No Demo­cratic pres­i­dent since at least Grover Cleve­land in the late 19th cen­tury has been be­loved by Amer­i­can busi­ness. But the bleak re­la­tion­ship be­tween Joe Biden and cor­po­rate Amer­ica is re­mark­able given both the stel­lar fi­nan­cial mar­ket per­for­mance dur­ing his ten­ure and the na­ture of the al­ter­na­tive.

Yes, Don­ald Trump of­fers some of what busi­ness has al­ways liked about Re­pub­li­cans — vows to lower cor­po­rate taxes and re­duce reg­u­la­tion — but com­pared to pre-Trump Re­pub­li­cans, he’s put a lot of dis­taste­ful items on the menu.

Trump’s dis­taste­ful items

He wants a 60% tar­iff on all goods im­ported from China and a 10% tax on im­ports from else­where. Quite apart from any im­pact on con­sumer prices, this would crush U.S. ex­port­ers who rely on for­eign-made in­ter­me­di­ate goods and com­pete with firms in Europe and Asia.

Trump is also vow­ing cuts to le­gal im­mi­gra­tion and a dra­matic in­crease in the de­por­ta­tion of peo­ple al­ready pres­ent and work­ing with­out au­tho­ri­za­tion in the U.S. This kind of pos­tur­ing is good cam­paign rhet­o­ric, but in a prac­ti­cal sense would be dev­as­tat­ing to the in­ter­ests of thou­sands of U.S. busi­nesses that rely on all kinds of im­mi­grant la­bor — skilled and un­skilled, le­gal and il­le­gal.

Advertise with us

The U.S. un­em­ploy­ment rate is al­ready very low, so the va­can­cies cre­ated by this pol­icy wouldn’t be filled by bring­ing peo­ple back into the la­bor force. The econ­omy’s pro­duc­tive ca­pac­ity would con­tract, risk­ing higher in­fla­tion or in­ter­est rates, which would make it harder for all busi­nesses to in­vest.

Speak­ing of in­ter­est rates: Busi­ness has al­ways loved the Re­pub­li­can ap­proach to tax pol­icy, but 2025 is not go­ing to be 2017 or 2003 in terms of mac­ro­eco­nomic cir­cum­stances. A huge tax cut that in­creases the def­i­cit would put more up­ward pres­sure on in­fla­tion and force even higher in­ter­est rates.

To deal with this, Trump has floated clip­ping the Fed’s in­de­pen­dence to force rates down — a di­sas­trous idea that could crip­ple the U.S. econ­omy for years to come.

And that’s just the rel­a­tively nor­mal pol­icy stuff. The long-tail risks of bomb­ing Mex­ico or end­ing NATO while cut­ting off aid to Ukraine, for ex­am­ple, are gar­gan­tuan. And yet cor­po­rate Amer­ica sees 2024 as a “no win” prop­o­si­tion.

Which raises the ques­tion: Why doesn’t busi­ness like Biden more?

Advertise with us

Busi­ness against Biden

Part of the rea­son may be sheer pet­ti­ness. It’s com­pletely fair for in­dus­try to com­plain about Lina Khan at the FTC or Gary Gensler at the SEC, or to take is­sue with stray bits of po­lit­i­cal rhet­o­ric about price goug­ing. But cor­po­rate Amer­ica is do­ing just fine un­der Biden.

There is also an oddly asym­met­ri­cal as­sess­ment of the risks in­volved in the choice be­tween Biden and Trump. Busi­ness can live with what Biden has done so far, but it is par­a­noid about what he might do in the fu­ture — such as tax­ing un­re­al­ized cap­i­tal gains. Mean­while, it is blithely con­fi­dent that Trump won’t fol­low through on his loopier prom­ises.

I have no idea where this con­fi­dence comes from. It’s true that Trump served a full term and the sky didn’t fall. But he also led an in­sur­rec­tion­ary mob to try to over­throw the gov­ern­ment.

And it’s worth point­ing out that the sky isn’t fall­ing un­der Biden, ei­ther. Trump, mean­while, has se­cured much more con­trol over his party in Con­gress, whereas it’s all but cer­tain that Biden will be checked by a Re­pub­li­can ma­jor­ity in the House, the Senate or both.

As far as I can fig­ure, the best jus­ti­fi­ca­tion for this busi­ness cool­ness to­ward Biden is just hurt feel­ings. And that raises the in­verse of my ear­lier ques­tion: Why doesn’t Biden like busi­ness more?

Advertise with us

Biden does not have a busi­ness leader in his cab­i­net. Trea­sury Sec­re­tary Janet Yel­len is an ac­a­demic, not a friendly face on Wall Street the way Tim Geith­ner or Robert Rubin was.

He does not re­ally pay hom­age to the en­tre­pre­neurial spirit of Amer­i­can busi­ness or do much to court the pri­vate sec­tor. He should con­sider chang­ing di­rec­tion on that, and find a bone or three to throw busi­ness on the reg­u­la­tory front.

Dem­o­crats are cur­rently ob­sessed with the idea that the Amer­i­can pub­lic is in­suf­fi­ciently ap­pre­cia­tive of the econ­omy. They’re not nec­es­sar­ily wrong. But tell­ing peo­ple that they don’t know how good they’ve got it is not a great mes­sage, po­lit­i­cally speak­ing.

Biden’s busi­ness ap­peal

By con­trast, re­cruit­ing out­side val­i­da­tors from the busi­ness world to talk about how healthy re­cent growth has been, and how risky a bet on Trump would be, could ac­tu­ally im­prove the “vibes.”

The White House of­ten seems overly ob­sessed with pre­serv­ing Biden’s pop­u­list street cred as a way to neu­tral­ize Trump. But pol­i­ti­cians fre­quently win by play­ing against type. Part of Trump’s schtick is be­ing more pop­u­list than most Re­pub­li­cans. Biden can ap­peal to vot­ers by show­ing them that he is more busi­ness-friendly than most Dem­o­crats.

Mat­thew Ygle­sias is a col­um­nist for Bloomberg Opin­ion. His previous article was “How truthful must politicians be?”