For­eign pol­icy can make a mock­ery of moral cer­ti­tude. You’re try­ing to mas­ter a land­scape of an­ar­chy po­liced by vi­o­lence, where ide­o­log­i­cal dif­fer­ences make Amer­i­can po­lar­iza­tion look like ge­nial neigh­bor­li­ness, where even a su­per­power’s abil­ity to im­pose its will dis­solves with dis­tance, where any grand proj­ect re­quires al­li­ances with tyr­anny and worse.

This seems clear when you con­sider the di­lem­mas of the past. It’s why the “good war” of World War II in­volved a part­ner­ship with a mon­ster in Mos­cow and the sub­jec­tion af­ter the war of half of Europe to to­tal­i­tar­ian op­pres­sion.

It’s why the “bad war” of Vi­et­nam was only es­caped at the cost of be­tray­ing the South Vi­et­nam­ese and mak­ing a deal with yet an­other mon­ster in Bei­jing.

The cold tragic vi­sion

But in ac­tive con­tro­ver­sies the tragic vi­sion can seem like a cold way of look­ing at the world. Lean into it too hard, and you get ac­cused of ig­nor­ing in­justice or re­ca­pit­u­lat­ing the in­dif­fer­ence that gave cover to past atroc­i­ties.

Advertise with us

Some­times those ac­cu­sa­tions have some bite. A “re­al­ist” for­eign pol­icy can slide from de­scrib­ing power to ex­cus­ing dep­re­da­tions. It can un­der­es­ti­mate the power of a righ­teous cause — as I un­der­es­ti­mated, for in­stance, Ukraine’s ca­pac­ity to de­fend it­self in 2022.

But see­ing state­craft as a tragic bal­anc­ing of evils is still es­sen­tial, es­pe­cially amid the kind of moral fer­vor that at­tends a con­flict like Is­rael’s war in the Gaza Strip. The al­ter­na­tive is a form of ar­gu­ment in which es­sen­tial as­pects of the world, be­ing in­con­ve­nient to moral ab­so­lut­ism, sim­ply dis­ap­pear.

For ex­am­ple, read­ing the ap­o­lo­gia for pro-Pal­es­tin­ian pro­tests from cer­tain left-wing in­tel­lec­tu­als, you have a sense of both eli­sion and ex­ag­ger­a­tion, a hype around Is­raeli moral fail­ures — it’s not enough for a war that yields so many ca­su­al­ties to be un­just, if it’s wrong it must be geno­cide — that ends up sup­press­ing the harsh im­pli­ca­tions of a sim­ple call for peace.

A rep­re­sen­ta­tive pas­sage, from Pankaj Mishra in The Lon­don Review of Books, de­scribes many pro­test­ers as “mo­ti­vated by the sim­ple wish to up­hold the ide­als that seemed so uni­ver­sally de­sir­able af­ter 1945: re­spect for free­dom, tol­er­ance for the oth­er­ness of be­liefs and ways of life; sol­i­dar­ity with hu­man suf­fer­ing; and a sense of moral re­spon­si­bil­ity for the weak and per­se­cuted.”

Ir­rel­e­vant ide­als

No doubt many cam­pus pro­test­ers have these mo­ti­va­tions. The dif­fi­culty is that lib­eral “free­dom” is on of­fer al­most no­where in the Mid­dle East, cer­tainly not in Gaza un­der Ha­mas’ rule, and the most chal­leng­ing “oth­er­ness of be­liefs” in this sit­u­a­tion are the be­liefs that mo­ti­vated the mas­sa­cres of Oct. 7.

Advertise with us

Another dif­fi­culty is that some in­sti­ga­tors of the pro­tests, in­clud­ing some of the stu­dent groups that were at work im­me­di­ately af­ter Oct. 7, seem un­trou­bled by this fact, and per­fectly com­fort­able with sup­port­ing not just peace­ful ne­go­ti­a­tion but a rev­o­lu­tion­ary strug­gle led by Isla­mist fa­nat­ics.

Which yields the moral di­lemma the pro­tests don’t ac­knowl­edge: End­ing the war on the terms they want could grant a ma­jor stra­te­gic vic­tory to the re­gional al­li­ance ded­i­cated to the mur­der of Is­rae­lis and their ex­pul­sion from the Mid­dle East.

Maybe the Is­rael-Ha­mas war is un­just enough, and Is­raeli goals un­achiev­able enough, that there’s no al­ter­na­tive to vin­di­cat­ing Ha­mas’ blood-soaked strat­egy. But you have to be hon­est about what you’re en­dors­ing: a bru­tal weigh­ing-out of evils, not any sort of tri­umph for “uni­ver­sally de­sir­able” ide­als.

Then a sim­i­lar point ap­plies to sup­port­ers of the Is­raeli war, for whom moral con­sid­er­ations — the evil of Ha­mas, the his­tor­i­cal suf­fer­ing of the Jew­ish peo­ple, the spe­cial Amer­i­can re­la­tion­ship with Is­rael — are in­voked as an ar­gu­ment-ender in an in­flex­i­ble way.

We are con­stantly urged to “stand with Is­rael” when it’s un­clear if Is­rael knows what it’s do­ing. Joe Biden’s ad­min­is­tra­tion is chas­tised for be­trayal when it tries to in­flu­ence Is­rael’s war­mak­ing, even though the Is­raeli gov­ern­ment’s de­ci­sions be­fore and since Oct. 7 do not in­spire great con­fi­dence.

Advertise with us

Biden’s spe­cific at­tempts to mi­cro­man­age the con­flict may be mis­guided or ham­fisted. But it’s not mis­guided for Amer­ica, an im­pe­rium deal­ing with mul­ti­ply­ing threats, to de­cline to write a blank check for a war be­ing waged with­out a clear plan for vic­tory or for peace.

Mir­rored left and right

The al­ter­na­tive ar­tic­u­lated by, for in­stance, Mitt Rom­ney — “We stand by al­lies, we don’t sec­ond-guess them” — is not a se­ri­ous pol­icy for a he­ge­mon bal­anc­ing its global ob­li­ga­tions. And the re­li­gious vi­sion of House Speaker Mike John­son and other Chris­tian Zion­ists, where Is­rael’s re-found­ing is ev­i­dence of a prov­i­den­tial plan, does not im­ply that Is­raeli gov­ern­ments are im­mune from stra­te­gic blun­ders. Go read the Book of Kings!

In each case, you have a de­sire that mir­rors the im­pulse of the left-wing in­tel­lec­tu­als — to make for­eign pol­icy easy by con­dens­ing ev­ery­thing to a sin­gle moral judg­ment. But the prob­lems of the world can­not be so eas­ily re­duced.

Be­ing cold-eyed and tragic-minded does not mean aban­don­ing mo­ral­ity. But it means rec­og­niz­ing that of­ten no­body is sim­ply right, no sin­gle ap­proach is mor­ally ob­vi­ous, and no strat­egy is clean.

Ross Douthat is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “Our diseases are as political as everything else.”