I am now 'uncommitted' to Joe Biden for one reason: that the ongoing Israel-Hamas war, which began with the horrific surprise murder of close to 1,200 lives in Israel in a single evening and has culminated in more than 32,000 deaths in Gaza, occurs with his complicity.

The escalating death toll in Gaza haunts my conscience and I direct my outrage towards our president. This is the man who styles himself as a compassionate listener and talented negotiator.

Mass deaths

My tax dollars fund the munitions that he twice bypassed Congress to sell to Israel to prolong and support this war. The mass civilian deaths, the unprecedented number of journalists and healthcare workers killed, hospitals destroyed, the denial of delivery of aid to Gaza, the widespread starvation — all of these circumstances would lead a compassionate person to take substantive steps to leverage a ceasefire.

The president could withhold military or financial aid to Israel, but he won’t. It seems that he considers it a non-negotiable obligation to provide Israel with unwavering military assistance. One can imagine the political fallout that would occur for a sitting president to reconsider such a policy in an election year.

Advertise with us

Certainly, accusations of anti-Semitism and the unfair betrayal of a close ally would follow such a move, but at what point does one hold an ally accountable for possible war crimes and disproportionate military responses? When does the righteousness of Israel’s cause or its ends, no longer justify the means? At what point does one call Biden’s compassion into question — when the death toll in Gaza hits 40,000? 50,000? 100,000?

The death toll of Oct. 7 on the population of Israel was described as comparable to fifteen “9/11s.” Per capita, slightly more than one person was killed per every 10,000 Israelis. But by this metric, the death toll in Gaza has surpassed 1,420 “9/11s,” with more than one person killed per every 100 Gazans.

Rather than besiege and bomb densely populated areas, Israel must allow a cease-fire, provide safe havens for civilians, supply Gazans with massive amounts of aid, and resolve the current humanitarian crisis. As Page Fortna, a professor of U.S. foreign and security policy, explains, while some safe havens might still exist in Gaza, Israel will need to take a much bolder step and set up well-equipped camps inside Israel proper.

This plan would not be popular within Israel, since Israelis would have no desire to keep Gazans within its 1967 borders. However, such circumstances credibly reassure Gazans that they would be permitted to return to their homes immediately after the war.

Even with Trump

I am well aware that a second term for Donald Trump might unleash an incalculable torrent of domestic and foreign policies that will harm Arabs, Muslims, Palestinians, and many marginalized populations in the United States for years to come. I have further argued with Arab and Muslim Americans that a far-right populist figure facing multiple criminal indictments like Donald Trump represents an existential threat to American democracy.

Advertise with us

But I can no longer argue that citizens have a moral obligation to vote for President Biden this November. I am too exhausted to continue defending him as a worthy alternative.

I’m not sure when I reached the tipping point. Perhaps it was the decision of the Israeli army to begin bombarding the southern town of Rafah after instructing more than a million Gazans to flee there for safety. Perhaps it is that this conflict is nearing its six month and the President has failed to act boldly to end it.

I acknowledge the president’s recent decision to begin airdropping aid to Gaza, but airdrops are seven times more expensive and far less effective than ground-delivered aid. C-130 aircraft carry twenty-one tons of cargo, which is the equivalent of only one truckload. While aid reaching the Gaza Strip was insufficient even before Oct. 7, Gazans depended on 500 trucks of aid daily.

As Fortna has argued, if Israel wants to defeat Hamas both militarily and politically, it must provide massive amounts of humanitarian aid to shelter and feed Palestinians in safe havens, including within Israel proper. Israel has the capacity to provide the necessary aid. The roundabout method of having the U.S. deliver aid by pier or air is unnecessary given this capacity.

She correctly argues that Israel should deliver this aid itself and that it is in its own self-interest to do so. “By providing the aid itself, Israel need not worry about checking it for weapons” or other prohibited items. Both President Biden and Israel must act boldly to end what experts have described as “the worst level of child malnutrition anywhere in the world” and conditions that make famine "imminent" in Gaza.

Advertise with us

Voting “uncommitted”

Hundreds of thousands of Democrats are voting “uncommitted” this primary season to protest the President’s policies in this war. As a result, Michigan, Minnesota, and Hawaii are now sending uncommitted delegates to the Democratic National Convention this August. I understand why my friends and family are heartbroken and uncommitted this primary season. I am too.

Nebil Husayn is associate professor of religious studies at the University of Miami and a faculty affiliate of the Center for Global Black Studies at the University of Miami, and author of “Caliphate and Imamate.”