Across Don­ald Trump’s pres­i­dency, the Amer­i­can es­tab­lish­ment achieved an un­prece­dented level of ide­o­log­i­cal unity and con­for­mity — first in op­po­si­tion to Trump him­self, and then in the em­brace of pro­gres­sive ide­ol­ogy, in the “Great Awo­ken­ing” that reached a cre­scendo in the hot­ter months of 2020.

Since then we’ve watched cracks spread through­out this ed­i­fice, di­vid­ing groups and in­sti­tu­tions that once seemed to move in lock step. These fault lines in­clude the split be­tween a more ide­o­log­i­cal ac­a­demic cul­ture, where wo­ke­ness seems en­trenched, and cor­po­rate and me­dia realms, where its hold has some­what weak­ened.

The wid­en­ing cracks

They in­clude the di­vi­sions be­tween do­nors, uni­ver­sity ad­min­is­tra­tors and ac­tiv­ists ex­posed and height­ened by the Ha­mas at­tacks and the Is­rael-Gaza war. They in­clude the strug­gle over Joe Biden’s fit­ness to run again, in which the lib­eral in­tel­li­gent­sia and the Demo­cratic Party were tem­po­rar­ily at war, and the emer­gence of new right-lean­ing fac­tions within the Amer­i­can elite.

But now, with the surge of sup­port for Kamala Har­ris’ can­di­dacy, you can sense an ef­fort to over­come these di­vi­sions, to re­as­sert the es­tab­lish­ment’s anti-Trump con­sen­sus, to re­cover the unity of 2020 and put the full power of what Nate Sil­ver once called the “in­digo blob” at the pre­sump­tive Demo­cratic nom­i­nee’s dis­posal.

Advertise with us

This means money: a surge of tens of mil­lions of dol­lars into Demo­cratic cof­fers. It means star power, whether through en­dorse­ments or just as­so­ci­a­tions: Olivia Ro­drigo and George Cloo­ney, Charli XCX and Beyoncé.

It means soft-fo­cus me­dia treat­ments and even the up­dat­ing of in­con­ve­nient lan­guage, as Ax­ios did when it cor­rected a past ref­er­ence to Har­ris as the Biden ad­min­is­tra­tion “bor­der czar” amid con­ser­va­tive crit­i­cism of her role in im­mi­gra­tion pol­icy. It means squelch­ing any chance of an in­tra-Demo­cratic con­flict or a con­ven­tion fight, while de­liv­er­ing hype from ev­ery cor­ner, from lib­er­als to ex-Re­pub­li­cans to TikTok us­ers, in an at­tempt to gild the Har­ris can­di­dacy with the magic of Obam­a­ma­nia.

What the Kamal­a­men­tum ef­fort shares with that 2008 phe­nom­e­non is one of Barack Obama’s fa­vor­ite words: “au­dac­ity.” But not the au­dac­ity of hope this time, so much as the au­dac­ity of des­per­a­tion — a sense that in this late hour the only hope for stop­ping Trump is to set aside all dif­fer­ences, bury all doubts and pres­ent Har­ris to the world not as an un­happy de­fault but as a po­ten­tially trans­for­ma­tive can­di­date, the kind that any Trump op­po­nent should have wanted all along.

The pre­vi­ous con­sen­sus

This is es­pe­cially au­da­cious be­cause the ag­ony that the Dem­o­crats only just es­caped, the dis­grace­ful at­tempt by Biden’s in­ner cir­cle to prop him up through one more cam­paign cy­cle, was it­self a di­rect re­sponse to a con­sen­sus among savvy po­lit­i­cal ob­serv­ers that Har­ris was an ex­cep­tion­ally poor can­di­date, ex­actly the wrong per­son to set against Trump, not an­other Obama but a lib­eral an­swer to Dan Quayle.

The speed at which this con­sen­sus shifted should not ex­actly be sur­pris­ing. We just watched, af­ter all, the rapid dis­so­lu­tion of a shared lib­eral re­al­ity in which Biden’s aging was at most a mi­nor prob­lem mag­ni­fied by Fox News and Re­pub­li­can dis­in­for­ma­tion ef­forts.

Advertise with us

Just as that con­sen­sus turned out to be a fond de­lu­sion, per­haps the un­der­es­ti­ma­tion of Har­ris will look un­moored from re­al­ity in hind­sight. Even poor Quayle might have out­per­formed his rep­u­ta­tion if some­one had only given him a chance.

But the ba­sic facts that made Har­ris seem like a du­bi­ous choice re­main. She is a pol­i­ti­cian who built her ca­reer in­side a lib­eral state where what mat­ters is win­ning over Demo­cratic Party elites and lib­eral-lean­ing vot­ers, not the con­ser­va­tive-lean­ing in­de­pen­dent vot­ers she needs to per­suade now.

She flopped com­pletely in her bid for na­tional of­fice in 2020 and was res­cued and el­e­vated only by the ex­i­gen­cies of George Floyd-era pro­gres­sive pol­i­tics. As vice pres­i­dent, she has no no­ta­ble suc­cesses, no im­pres­sive port­fo­lio, and her strug­gles and mis­cues have in­spired com­par­i­sons to HBO’s “Veep” for a rea­son.

To­day she oc­cu­pies an odd po­si­tion as pre­sump­tive nom­i­nee, hav­ing suc­ceeded in nei­ther of the tra­di­tional means of as­cent: She won no pri­ma­ries or cau­cuses, and no smoke-filled room of Demo­cratic gran­dees agreed on her electabil­ity. Dem­o­crats have made their peace with her nom­i­na­tion, but they are mak­ing a vir­tue of ne­ces­sity, not crown­ing a vic­tor or re­ward­ing a great suc­cess.

The dou­ble test

That ne­ces­sity has brought us to a dou­ble test. For Har­ris her­self, the ques­tion is whether she can rise to the oc­ca­sion, con­duct out­reach more ef­fec­tively than the cur­rent pres­i­dent has, shed her Quay­lian bag­gage and show skills that even her al­lies have wor­ried that she lacks.

Advertise with us

For the es­tab­lish­ment ral­ly­ing around her, the ques­tion is whether the united front that’s con­tained Trump but failed to bury him has enough re­main­ing juice, enough po­tency de­spite its di­vi­sions, to achieve a great and here­to­fore un­likely seem­ing feat: mak­ing Kamala Har­ris hap­pen.

Ross Douthat is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “Biden should step down to save the country from Trump — and himself.”