There were local elections in several German states last week, with a strong showing by the Alternative for Germany, or AfD, a right-wing extremist party. I am not any kind of an expert on Germany, but I can say as an American that the rise of Germany’s modern far right — and especially its concentration of support in economically depressed areas — looks remarkably familiar to ours.
In some important respects Thuringia, the German state where the AfD won more votes than any other party, resembles West Virginia. Like West Virginia, it’s a place the 21st-century economy seems to have left behind, whose population is in decline, with younger people in particular leaving for opportunities elsewhere. And West Virginia strongly supports Donald Trump and his party, whose doctrines bear considerable resemblance to those of the AfD.
The rise of Make America Great Again does seem connected to the economic decline of much of rural and small-town America, and West Virginia epitomizes both the economic and political problems of left-behind regions.
Men not working
What stands out when you compare West Virginia with other parts of America is the number of men not working. In a comparison between West Virginia and New Jersey, of adults ages 20 to 64 who didn’t have jobs in 2019 (before the pandemic), adults of both sexes were much more likely not to be working in West Virginia, although the gap was larger for men (67% versus 43%).
Why is not working a problem? You aren’t earning wages, but the problem goes deeper than that. Jobs are a source of dignity and a sense of self-worth. People who aren’t working when they feel they should be feel shame, which all too easily turns into anger, a desire to blame someone else and lash out.
The lack of jobs for men helps extremist political movements that appeal to angry men. Why are jobs, especially for men, so hard to get in West Virginia?
Read More
Native-born West Virginians aren’t losing jobs to immigrants because the state hardly has any immigrants. The heartland isn’t suffering because trade deficits are undermining our manufacturing sector. For while America has indeed been running trade deficits, Germany has been running huge surpluses — yet is experiencing similar discontent and anger.
So what’s the matter with the heartland? The most likely story is that the 21st-century economy is driven by knowledge-intensive industries that flourish in metropolitan areas with highly educated workforces. This has led to a self-reinforcing process in which jobs migrate to places with lots of college graduates, and college graduates migrate to the same places, leaving less-educated places like West Virginia stranded.
Helping the heartland
Is the solution, then, for the regions that have benefited from this process to provide aid to those on the losing end? They actually do in effect provide such aid, although until recently it was the result of aid to individuals rather than reflecting a deliberate “place-based” policy.
Here’s what I mean: The federal government provides a lot of support to U.S. citizens via Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. Poor states receive the full benefit of these programs, but pay relatively little in federal taxes. The result is huge implicit aid to lower-income states.
In effect, West Virginia received “foreign aid” from wealthier states of almost 12% of GDP, which is huge.
The state also benefited immensely from the Affordable Care Act, which greatly reduced the number of its residents without health insurance.
You might say that the federal social safety net increases people’s incomes but doesn’t create jobs. But that’s not true. Social Security supports consumer spending, which creates jobs in retail and more. Medicare and Medicaid support jobs in hospitals, doctors’ offices, and so on.
West Virginia may still think of itself as a coal-mining state, but by the numbers it has long been more accurately described as a health care state, with much of its employment ultimately driven by those federal dollars.
What is true, and may partially explain political rage in left-behind regions, is that many of the jobs federal aid creates tend to be female-coded, certainly more so than coal mining — which may in turn explain why the problem of adults without jobs appears to be worse, at least in terms of its political weight, for men than for women.
That said, the Biden-Harris administration has been making a serious effort to promote manufacturing as part of its industrial policies — an effort that seems to be disproportionately helping heartland states.
Their politicians
The odd thing is that the politicians angry heartland voters support — Trump received more than twice as many votes in West Virginia as Joe Biden in 2020 — oppose the very programs that aid these depressed areas. Trump tried, in effect, to kill the Affordable Care Act. Not a single Republican voted for the Inflation Reduction Act, which is helping to create manufacturing jobs in the heartland.
Adam Tooze, who does know something about German political economy, tells us that while the AfD talks a lot about “social distress” in lagging regions, this “does not translate into a platform that supports greater state spending.”
In Germany as in America, voters in left-behind regions are, understandably, angry — and they channel this anger into support for politicians who will make their plight worse.
Paul Krugman is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “America must support Ukraine the way we supported Britain in WWII.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.