I have been thinking, somewhat abashedly, about a conversation with a friend some years ago. She said she was considering moving away from Los Angeles, but it had to be to a blue state.
She said she could not bear to live in a place where her neighbors might be political neanderthals, especially where they might be the majority. This was years before the rise of Donald Trump and Trumpism.
Being comfortable
The conversation came back to me during another conversation, recently, with a much younger person. He is contemplating a move from New York City to upstate New York.
Who will my neighbors be there, he wondered. Will they mostly be gun owners? Will they therefore be Trumpists? Am I wrong to assume that? Will they assume things about me? Will they hate me without knowing me?
I feel embarrassed about the LA convo because, at the time, I thought: How absurd — to base where you live on politics. To judge your neighbors, as human beings, based on political opinions and beliefs. Just live where you want to live.
I felt differently during the New York conversation. I would not like to see that young person at risk.
There are places where a gay black man will not feel comfortable. And places where a hunting enthusiast in a “Make America Great Again” cap will not feel comfortable. And it’s OK to want to feel comfortable.
But I fear this desire to be with our own people is now much deeper than that. We don’t want to see or hear the other.
Red voters see the governments of blue states as hopelessly corrupt and the voters who support them as snobs who are morally decadent. Liberals and lefties see red voters as “deplorables,” clinging to their Bibles and guns.
Many evangelicals don’t want to live in Godless LA or New York. Many blue voters think rural America is Deliverance country, if they think of it at all.
In truth, there are Christians in California who would welcome the Southerner, the newcomer, or outsider to their churches. And there are Christians in Kentucky and North Carolina who would welcome the transplanted northerner with a Biden-Harris sticker on the car.
But the culture drowns them out.
Our bullying culture
Our bullying culture war divides us and fuels the left/right manias. It, and not economics, fuels Trumpist populism.
I admit that a room, or state, full of hard-core Trumpists would drive me to distraction. Mostly because it is as if they have all drunk the Kool-Aid and eerily recite the same “facts” and tropes. It’s a cult.
But a 90% blue city or state would be insufferable.
When they read, Trumpists read only for reference to Trump. They see nothing else. If it is not worshipful, they react. The writer must be a Godless liberal.
With the left, the writer must intone his Trump hate (real hate), then repeat, repeat, repeat. Otherwise, he is evil. Or complicit with evil.
Generally the right calls the opinion it dislikes stupid and un-American. The left calls the opinion unclean and impugns the writer’s motives.
It’s all part of our hands-over ears, bi-partisan, universal cancel culture. Missing in our politics at the moment are not so much people in the middle, or moderates, but people who are hybrids: Republicans who can see Donald Trump as the chaotic lawbreaker he is and Democrats who can see that the endless and boundless prosecution of Mr. Trump has a cost.
Conservatives with compassion. Liberals with limits.
I have written in this space before about my Dad and his friend Bill. They happened to be neighbors. They were also neighbors, defined by Jesus as the people who help the ones in need.
Deepest red and deeper blue: Bill loved guns and the John Birch Society, but he was also a person of great empathy. Dad loved unions and FDR, but he also loved God and country.
They both loved music, V-8 engines, corny jokes, work. They were hybrids. Individuals. Not cultists; not bots.
Their mutual respect made it possible to accept the other’s views, and occasionally concede a point.
This past week, the actor Richard Dreyfuss shot his mouth off at an event in Boston and a great brouhaha ensued. He was only supposed to talk about a film, not parenting and trans kids. Chastisements and apologies were issued.
What happened here?
And all I could think of was: What happened to the America of “it’s a free country” and “it takes all kinds to make a world”?
Free speech is the foundation of an open society. Tolerance and forbearance is the oxygen of free speech. Pluralism is the result: Many people; many ethnicities and identities; many views. And the embrace of this. Out of one, many.
Let Mr. Dreyfuss and J.K. Rowling speak their peace. Then speak yours. And don’t write off California or the South.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Trump’s conviction was good, but good for what?”.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.