra­tion, and man­dat­ing gun buy­back pro­grams.

“There were no Re­pub­li­can voice­overs, no dark lights or om­i­nous lan­guage,” McCormick said of the ad. “It was just her in her own words, say­ing what she be­lieves. And then it was Sena­tor Ca­sey say­ing, she’s ready to be pres­i­dent to­day.”

Advertise with us

The quotes from Har­ris were from her failed 2020 cam­paign for the Demo­cratic nom­i­na­tion. The goal was guilt by as­so­ci­a­tion: Ty­ing Ca­sey to Har­ris, who was once rated the most lib­eral mem­ber of the Senate.

The McCormick blue­print

A spokes­woman for the Ca­sey cam­paign re­sponded by say­ing that “McCormick is grasp­ing at straws” be­fore not­ing that the sen­a­tor has voted against frack­ing bans al­ready and sup­ported the bi­par­ti­san Senate bor­der bill, which Har­ris pledges to sign into law if elected. The spokes­woman added that “Ca­sey is ac­tu­ally de­liv­er­ing for the Com­mon­wealth by hold­ing greedy cor­po­ra­tions ac­count­able, low­er­ing costs, and sup­port­ing our vet­er­ans and se­niors.”

The in­cum­bent cer­tainly hasn’t held the Demo­cratic nom­i­nee at arm’s length. In Pitts­burgh re­cently, Ca­sey told a crowd that Har­ris “has proven” she is ready not just to be “our com­mander in chief” but is “ready in these next 60 plus days to take on Don­ald Trump and win.”

Re­pub­li­cans are still thrilled with the McCormick blue­print. Trump del­egate Chris­tian Zieg­ler called it “one of the most bru­tal and ef­fec­tive ads I’ve seen in a while” be­fore sug­gest­ing that the ad­ver­tise­ment should be played “ev­ery mo­ment from now un­til No­vem­ber.”

That strat­egy did not ma­teri­al­ize im­me­di­ately, at least on the na­tional stage. Be­fore Trump dubbed his op­po­nent “Com­rade Kamala,” her cam­paign qui­etly dis­avowed her more lib­eral po­si­tions in writ­ten state­ments to the press.

Advertise with us

Dur­ing a CNN in­ter­view at the end of the sum­mer, Har­ris fi­nally dis­avowed her pre­vi­ous calls to ban frack­ing and de­crim­i­nal­ize bor­der cross­ings, stress­ing, how­ever, that “my val­ues have not changed.”

McCormick doesn’t make much of those de­ni­als, of course. He de­fined the race dur­ing an in­ter­view with RealClearPol­i­tics by ask­ing if vot­ers “are will­ing to take the risk that she ac­tu­ally be­lieves in all the rad­i­cal stuff she once said she be­lieved in.” His op­po­nent, he added, “has been a sure vote for the pol­i­cies of Kamala Har­ris.” Run­ning a tape of vin­tage Har­ris “is the play­book in Penn­syl­va­nia.”

McCormick and Ca­sey have al­ready agreed to a de­bate next month in a state that is seen as key not only to Re­pub­li­can chances of re­tak­ing the Senate but also to win­ning back the White House.

A su­per close race

“Penn­syl­va­nia is go­ing to be su­per close,” McCormick pre­dicted. “I sus­pect it’ll be su­per close for Pres­i­dent Trump. I think he will win, but it is go­ing to be a close race, and I think he knows it. That’s why he is spend­ing so much time here.”

De­fin­ing the op­po­si­tion will be key for Re­pub­li­cans in the state and na­tion­ally. “I’m pretty con­fi­dent that when peo­ple see who Kamala Har­ris is, Pres­i­dent Trump will pre­vail,” McCormick said of the con­trast. “And I’m hop­ing that if I con­tinue to run a strong cam­paign, and they see how weak and lib­eral Bob Ca­sey is, that I will pre­vail.”

Advertise with us

Thus ends “brat sum­mer” for McCormick. The con­fus­ing term de­fies def­i­ni­tion. The poll num­bers do not. He is the can­di­date who has surged to a tie in Penn­syl­va­nia and likely rep­resents the best chance Re­pub­li­cans have to re­take the Senate.

Philip Wegmann is a writer for RealClearPolitics. His previous article was “A conservative who wants to kill Citizens United and the power of super PACs.”