Since the pan­demic, go­ing to the gro­cery store has be­come a jar­ring ex­pe­ri­ence. Gro­cery prices have soared nearly 27% since 2020, higher than over­all in­fla­tion.

Some con­sum­ers have gone into debt to af­ford gro­cer­ies. Ac­cord­ing to an Ur­ban In­sti­tute anal­y­sis, many fam­i­lies have had to tap credit cards, sav­ings and pay­day loans to af­ford the es­sen­tials.

The stan­dard ex­pla­na­tion for these gro­cery price in­creases has been sup­ply chain dis­rup­tions caused by pan­demic-re­lated la­bor short­ages, ris­ing fuel costs and droughts.

Cer­tainly those fac­tors have all played a sig­nifi­cant role. But is that all that’s go­ing on here? The ma­jor gro­cery chains have been op­er­at­ing at the high­est profit mar­gins in two de­cades. Let’s probe a lit­tle deeper.

Advertise with us

Lever­ag­ing size

Con­cur­rent with the alarm­ing rise in gro­cery prices has been a record in­crease in gro­cery in­dus­try prof­its. A re­cent Fed­eral Trade Com­mis­sion study on gro­cery sup­ply chains found that ma­jor re­tail­ers have le­ver­aged their size and in­flu­ence to dic­tate what they pay to their sup­pli­ers.

So dur­ing a time when ev­ery­one else’s costs have es­ca­lated, gro­cery chains have been able to con­trol costs even as their prices soared.

For ex­am­ple, Pepsi and Coca-Cola dom­i­nate the bev­er­age in­dus­try. In 2021, dur­ing the mid­dle of the pan­demic, Pepsi raised its prices, blam­ing it on al­leged higher costs. Yet some­how it still raked in $11 bil­lion in prof­its. Then in 2023, even though the pan­demic was over and in­fla­tion was drop­ping, Pepsi still hiked its prices by dou­ble dig­its for the sev­enth con­sec­u­tive quar­ter. Its prof­its soared an­other 14%.

Pepsi’s only ma­jor com­pet­i­tor, Coca-Cola, an­nounced the same price hikes around the same time. If Pepsi and Coke had other large com­pet­i­tors, con­sum­ers would have more choices. But Pepsi and Coke own most of the sub­sti­tute bev­er­age prod­ucts!

That’s what’s called a mar­ket mo­nop­oly, and soft drinks are not the only food prod­ucts dom­i­nated by a hand­ful of busi­nesses. Only four com­pa­nies con­trol the pro­cess­ing of 80% of beef, nearly 70% of pork and al­most 60% of poul­try.

Advertise with us

With so few busi­nesses com­pet­ing, it is pretty easy for them to co­or­di­nate price in­creases. Con­se­quently, at the end of 2023, Amer­i­cans were pay­ing at least 30% more for beef, poul­try and pork prod­ucts than they were be­fore the pan­demic.

The num­ber of gro­cery stores it­self has fallen 30% in the past 25 years, re­sult­ing in more than a third of gro­cery sales com­ing from only four re­tail­ers. Wal­mart alone has nearly a quar­ter of the gro­cery mar­ket. Low com­pe­ti­tion gives these re­tail­ers more mar­ket power to raise prices.

Too few com­pa­nies com­pet­ing

So yes, in­fla­tion is down, but many peo­ple don’t no­tice be­cause food prices are still high, partly due to sev­eral years of price goug­ing by mo­nop­o­lies.

And this dy­namic goes well be­yond the gro­cery store. In 75% of U.S. in­dus­tries, whether phar­ma­ceu­ti­cals, air­lines, health care, util­i­ties, en­ergy or oth­ers, fewer com­pa­nies now con­trol more of their mar­kets than 20 years ago.

What role do pres­i­dents or pol­i­tics play in all of this? Dur­ing the re­cent de­bate, Don­ald Trump at­tacked Pres­i­dent Joe Biden over high gro­cery prices, say­ing, “He caused the in­fla­tion … it’s kill­ing peo­ple. They can’t buy gro­cer­ies any­more.”

Advertise with us

Cer­tainly it’s true that prices have greatly in­creased dur­ing the Biden pres­i­dency. But much of that ini­tially was a re­sult of the pan­demic — which be­gan dur­ing Trump’s pres­i­dency. It’s un­likely that ei­ther pres­i­dent could have con­trolled those pan­demic-un­leashed eco­nomic forces.

To Biden’s credit, his ad­min­is­tra­tion has been press­ing gro­cery re­tail­ers to lower prices, and ac­tu­ally has done more than any pres­i­dent since Teddy Roosevelt to crack down on mo­nop­o­lies. His FTC has taken ac­tion against price-fix­ing in the meat in­dus­try and filed a law­suit to block the merger of su­per­mar­ket gi­ants Kroger and Al­bert­sons that would elim­i­nate even more com­pe­ti­tion and lead to higher prices.

Trump, in his strat­egy to pro­tect Amer­i­can busi­nesses, has called for a 10% tar­iff on all im­ported goods. That makes a great cam­paign slo­gan, but given that the United States im­ports 15% of its food sup­ply — in­clud­ing 60% of fresh fruit and nearly 40% of fresh veg­e­ta­bles — that would likely fur­ther in­crease food costs.

Just re­cently, there’s ev­i­dence that some of the anti-mo­nop­oly sa­ber rat­tling might be work­ing. Gro­cery chains have fi­nally be­gun low­er­ing prices. Tar­get an­nounced it would lower prices on roughly 5,000 items, in­clud­ing sta­ples such as milk, pro­duce, bread, cof­fee, di­a­pers and pet food.

Aldi, the fast­est-grow­ing gro­cery chain in the coun­try, an­nounced price cuts on hun­dreds of items. Wal­mart and Safe­way have fol­lowed suit.

Advertise with us

Greedy gro­cers

But this is not some new­found cor­po­rate gen­er­os­ity. With prices so high, U.S. con­sum­ers had re­duced their gro­cery spend­ing to the point that it ac­tu­ally be­gan to threaten Big Gro­cery’s sales and prof­its. Greedy gro­cery chains have quite lit­er­ally bit­ten the hand that feeds them.

As Amer­ica races to­ward a pres­i­den­tial elec­tion, vot­ers will be eye­ing their gro­cery bills and com­par­ing the can­di­dates’ state­ments over who will pro­vide the most re­lief.

Hill was policy director for the Center for Humane Technology, co-founder of FairVote and political reform director at New America. You can reach him on X @StevenHill1776.