The nature of work underwent a profound shift during the covid pandemic, but we’ve been here before. In 1933 the Senate passed, and President Franklin D. Roosevelt supported, a bill to reduce the standard workweek to only 30 hours.
Americans have worked hard, perhaps too hard, since the Colonial era. A philosophy of working from sunrise to sunset prevailed. The Massachusetts colony even passed a law requiring a 10-hour minimum workday.
Enslaved people, whose labor profits were stolen, generally worked 10 to 16 hours a day, six days a week. Some studies estimate that when slavery ended, the hours African Americans spent working fell by 26 to 35%.
From 70 hours to 40
In the 1830s, workers in manufacturing were on the job roughly 70 hours a week, often in horrendous and even deadly conditions. By the 1890s, that had dropped to about 60 hours. This period also saw the rise of labor unions, the creation of Labor Day as a national holiday, Grand Eight Hours Leagues and the motto “Eight hours for work, eight hours for rest, eight hours for what you will.” At that time, workweeks were generally six days, with Sunday off.
In 1926, Ford CEO Henry Ford instituted a five-day, 40-hour workweek for all employees, along with a pay raise. He argued that his employees were more productive in fewer hours; critics were skeptical they could be productive enough to make up the difference.
Then came the stock market crash, the Great Depression and record unemployment. A reduced workweek was a major issue in the 1932 election, and both candidates had ideas, according to historian Benjamin Hunnicutt in his book “Work Without End.”
Roosevelt pushed federal legislation to establish shorter work hours — something he had already done in New York — while Hoover backed voluntary share-the-work drives. The idea was that if workers had shorter hours, no one would be unemployed, even if everyone ended up making less money, though unions were also pushing for a decent federal minimum wage.
After Roosevelt won the election but before he took office, Sen. Hugo Black (D-Ala.) introduced a bill backed by the American Federation of Labor to temporarily shorten the workweek to 30 hours —- six hours a day, five days a week.
For a while, it had Roosevelt’s support, and he began negotiating with business leaders behind closed doors. If they would shorten the workweek to 30 hours voluntarily, then he would go easy on antitrust reforms, he said, according to Hunnicutt.
As soon as Roosevelt took office on March 4, 1933, he called Congress into a special session, beginning what would become its most productive streak in history. During the next 100 days, Roosevelt and his Cabinet guided more than a dozen major bills through the House and Senate, stabilizing the banking system, regulating Wall Street, subsidizing farmers and getting relief checks into the hands of the unemployed.
Almost 30
Amid this flurry, on April 6, the Senate passed Black’s 30-hour week bill 53 to 30, in a bipartisan vote. Supporters claimed it would create six million jobs. It was expected to pass the House.
Business leaders were up in arms. “Instead of looking at the increase in leisure as inevitable or as potentially beneficial,” Hunnicutt wrote, they feared that if workers got a taste of a 30-hour week, they would never want to go back to longer workdays, and the law would become permanent. Men of industry held emergency meetings in Chicago and Philadelphia, and Perkins, who also supported a federal minimum wage, was flooded with messages of opposition.
At the White House, as Roosevelt worked on a comprehensive recovery plan, he began to turn against the 30-hour week. What if, rather than having people share available work, there was just more work?
As the plan for a massive public works program took shape, support for the 30-hour week collapsed. Roosevelt used the threat of it as leverage to get industry leaders to agree to ban child labor, set a modest minimum wage and limit the standard workweek to 40 hours, Hunnicutt wrote.
The resulting National Industrial Recovery Act was a triumph, but in May 1935, the Supreme Court declared it unconstitutional in a decision that so angered Roosevelt that he threatened to expand the court.
Still 40 hours a week
In 1938, the minimum wage, 40-hour week and child labor ban returned, in the Fair Labor Standards Act. Labor Secretary Frances Perkins asked Labor Department lawyers to draft a law that had a better chance of withstanding judicial scrutiny.
And they had another ace up their sleeve. A few months earlier, Roosevelt had nominated his first justice for the Supreme Court. He chose Hugo Black.
In 1956, Vice President Richard M. Nixon predicted a 32-hour, four-day workweek in the “not too distant future.” It hasn’t happened. In a 2014 Gallup poll, half of full-time employed respondents reported working 41 hours or more per week and 18% said they worked more than 60. Only 8% said they worked fewer than 40.
Gillian Brockell is a staff writer for The Washington Post’s history blog, Retropolis.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.