There were lo­cal elec­tions in sev­eral Ger­man states last week, with a strong show­ing by the Al­ter­na­tive for Ger­many, or AfD, a right-wing ex­trem­ist party. I am not any kind of an ex­pert on Ger­many, but I can say as an Amer­i­can that the rise of Ger­many’s mod­ern far right — and es­pe­cially its con­cen­tra­tion of sup­port in eco­nom­i­cally de­pressed ar­eas — looks re­mark­ably fa­mil­iar to ours.

In some im­por­tant re­spects Thur­in­gia, the Ger­man state where the AfD won more votes than any other party, re­sem­bles West Vir­ginia. Like West Vir­ginia, it’s a place the 21st-cen­tury econ­omy seems to have left be­hind, whose pop­u­la­tion is in de­cline, with younger peo­ple in par­tic­u­lar leav­ing for op­por­tu­ni­ties else­where. And West Vir­ginia strongly sup­ports Don­ald Trump and his party, whose doc­trines bear con­sid­er­able re­sem­blance to those of the AfD.

The rise of Make Amer­ica Great Again does seem con­nected to the eco­nomic de­cline of much of ru­ral and small-town Amer­ica, and West Vir­ginia epit­o­mizes both the eco­nomic and po­lit­i­cal prob­lems of left-be­hind re­gions.

Men not work­ing

What stands out when you com­pare West Vir­ginia with other parts of Amer­ica is the num­ber of men not work­ing. In a com­par­i­son be­tween West Vir­ginia and New Jer­sey, of adults ages 20 to 64 who didn’t have jobs in 2019 (be­fore the pan­demic), adults of both sexes were much more likely not to be work­ing in West Vir­ginia, al­though the gap was larger for men (67% ver­sus 43%).

Advertise with us

Why is not work­ing a prob­lem? You aren’t earn­ing wages, but the prob­lem goes deeper than that. Jobs are a source of dig­nity and a sense of self-worth. People who aren’t work­ing when they feel they should be feel shame, which all too eas­ily turns into an­ger, a de­sire to blame some­one else and lash out.

The lack of jobs for men helps ex­trem­ist po­lit­i­cal move­ments that ap­peal to an­gry men. Why are jobs, es­pe­cially for men, so hard to get in West Vir­ginia?

Na­tive-born West Vir­gin­ians aren’t los­ing jobs to im­mi­grants be­cause the state hardly has any im­mi­grants. The heart­land isn’t suf­fer­ing be­cause trade def­i­cits are un­der­min­ing our man­u­fac­tur­ing sec­tor. For while Amer­ica has in­deed been run­ning trade def­i­cits, Ger­many has been run­ning huge sur­pluses — yet is ex­pe­ri­enc­ing sim­i­lar dis­con­tent and an­ger.

So what’s the mat­ter with the heart­land? The most likely story is that the 21st-cen­tury econ­omy is driven by knowl­edge-in­ten­sive in­dus­tries that flour­ish in met­ro­pol­i­tan ar­eas with highly ed­u­cated work­forces. This has led to a self-re­in­forc­ing pro­cess in which jobs mi­grate to places with lots of col­lege grad­u­ates, and col­lege grad­u­ates mi­grate to the same places, leav­ing less-ed­u­cated places like West Vir­ginia stranded.

Help­ing the heart­land

Is the solu­tion, then, for the re­gions that have ben­e­fited from this pro­cess to pro­vide aid to those on the los­ing end? They ac­tu­ally do in ef­fect pro­vide such aid, al­though un­til re­cently it was the re­sult of aid to in­di­vid­u­als rather than re­flect­ing a de­lib­er­ate “place-based” pol­icy.

Advertise with us

Here’s what I mean: The fed­eral gov­ern­ment pro­vides a lot of sup­port to U.S. cit­i­zens via So­cial Se­cu­rity, Med­i­care and Med­ic­aid. Poor states re­ceive the full ben­e­fit of these pro­grams, but pay rel­a­tively lit­tle in fed­eral taxes. The re­sult is huge im­plicit aid to lower-in­come states.

In ef­fect, West Vir­ginia re­ceived “for­eign aid” from wealth­ier states of al­most 12% of GDP, which is huge.

The state also ben­e­fited im­mensely from the Af­ford­able Care Act, which greatly re­duced the num­ber of its res­i­dents with­out health in­sur­ance.

You might say that the fed­eral so­cial safety net in­creases peo­ple’s in­comes but doesn’t cre­ate jobs. But that’s not true. So­cial Se­cu­rity sup­ports con­sumer spend­ing, which cre­ates jobs in re­tail and more. Med­i­care and Med­ic­aid sup­port jobs in hos­pi­tals, doc­tors’ of­fices, and so on.

West Vir­ginia may still think of it­self as a coal-min­ing state, but by the num­bers it has long been more ac­cu­rately de­scribed as a health care state, with much of its em­ploy­ment ul­ti­mately driven by those fed­eral dol­lars.

Advertise with us

What is true, and may par­tially ex­plain po­lit­i­cal rage in left-be­hind re­gions, is that many of the jobs fed­eral aid cre­ates tend to be fe­male-coded, cer­tainly more so than coal min­ing — which may in turn ex­plain why the prob­lem of adults with­out jobs ap­pears to be worse, at least in terms of its po­lit­i­cal weight, for men than for women.

That said, the Biden-Har­ris ad­min­is­tra­tion has been mak­ing a se­ri­ous ef­fort to pro­mote man­u­fac­tur­ing as part of its in­dus­trial pol­i­cies — an ef­fort that seems to be dis­pro­por­tion­ately help­ing heart­land states.

Their pol­i­ti­cians

The odd thing is that the pol­i­ti­cians an­gry heart­land vot­ers sup­port — Trump re­ceived more than twice as many votes in West Vir­ginia as Joe Biden in 2020 — op­pose the very pro­grams that aid these de­pressed ar­eas. Trump tried, in ef­fect, to kill the Af­ford­able Care Act. Not a sin­gle Re­pub­li­can voted for the In­fla­tion Re­duc­tion Act, which is help­ing to cre­ate man­u­fac­tur­ing jobs in the heart­land.

Adam Tooze, who does know some­thing about Ger­man po­lit­i­cal econ­omy, tells us that while the AfD talks a lot about “so­cial dis­tress” in lag­ging re­gions, this “does not trans­late into a plat­form that sup­ports greater state spend­ing.”

In Ger­many as in Amer­ica, vot­ers in left-be­hind re­gions are, un­der­stand­ably, an­gry — and they chan­nel this an­ger into sup­port for pol­i­ti­cians who will make their plight worse.

Paul Krugman is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “America must support Ukraine the way we supported Britain in WWII.”