The com­pa­nies that run col­lege en­trance ex­ams have been slammed by fi­nan­cial losses, and pri­vate eq­uity firms are swoop­ing in to help while tak­ing ma­jor­ity stakes in ex­change. That’s wor­ry­ing some ed­u­ca­tion ad­vo­cates.

ACT Inc., the Iowa-based non­profit be­hind the epon­y­mous col­lege en­trance exam, has recorded a net loss of $12 mil­lion in fis­cal year 2022, $6 mil­lion in 2021 and $60.5 mil­lion in 2020. The num­bers of test-tak­ers have not re­turned to pre-pan­demic lev­els.

Last week, the com­pany an­nounced that it would part­ner with Cal­i­for­nia-based pri­vate eq­uity firm Nexus Cap­i­tal Man­age­ment and move its test into a for-profit com­pany.

ACT Inc. says that this cash in­fu­sion will help ex­pand and en­hance ser­vices be­yond test­ing. “At this mo­ment in time, 40% of stu­dents leav­ing high school on av­er­age are go­ing straight to the work­force,” ACT CEO Janet God­win told CNN. “I think Nexus sees with ACT the ab­so­lute need that our na­tion has to make sure that we are de­vel­op­ing tal­ent for the needs of our em­ploy­ers.”

Advertise with us

Good­win, said the deal would bring “op­por­tu­ni­ties for in­or­ganic growth” like merg­ers and ac­qui­si­tions, stra­te­gic port­fo­lio in­vest­ments and ac­cess to new tal­ent.

A loss of trans­par­ency

Still, some econ­o­mists and ed­u­ca­tion ad­vo­cates worry that the move will de­crease trans­par­ency in the test­ing pro­cess.

“There’s a rea­son why we typ­i­cally have non­prof­its de­liver pub­lic goods like col­lege ad­mis­sions ex­ams,” Char­lie Ea­ton, co­founder of the Higher Ed­u­ca­tion, Race, and the Econ­omy Lab at the Univer­sity of Cal­i­for­nia, Merced, told CNN. “People need to be able to trust that there’s a fair eval­u­a­tion pro­cess so noth­ing gets dis­torted.”

Non­profit com­pa­nies are sub­ject to reg­u­la­tory over­sight and dis­clo­sure re­quire­ments, which help en­sure trans­par­ency and main­tain pub­lic con­fi­dence. A com­pany owned by pri­vate eq­uity can ob­fus­cate what the com­pany ac­tu­ally does to the pub­lic and po­ten­tially to reg­u­la­tors.

The ACT will be­come a “pub­lic ben­e­fit cor­po­ra­tion,” which means it is sup­posed to take the pub­lic good and share­holder in­ter­ests into ac­count. Still, that does not ex­empt it from taxes or from dis­trib­ut­ing its prof­its to its new own­ers.

Advertise with us

Nexus Cap­i­tal Man­age­ment’s port­fo­lio also in­cludes Sav­vas Learn­ing Com­pany, which spe­cial­izes in de­sign­ing K-12 cur­ric­u­lums. “If a pri­vate eq­uity firm has in­put in the test­ing but they also own a com­pany that de­vel­ops the cur­ric­u­lum, they have con­trol over the en­tire pro­cess,” said Azani Creeks, a se­nior re­search at the Pri­vate Equity Share­holder Proj­ect.

Opaque con­trol

“They have a lot of con­trol in ways that are not trans­par­ent. With some­thing as im­por­tant as col­lege ad­mis­sions test­ing you want that trans­par­ency. Non­prof­its have to share a lot of in­for­ma­tion with the pub­lic, pri­vate eq­uity-owned struc­tures don’t,” she added.

ACT says it will not im­me­di­ately raise test prices and that cur­rent, non­profit ACT will re­tain a mi­nor­ity in­ter­est in the com­pany and con­tinue its re­search on ed­u­ca­tion and the work­place.

Good­win told CNN that she has heard and un­der­stands the con­cerns, but that ACT part­nered with Nexus be­cause of its “track record of work­ing in ed­u­ca­tion in a trans­par­ent way” and with the in­ten­tion of cre­at­ing long-term value in­stead of chas­ing profit.

Crit­ics re­main skep­ti­cal. “We should be wor­ried about in­dus­tries where there are a lot of gov­ern­ment sub­si­dies avail­able, where con­sum­ers of­ten are not well in­formed, and where there’s a lot of mar­ket power for firms,” said Con­stan­tine Yan­nelis, an as­so­ci­ate pro­fes­sor of fi­nance at Univer­sity of Chi­cago Booth School of Busi­ness. “I think the test­ing in­dus­try is un­for­tu­nately one of those in­dus­tries where all three of those fac­tors ap­ply pretty strongly.”

Advertise with us

A lot of col­leges that are state-owned and re­ceive gov­ern­ment sub­si­dies use the ACT to ad­mit stu­dents and to ad­min­is­ter aid, he said. “I worry that prof­it­abil­ity could come at the ex­pense of stu­dents, and par­tic­u­larly stu­dents com­ing from lower in­come fam­i­lies.”

A broader prob­lem

It’s not just the ACT that’s go­ing the way of pri­vate eq­uity. “Test­ing is go­ing down­hill in the U.S.,” said Rebecca Winthrop, di­rec­tor of the Center for Univer­sal Ed­u­ca­tion at the Brook­ings In­sti­tu­tion. “All of these com­pa­nies are ac­tively shift­ing how they think about their prod­ucts and the roles of test­ing. They’re los­ing money be­cause peo­ple are ques­tion­ing their mer­its.”

That means they need to ex­pand. Pri­vate eq­uity in­vest­ment in ed­u­ca­tion ser­vices amounted to $2.09 bil­lion across 31 deals in the quar­ter to June 20, 2023, sur­pass­ing the $1.42 bil­lion recorded in the sec­ond quar­ter of 2022, ac­cord­ing to S&P Global Mar­ket In­tel­li­gence data.

Pri­vate eq­uity firms “come into in­dus­tries that are al­ready suf­fer­ing from a lack of fund­ing,” said Creeks. “All of these is­sues with stan­dard­ized test­ing pre­date pri­vate eq­uity. They’ve had a lack of fund­ing and sup­port and so some­times pri­vate eq­uity is the only vi­a­ble op­tion. That’s why I re­ally sup­port gov­ern­ment reg­u­la­tion and in­creased fund­ing.”

Nicole Goodkind is a senior markets reporter at CNN Business.