Tens of thousands of people were expected to march on the Democratic National Convention to protest the loss of innocent lives in the Gaza Strip. But by early Monday afternoon, only a fraction had shown up.

The speakers were spirited, to be sure. But the park seemed half empty; a stack of signs depicting “Killer Kamala” and “Genocide Joe” — the ones that had freaky laser beams for eyes — lay unused in a pile in an empty corner of the park. It was not 1968.

The Gaza protests have lost some momentum since the switch from President Joe Biden. But that doesn’t mean the battle over the soul of the Democratic Party has been called off.

The party still faces a long-term moral quandary of how to square its rhetoric about being the party of freedom, equality and racial justice with the virtually unconditional support it has offered to a far-right government in Israel that is accused of starving and bombarding large numbers of civilians in Gaza since the brutal Oct. 7 attack by Hamas.

Advertise with us

Unwanted stepchildren

At the Democratic National Convention, some delegates are demanding a cease-fire and an end to the unconditional supply of arms to Israel. But they are being treated like the unwanted stepchildren at the family reunion.

The party agreed to hold a human rights panel on Monday afternoon to highlight the suffering of Palestinians, but that didn’t feel like equal treatment. It wasn’t held on the main stage or during a prime time television slot, as the families of some of the hostages taken from Israel are expected to get.

The truth is that Palestinians have been struggling for decades to have their full humanity recognized by American politicians, including those in the Democratic Party. Jim Zogby, a founder of the Arab American Institute, has been at it since the 1980s. For years, he said, candidates from both parties returned donations from Arab Americans and avoided being associated with Arab American organizers out of fear of offending pro-Israel groups.

Jesse Jackson was among the first to bring Arab Americans into the fold. They helped his Rainbow Coalition win a surprise victory in the Michigan caucuses in 1988. He garnered enough delegates at the convention in Atlanta that year to force a debate about U.S. policy in the Middle East.

Zogby made the case that the Democratic platform should call for “mutual recognition, territorial compromise and self-determination for both Israelis and Palestinians.” Rep. Chuck Schumer of New York forcefully rebutted him. A vote on the new language was never held, but simply hearing the word “Palestinian” uttered on the convention floor — “the P word,” Zogby called it — felt like a watershed moment.

Advertise with us

Little change since 1988

Yet stunningly little has changed since 1988. In 2016, Hillary Clinton’s campaign was willing to adopt some of Sen. Bernie Sanders’s views, like support for a higher minimum wage and the legalization of marijuana, but didn’t budge on Israel and refused to allow the word “occupation” of the Palestinian territories to be included in the party platform, according to Matt Duss, a Middle East expert who later worked on Sanders’ staff.

“The same old people trot out the same old talking points, representing an outdated view of Israel that is not only no longer accurate but it also doesn’t represent where Democratic Party voters are today,” Duss told me.

A Gallup poll in March 2023 showed, for the first time, that Democrats’ sympathies lie more with the Palestinians than the Israelis, a shift that happened gradually over the last decade. That may be, in part, why Schumer, now the Senate majority leader, made his extraordinary speech about Israel earlier this year, in which he called directly for a change in leadership.

But for the most part, the way elected officials vote and talk about the conflict hasn’t kept up with Democratic voters’ sentiments. That’s why there has been a concerted, but so far mostly thwarted, effort this year by delegates from the “uncommitted movement” to change the party from within.

These delegates are Democrats who believe in the system and don’t want to elect Donald Trump — who has used the word Palestinian as a slur and appears to have been ready to accept the annexation of the West Bank.

Advertise with us

The party will change

“Understanding that she is the vice president, and the president sets the policy right now, we need her to tell us how she plans to stop sending weapons to be used to kill civilians,” said Abbas Alawieh, a founder of the Uncommitted National Movement.

So far, there’s no indication that Harris will say any such thing. But after the human rights panel, Zogby was in good spirits, full of optimism about the party’s capacity to change.

“They created a space for this discussion, and that’s never happened before,” he told me, referring to the panel. The room was packed, and some of Harris’ advisers were there, he said. “There’s a sense that she wants to turn a corner. Does it happen tomorrow? I don’t think so. But it will happen.”

Farah Stockman is a member of the editorial board of The New York Times, where this first appeared. Her previous article was “