The United States’ per­for­mance at the 2024 Paris Olym­pics has been mag­nif­i­cent, as most peo­ple ex­pected. Si­mone Biles and the en­tire women’s team daz­zled view­ers with their gold medal per­for­mances in the women’s team gym­nas­tics com­pe­ti­tion. In sports with lesser fol­low­ings, Lee Kiefer de­feated Lau­ren Scruggs to cap­ture the gold and sil­ver med­als in the women’s in­di­vid­ual foil com­pe­ti­tion.

Where the United States has his­tor­i­cally per­formed well is in swim­ming. Though Katie Le­decky and Bobby Finke de­liv­ered record per­for­mances in their spe­cial­ties — the women’s and men’s 1500 me­ters free­style, re­spec­tively — the Amer­i­can swim­mers did not dom­i­nate the com­pe­ti­tion as they have in prior Olym­pics.

Fewer med­als than usual

The United States cap­tured 28 med­als (in­clud­ing eight golds), both very good num­bers, and ahead of the Aus­tra­lians, who won 18 med­als and seven golds. A to­tal of 17 Olym­pic records were bro­ken dur­ing the Games.

How­ever, only four world records were eclipsed, with just two for in­di­vid­ual races, Pan Zhanle of China in the Men’s 100-me­ter free­style and Bobby Finke of the United States in the 1,500-me­ter free­style.

Advertise with us

The 28 to­tal med­als were the low­est num­ber for the Amer­i­cans since the 2004 Athens Games. The eight golds was also the low­est tally by the Amer­i­can swim­mers since the 1956 Mel­bourne Games, when they won just two golds out of 13 swim­ming events.

Just how dom­i­nant has the United States been in swim­ming?

In the 2020 To­kyo Games, the United States cap­tured 30 med­als, in­clud­ing 11 golds, ahead of the Aus­tra­lians, who won 21 med­als and nine golds. A to­tal of six world records and 26 Olym­pic records were shat­tered dur­ing the Games.

In the 2016 Rio de Ja­neiro Games, the United States cap­tured 33 med­als (in­clud­ing 16 golds), ahead of the Aus­tra­lians, who won 10 med­als and three golds. A to­tal of eight world records and 15 Olym­pic records were smashed dur­ing the Games.

In the 2012 Lon­don Games, the United States cap­tured 31 med­als (in­clud­ing 16 golds), ahead of the Aus­tra­lians, who won 10 med­als and five golds. A to­tal of nine world records and 16 Olym­pic records were shat­tered dur­ing the Games.

Advertise with us

In the 2008 Bei­jing Games, the United States cap­tured 31 med­als (in­clud­ing 12 golds), ahead of the Aus­tra­lians, who won 20 med­als and six golds. A to­tal of 24 world records and 41 Olym­pic records were shat­tered dur­ing the Games.

Why so few

The United States swim­mers’ per­for­mance can be ex­plained by other swim­mers around the world gain­ing on the Amer­i­cans’ his­toric su­pe­ri­or­ity.

Many of the best in­ter­na­tional swim­mers train in the United States. For ex­am­ple, Léon March­and, who won four in­di­vid­ual golds for France, swam for Ari­zona State Univer­sity, where he was coached by Bob Bow­man, one of the cur­rent swim­ming coaches for France.

Clearly, train­ing and coach­ing af­fect per­for­mance in the pool, and in­ter­na­tional swim­mers have em­braced such op­por­tu­ni­ties.

How­ever, the dearth of world-record-set­ting per­for­mances raises the ques­tion: Did the de­sign of the Paris pool sup­press swim­ming times?

Advertise with us

One is­sue is that the depth of the Paris pool was around 2.15 me­ters, less than the 2.5 to 3.0 me­ters used at the most re­cent Olym­pics, though well within the ac­cepted range. The gen­eral rule is that the deeper the pool, the less tur­bu­lence in the wa­ter, which in the­ory should lead to faster swims and more records be­ing set. How­ever, other fac­tors come into play to de­ter­mine the speed of a pool.

For ex­am­ple, how the walls are de­signed, namely with the po­si­tion­ing of the touch­pads, may also im­pact wa­ter tur­bu­lence, yet an­other fac­tor that could slow swim­mers down.

This phe­nom­e­non of play­ing field de­sign af­fects per­for­mance in many sports. Ten­nis sur­faces (clay ver­sus grass ver­sus hard) fa­vor cer­tain styles of play and ath­letes more than oth­ers. The same idea holds true with golf course de­sign, in­clud­ing the width of fair­ways as well as the size and level of greens. It is pos­si­ble that the same ef­fects can be re­al­ized from pool de­signs and wa­ter depth.

Most Amer­i­can swim­mers come up through the col­lege sys­tem, where times are fast. This means that the pools in which Amer­i­can swim­mers train and com­pete are much faster than those they saw in Paris. This cre­ated a nat­u­ral head­wind on times, par­tic­u­larly if they have not been ex­posed to such shal­low pool depth.

In the fu­ture

Inde­pen­dent of the speed of the Paris pool, Amer­i­can swim­mers con­tin­ued to show their dom­i­nance, though not to the same de­gree as in pre­vi­ous Olym­pics. In­ter­na­tional swim­mers train­ing in the United States will con­tinue to level the play­ing field.

Advertise with us

In fu­ture Olym­pics, the pool de­sign and spec­i­fi­ca­tions should also be shared with all coun­tries well be­fore the Games, so all par­tic­i­pants could ben­e­fit from such in­for­ma­tion. Indeed, in­tense com­pe­ti­tion keeps ev­ery swim­mer push­ing to achieve their per­sonal bests, show­cas­ing ex­cel­lence that is the hall­mark of the Olym­pics.

Sheldon H. Jacobson is a professor in computer science at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. His previous article was “A government plan for air travel may hurt you, not help.”