Why is God doing everything he can to reelect Donald Trump? First, he inspired President Joe Biden to overstimulate the economy, leading to inflation and discrediting the Biden domestic policy in the eyes of many voters.
Then he inspired Democrats to run the televised Jan. 6 hearings, which was a noble civic responsibility but a political distraction. That’s not what key swing voters are most concerned about.
Then Trump’s main primary rival, Ron DeSantis, turned out to be a total stiff. Then prosecutors started indicting Trump, guaranteeing that he would win the Republican nomination. Then there was the avoidance of tragedy in Butler, Pennsylvania.
A mystery
Then there was this week. This is the happiest, most united and most confident Republican convention I’ve ever been to. Meanwhile, the Democratic Party is imploding.
Next week, we may very well learn that Trump is going to face Kamala Harris in the general election. The swing states are mostly in the Upper Midwest, and Trump will probably be running against a progressive from San Francisco.
The ways of the Lord are truly mysterious.
Of course, human beings may have played a role. At his blog Marginal Revolution, economist Tyler Cowen lists a number of reasons for the rightward shift in the political climate since 2020.
The most crucial, I’d say, are these: The Trumpian right has been more intellectually creative than the progressive left. The Trump message resonates better with today’s deeply pessimistic culture. The deindustrialization of America has had decades-long social effects.
People don’t want to be ruled by the intellectual class, whether under Barack Obama or Biden. What we call wokeism is really unpopular. The Biden age cover-up damages Democratic credibility and undermines the party’s claims of moral superiority.
Of course Trump himself may have played a role in his success. Over the past year he has performed acts of showmanship that were remarkably effective, even for him. He turned a mug shot into a propaganda win and an assassination attempt into an iconic image of defiance.
But here are a few things that I, at least, did not expect from Trump. He chose two veteran campaign managers in Susie Wiles and Chris LaCivita and he’s doing what they tell him to do. He’s leading a campaign operation that is far more disciplined and professional than his White House was.
He has mostly shut up and laid low as the Democratic campaign falls apart. He has suppressed his bellicose, nasty nature and smiled benignly as his daughter-in-law and granddaughter portray him as a kindly grandpa.
A new philosophy
Most important, he has shifted the entire governing philosophy of the Republican Party. His campaign aggressively controlled the platform, moving it in a populist direction. The campaign softened the party’s abortion stance, which I would have thought impossible.
Trump also made the right vice-presidential pick. Business types such as Doug Burgum and Glenn Youngkin would have undercut his populist message while putting people to sleep.
Many of the delegates I have spoken to once cheered lustily for the free-market gospel of Mitt Romney and the aggressive internationalism of John McCain. On Wednesday night they were won over by JD Vance, who ripped into both those worldviews.
The delegates are still not completely where Trump is. On Monday night, Teamster boss Sean O’Brien addressed the convention, lashing out at corporate greed.
Afterward I was walking down the stairs to exit the arena when I overheard a delegate complaining: “Couldn’t he have mentioned small business at least once?” This is still somewhat a business owner’s party.
In retrospect, the last decade has been a race between rival populisms — the left-wing kind personified by Bernie Sanders and the right-wing kind personified by Trump and Vance. The right-wing kind has won.
Even for those of us who detest the man, it’s kind of impressive. We’ve learned, probably too late, not to underestimate Trump.
David Brooks is a columnist for the New York Times, in which this article first appeared. His previous article was “The dangerous dynamics of elite America.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.