The na­ture of work un­der­went a pro­found shift dur­ing the covid pan­demic, but we’ve been here be­fore. In 1933 the Senate passed, and Pres­i­dent Frank­lin D. Roosevelt sup­ported, a bill to re­duce the stan­dard work­week to only 30 hours.

Amer­i­cans have worked hard, per­haps too hard, since the Co­lo­nial era. A phi­los­o­phy of work­ing from sun­rise to sun­set pre­vailed. The Mas­sa­chu­setts col­ony even passed a law re­quir­ing a 10-hour min­i­mum work­day.

Enslaved peo­ple, whose la­bor prof­its were sto­len, gen­er­ally worked 10 to 16 hours a day, six days a week. Some stud­ies es­ti­mate that when slav­ery ended, the hours African Amer­i­cans spent work­ing fell by 26 to 35%.

From 70 hours to 40

In the 1830s, work­ers in man­u­fac­tur­ing were on the job roughly 70 hours a week, of­ten in hor­ren­dous and even deadly con­di­tions. By the 1890s, that had dropped to about 60 hours. This pe­riod also saw the rise of la­bor unions, the cre­ation of La­bor Day as a na­tional hol­i­day, Grand Eight Hours Leagues and the motto “Eight hours for work, eight hours for rest, eight hours for what you will.” At that time, work­weeks were gen­er­ally six days, with Sun­day off.

Advertise with us

In 1926, Ford CEO Henry Ford in­sti­tuted a five-day, 40-hour work­week for all em­ploy­ees, along with a pay raise. He ar­gued that his em­ploy­ees were more pro­duc­tive in fewer hours; crit­ics were skep­ti­cal they could be pro­duc­tive enough to make up the dif­fer­ence.

Then came the stock mar­ket crash, the Great De­pres­sion and record un­em­ploy­ment. A re­duced work­week was a ma­jor is­sue in the 1932 elec­tion, and both can­di­dates had ideas, ac­cord­ing to his­to­rian Ben­ja­min Hun­ni­cutt in his book “Work With­out End.”

Roosevelt pushed fed­eral leg­is­la­tion to es­tab­lish shorter work hours — some­thing he had al­ready done in New York — while Hoover backed vol­un­tary share-the-work drives. The idea was that if work­ers had shorter hours, no one would be un­em­ployed, even if ev­ery­one ended up mak­ing less money, though unions were also push­ing for a de­cent fed­eral min­i­mum wage.

After Roosevelt won the elec­tion but be­fore he took of­fice, Sen. Hugo Black (D-Ala.) in­tro­duced a bill backed by the Amer­i­can Fed­er­a­tion of La­bor to tem­po­rar­ily shorten the work­week to 30 hours —- six hours a day, five days a week.

For a while, it had Roosevelt’s sup­port, and he be­gan ne­go­ti­at­ing with busi­ness lead­ers be­hind closed doors. If they would shorten the work­week to 30 hours vol­un­tar­ily, then he would go easy on an­ti­trust re­forms, he said, ac­cord­ing to Hun­ni­cutt.

Advertise with us

As soon as Roosevelt took of­fice on March 4, 1933, he called Con­gress into a spe­cial ses­sion, be­gin­ning what would be­come its most pro­duc­tive streak in his­tory. Dur­ing the next 100 days, Roosevelt and his Cabi­net guided more than a dozen ma­jor bills through the House and Senate, sta­bi­liz­ing the bank­ing sys­tem, reg­u­lat­ing Wall Street, sub­si­diz­ing farm­ers and get­ting re­lief checks into the hands of the un­em­ployed.

Al­most 30

Amid this flurry, on April 6, the Senate passed Black’s 30-hour week bill 53 to 30, in a bi­par­ti­san vote. Sup­port­ers claimed it would cre­ate six mil­lion jobs. It was ex­pected to pass the House.

Busi­ness lead­ers were up in arms. “In­stead of look­ing at the in­crease in lei­sure as in­ev­i­ta­ble or as po­ten­tially ben­e­fi­cial,” Hun­ni­cutt wrote, they feared that if work­ers got a taste of a 30-hour week, they would never want to go back to lon­ger work­days, and the law would be­come per­ma­nent. Men of in­dus­try held emer­gency meet­ings in Chi­cago and Phil­a­del­phia, and Perkins, who also sup­ported a fed­eral min­i­mum wage, was flooded with mes­sages of op­po­si­tion.

At the White House, as Roosevelt worked on a com­pre­hen­sive re­cov­ery plan, he be­gan to turn against the 30-hour week. What if, rather than hav­ing peo­ple share avail­able work, there was just more work?

As the plan for a mas­sive pub­lic works pro­gram took shape, sup­port for the 30-hour week col­lapsed. Roosevelt used the threat of it as le­ver­age to get in­dus­try lead­ers to agree to ban child la­bor, set a mod­est min­i­mum wage and limit the stan­dard work­week to 40 hours, Hun­ni­cutt wrote.

Advertise with us

The re­sult­ing Na­tional In­dus­trial Re­cov­ery Act was a tri­umph, but in May 1935, the Supreme Court de­clared it un­con­sti­tu­tional in a de­ci­sion that so an­gered Roosevelt that he threat­ened to ex­pand the court.

Still 40 hours a week

In 1938, the min­i­mum wage, 40-hour week and child la­bor ban re­turned, in the Fair La­bor Stan­dards Act. Labor Secretary Frances Perkins asked La­bor Depart­ment law­yers to draft a law that had a bet­ter chance of with­stand­ing ju­di­cial scru­tiny.

And they had an­other ace up their sleeve. A few months ear­lier, Roosevelt had nom­i­nated his first justice for the Supreme Court. He chose Hugo Black.

In 1956, Vice Pres­i­dent Rich­ard M. Nixon pre­dicted a 32-hour, four-day work­week in the “not too dis­tant fu­ture.” It hasn’t hap­pened. In a 2014 Gallup poll, half of full-time em­ployed re­spon­dents re­ported work­ing 41 hours or more per week and 18% said they worked more than 60. Only 8% said they worked fewer than 40.

Gillian Brockell is a staff writer for The Washington Post’s history blog, Retropolis.