Apart from Don­ald Trump, the ba­sic prob­lem of the Re­pub­li­can Party — the ex­tent to which it has been cap­tured by ni­hi­lists and ide­o­log­i­cal ex­trem­ists — is that the party is un­teth­ered from any elec­toral dy­namic that might force it to mod­er­ate its be­hav­ior.

For ex­am­ple, de­spite the much-dis­cussed will­ing­ness of some Black and His­panic men to sup­port the oc­ca­sional Re­pub­li­can can­di­date (mostly Trump), the Re­pub­li­can co­a­li­tion is still over­whelm­ingly white and con­ser­va­tive and spread through­out the na­tion’s ru­ral and ex­u­r­ban coun­ties.

In the­ory, there are ten­sions within the Re­pub­li­can co­a­li­tion. The party’s com­mit­ment to the in­ter­ests of the su­per­rich is an un­easy fit, to say the least, with the most down­scale el­e­ments of its blue-col­lar con­stit­u­ency. In prac­tice, though, those ten­sions are sub­sumed by com­mit­ments to a shared cul­tural (and of­ten re­li­gious) iden­tity.

The ho­mo­ge­neous party

Dem­o­crats must nav­i­gate a large and frac­tious al­li­ance of in­ter­ests, some of which are at odds or cross-pur­poses with each other. Re­pub­li­cans, by con­trast, can sail the rel­a­tively calm wa­ters of de­mo­graphic ho­mo­ge­ne­ity. But what this also means is that there is no force in­ter­nal to the Re­pub­li­can Party’s elec­toral co­a­li­tion that might force its rep­re­sen­ta­tives onto a dif­fer­ent path.

Advertise with us

In the ab­sence of an al­ter­na­tive de­mo­graphic or ide­o­log­i­cal base from which to build in­flu­ence, the am­bi­tious Re­pub­li­can pol­i­ti­cian has one op­tion if he or she hopes to ad­vance within the party: rigid com­mit­ment to ide­o­log­i­cal pu­rity. The only way to get ahead is to out-con­ser­va­tive — or now, out-MAGA — your ri­vals.

There is no in­cen­tive for any­thing else. If you want to win a pri­mary, if you want to as­cend to lead­er­ship, if you want to avoid the ire of con­ser­va­tive me­dia, if you want to be on a na­tional ticket, then you can­not have en­e­mies to your right.

There is no room, in the na­tional Re­pub­li­can Party, for the mod­er­ate Re­pub­li­can gov­er­nor of a Demo­cratic state — the Larry Ho­gans and Char­lie Bak­ers of Amer­i­can pol­i­tics. There is not even room, it turns out, for the prag­matic con­ser­va­tives of the party — the Nikki Ha­leys and Mitt Rom­neys.

Osten­si­bly, the pres­sure to win a gen­eral elec­tion should work to curb and cur­tail this dy­namic. But the de­mo­graphic ho­mo­ge­ne­ity of the Re­pub­li­can co­a­li­tion con­fers a dis­tinct ad­van­tage on the party: It gives it a high floor from which to en­gage the bi­en­nial con­test for con­trol of the na­tional gov­ern­ment.

Well-dis­trib­uted Re­pub­li­cans

When enough states in the union are low den­sity and low pop­u­la­tion, the party that dom­i­nates the na­tion’s ru­ral ar­eas al­ready con­trols nearly half the seats in the Senate and has a sig­nifi­cant ad­van­tage in the House of Rep­re­sen­ta­tives as well.

Advertise with us

What’s more, the ef­fi­cient dis­tri­bu­tion of Re­pub­li­can and Re­pub­li­can-lean­ing vot­ers — ru­ral and ex­u­r­ban Amer­ica ex­tends through ev­ery state — means that, as we’ve seen in two of the last six pres­i­den­tial elec­tions, a Re­pub­li­can pres­i­den­tial can­di­date does not need to win the most votes na­tion­wide to win the Elec­toral Col­lege and there­fore the White House.

The abil­ity to win power with­out win­ning votes is a pow­er­ful dis­in­cen­tive to change. As we see with Trump’s strug­gle to break out of his MAGA echo cham­ber, it stunts a pol­i­ti­cian’s — and a party’s — abil­ity to reach be­yond the faith­ful.

It has also stim­u­lated, among the Re­pub­li­can rank-and-file, a real dis­dain for what Re­pub­li­can Sen. Mike Lee called “rank de­moc­racy,” ex­em­pli­fied in the as­ser­tion that the United States is a “re­pub­lic, not a de­moc­racy.” It makes sense: If more de­moc­racy would make it harder for Re­pub­li­cans to win, then more de­moc­racy can’t be good.

The United States will al­ways have a con­ser­va­tive party, but Amer­i­can de­moc­racy needs that party to be com­mit­ted to the main­te­nance of our demo­cratic in­sti­tu­tions. The only way to plot a path from here to there is to forc­i­bly change the in­cen­tives within the Re­pub­li­can Party, which is to say, to change the rules of the game. A more demo­cratic Amer­i­can de­moc­racy — where ma­jor­i­ties elect and ma­jor­i­ties rule — would force the Re­pub­li­can Party to try, once again, to com­pete for na­tional ma­jor­i­ties.

The re­forms are straight­for­ward. End the Elec­toral Col­lege and move to a na­tional pop­u­lar vote. End par­ti­san ger­ry­man­der­ing and ex­per­i­ment with forms of vot­ing that might en­able more party com­pe­ti­tion, like fu­sion, which would let two or more par­ties nom­i­nate the same can­di­date for of­fice.

Advertise with us

End the fil­i­bus­ter and pass a new, more ro­bust Vot­ing Rights Act. Grant Wash­ing­ton, D.C., state­hood in ac­cor­dance with the wishes of a ma­jor­ity of its res­i­dents. And pur­sue re­form of the en­tire fed­eral ju­di­ciary, so that the Supreme Court, which has been too happy to help Re­pub­li­cans en­trench mi­nor­ity rule in the states, can­not take an ax to this agenda.

Demo­cratic con­fron­ta­tion

If the aim of both the Demo­cratic Party and its al­lies is to pro­tect and de­fend Amer­i­can de­moc­racy, then it can­not avoid a con­fron­ta­tion with those as­pects of the Amer­i­can sys­tem that en­abled the Re­pub­li­can spi­ral into ni­hi­lism.

If Dem­o­crats win con­trol of Wash­ing­ton in No­vem­ber, they should make re­form­ing our de­moc­racy a pri­or­ity, since even with­out Trump, the sick­ness in the Re­pub­li­can Party will re­main. It will take strong med­i­cine to save the pa­tient. Dem­o­crats must be pre­pared to ad­min­is­ter the cure.

Jamelle Bouie is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article originally appeared. His previous article was “Both parties should worry about their presidential candidates losing.”