An elec­tion that will have a ma­jor ef­fect on 70% of the world’s sur­face has gone al­most un­no­ticed: Last week’s vote for sec­re­tary-gen­eral of In­ter­na­tional Se­a­bed Au­thor­ity, with 169 mem­ber states.

An or­gan of the United Na­tions, the ISA was cre­ated by the UN Con­ven­tion on the Law of the Sea in 1982. Head­quar­tered in Ja­maica, it has au­thor­ity over all deep sea­bed min­ing con­ces­sions world­wide, with a man­date to pro­tect the riches of the in­ter­na­tional sea­bed (which ac­counts for more than half of the to­tal ocean floor).

Of par­tic­u­lar note, the ISA will de­cide whether to per­mit min­ing in ar­eas con­tain­ing man­ganese, co­balt, cop­per and nickel.

Ac­cel­er­at­ing strip min­ing

Deep sea­bed min­ing has been stalled for a va­ri­ety of en­vi­ron­men­tal and eco­nomic rea­sons, as well as the re­quire­ment to share rel­e­vant tech­nol­ogy with the global com­mu­nity. Now, how­ever, the tech­nol­ogy to sur­face the min­er­als is im­prov­ing, while land-based sources are dry­ing up and com­mod­ity prices are ris­ing.

Advertise with us

So the elec­tion of the new ISA sec­re­tary-gen­eral took on an out­size im­por­tance. The win­ner, Bra­zil­ian ocean­og­ra­pher Leti­cia Car­valho, has a strong man­date: The vote was 79 to 34. Car­valho, cur­rently an of­fi­cial for the UN en­vi­ron­men­tal pro­gram in Nai­robi, will be the first Bra­zil­ian, the first sci­en­tist and the first woman to lead the or­ga­ni­za­tion.

Her pre­de­ces­sor, Mi­chael Lodge, has pushed ag­gres­sively for a set of reg­u­la­tions for deep sea­bed min­ing, which the in­dus­try sup­ports. Car­valho, who takes of­fice on Jan. 1, has said that the ISA is un­likely to meet its in­ter­nal dead­line of July 2025 to for­mal­ize those rules.

That’s un­for­tu­nate. Par­tic­u­larly as elec­tric ve­hi­cles be­come more pop­u­lar and the need for bat­ter­ies grows, the strip min­ing of nod­ules from the deep sea­bed will ac­cel­er­ate. The ISA has is­sued more than 30 con­tracts to both pri­vate and state-run com­pa­nies to look for nod­ules across 500,000 square miles of in­ter­na­tional sea­bed.

Car­valho’s elec­tion comes at a com­pli­cated mo­ment. New and un­ex­pected find­ings in­di­cate that the nod­ules may pro­duce ox­y­gen. This means that more data col­lec­tion and en­vi­ron­men­tal anal­y­sis will be nec­es­sary. A mi­nor­ity of ISA mem­ber states (the U.S. is not one) has al­ready called for a pause on min­ing, and more may join in re­quest­ing a mor­a­to­rium.

The hot zone

The “hot zone” for min­ing is in the cen­ter of the Pa­cific, near the tiny is­land na­tions of Kiri­bati, Naura, and Tonga. They are work­ing with a Ca­na­dian firm, The Met­als Com­pany, to be­gin min­ing, even if reg­u­la­tions are not in place.

Advertise with us

This will not sit well with many of the na­tion-states of the ISA, some of whom see the ex­ploitation of the sea­bed as 21st cen­tury col­o­ni­za­tion. A guid­ing prin­ci­ple of the Law of the Sea treaty is that the in­ter­na­tional sea­bed is the “com­mon her­i­tage of all man­kind.”

But some of the del­e­ga­tions are push­ing for­ward, in­clud­ing China and Japan, whose com­bined GDP is nearly a quar­ter of the global econ­omy. The U.S., while not a mem­ber of the ISA, has gen­er­ally fa­vored min­ing in or­der to sup­port man­u­fac­tur­ing. Sev­eral Euro­pean, Aus­tra­lian and Ca­na­dian com­pa­nies are in­ter­ested in mov­ing for­ward on min­ing for both eco­nomic and geo­s­tra­te­gic rea­sons.

The rise of AI, which is used to pros­pect and ex­plore the deep sea­bed, has al­lowed for more ef­fi­cient min­ing, as have ad­vances in ro­bot­ics and nan­o­tech­nol­ogy. These tech­nol­o­gies will only add to the pres­sure to mine the deep sea­bed.

The geo­po­lit­i­cal im­pli­ca­tions of this are fraught. As de­mand for crit­i­cal ma­teri­als in­creases, the drive to cre­ate state-spon­sored or state-sup­ported en­ti­ties to as­sure sup­plies will be­come ir­re­sist­ible.

There will also be com­pe­ti­tion among ma­jor in­dus­trial pow­ers to curry fa­vor with the na­tions with large ex­clu­sive eco­nomic zones, con­sti­tut­ing 200 nau­ti­cal miles near large nod­ule fields. Al­ready there are ma­jor state-spon­sored ini­tia­tives to work with Pa­cific Island na­tions to de­velop their sea­bed.

Advertise with us

Our ma­jor stra­te­gic pri­or­ity

For the U.S., the ma­jor stra­te­gic pri­or­ity should be to rat­ify the UN Con­ven­tion on the Law of the Sea. Iron­i­cally, it was ob­jec­tions over the deep sea­bed min­ing re­gime that caused the U.S. to op­pose the treaty in the 1980s.

Despite a cou­ple of close calls over the de­cades, it has never been ap­proved by the U.S. Senate. Yet it en­joys over­whelm­ing sup­port from U.S. na­val strat­e­gists — in­clud­ing ev­ery ad­mi­ral I know — as well as U.S. in­dus­try.

If the US wants a voice in the de­lib­er­a­tions over the deep sea­bed — and it should — it needs to rat­ify the treaty, which will re­quire bi­par­ti­san sup­port, and try to in­flu­ence the pro­cess from the in­side.

The ISA’s re­cent elec­tion should serve as a warn­ing: The op­por­tu­nity to make an im­pact on pol­icy over the world’s oceans is drift­ing away (pun in­tended) from the U.S..

James Stavridis, a retired U.S. Navy admiral and former supreme allied commander of NATO, is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. His previous article was “Putin wants more than Ukraine.”