Since the In­dus­trial Revo­lu­tion, work­ers have con­tended with tech­no­log­i­cal threats to their jobs. To­day that’s ar­ti­fi­cial in­tel­li­gence, or AI. AI has been a main­stay in our pop­u­lar imag­i­na­tion for de­cades — from apoc­a­lyp­tic ro­bot take­overs to thriv­ing post-work so­ci­et­ies. All that re­mains sci­ence fic­tion, but many of us un­der­stand­ably worry that AI might take our jobs.

The good news? That’s un­likely. The re­al­ity — and the less good news — is that AI is rap­idly in­creas­ing sur­veil­lance in the work­place.

An over­whelm­ing ma­jor­ity of work­ers say AI will have a di­rect im­pact on their jobs, but they don’t agree on how. Some feel that it will help, while 42% fear that some as­pects of their job will soon be au­to­mated.

That’s cer­tainly what many tech ex­ec­u­tives have sug­gested will hap­pen. Re­ports that a ma­jor­ity of U.S. firms are plan­ning to in­cor­po­rate AI within the next year have com­pounded those con­cerns. In fact, Gold­man Sachs pre­dicts that gen­er­a­tive AI could “sub­sti­tute up to one-fourth of cur­rent work.”

Advertise with us

Mixed re­sults

Yet the con­crete re­sults of AI have been mixed at best. Driv­er­less cars ha­ven’t ma­teri­al­ized to re­place hu­mans on the road. McDon­ald’s cut ties with IBM af­ter their new au­to­mated or­der tak­ing sys­tem failed to make fast food or­ders more ef­fi­cient. And Google’s new AI Overview tool — which seeks to “do the goo­gling for you” — keeps spit­ting out com­i­cal false­hoods.

In short, AI isn’t as ad­vanced as the tech in­dus­try would have us be­lieve. But be­cause these com­pa­nies want to at­tract cap­i­tal from in­ves­tors, some are ex­ag­ger­at­ing or mis­rep­re­sent­ing their AI ca­pa­bil­i­ties, caus­ing the Se­cu­ri­ties and Ex­change Com­mis­sion to crack down on two com­pa­nies for so-called “AI-wash­ing.”

Yet Big Tech re­mains un­de­terred. Most AI firms con­tinue to be un­prof­it­able, yet ven­ture cap­i­tal­ists are still flood­ing the sec­tor with bil­lions of dol­lars with the hope it will one day trans­form the in­dus­try into a vi­a­ble and in­no­va­tive busi­ness.

In short, the “AI-will-re­place-us-all-one-day” frenzy is a form of pro­pa­ganda. It’s de­signed to de­mor­al­ize work­ers over a fu­ture that may never ar­rive. In­stead, our fo­cus should be on where AI is ac­tu­ally de­ployed to­day: in the realm of worker sur­veil­lance.

Chev­ron and Star­bucks are al­ready us­ing AI soft­ware to mon­i­tor the com­mu­ni­ca­tions of their work­ers to flag dis­con­tent in the work­place. Am­a­zon de­liv­ery driv­ers, mean­while, are forced to “con­sent” to the in­stal­la­tion of AI-pow­ered cam­eras that fi­nan­cially pe­nal­ize driv­ers for or­di­nary be­hav­ior like fid­dling with the ra­dio — or even mis­takes they may not have ac­tu­ally com­mit­ted.

Advertise with us

Con­cern­ingly, some cor­po­ra­tions are us­ing mil­i­tary-grade AI to sub­vert and dis­rupt union­iza­tion ef­forts. These busi­nesses use AI for dig­i­tal union bust­ing, iden­ti­fy­ing and fir­ing la­bor or­ga­niz­ers through key­board track­ing, Zoom call spy­ing, and alerts when a large num­ber of em­ploy­ees hold in­ter­nal meet­ings.

All of this trans­forms the work­place into an elec­tronic panop­ti­con where work­ers are con­stantly vis­i­ble to an un­seen watcher en­croach­ing on their au­ton­omy, pri­vacy, and la­bor rights.

Fight­ing back

Thank­fully, work­ers are be­gin­ning to fight back. The Team­sters ne­go­ti­ated a con­tract with UPS that in­cluded strong pro­tec­tions against AI sur­veil­lance.

The Com­mu­ni­ca­tions Work­ers of Amer­ica suc­ceeded in en­sur­ing that any data col­lected by AI will be used for train­ing pur­poses only — not to dis­ci­pline work­ers. And the Writ­ers Guild of Amer­ica put guard­rails on AI to en­sure it doesn’t sup­press wages — and make sure it re­mains un­der work­ers’ con­trol.

While tech ex­ec­u­tives may prom­ise that AI will fun­da­men­tally trans­form the econ­omy, it’s un­likely to com­pletely re­place most work­ers. Even so, AI’s abil­ity to de­value la­bor and di­min­ish work­ing con­di­tions is trou­bling.

Advertise with us

We need to make sure that tech­no­log­i­cal ad­vance­ments make work bet­ter, not worse. And un­like AI, we can act on our own ac­cord. We can ed­u­cate, ad­vo­cate, and or­ga­nize to make cer­tain that new tech­nol­o­gies are im­ple­mented for the ben­e­fit of all, not just the priv­i­leged few.

A.J. Schumann is Henry A. Wallace Fellow and Omar Ocampo an IPS inequality researcher at the Institute for Policy Studies.