When James Madi­son was on his death­bed, his niece no­ticed an odd ex­pres­sion on his face and asked if he was okay. He re­plied, “Noth­ing more than a change of mind, my dear.” And then the Father of the Con­sti­tu­tion died.

What did he change his mind about? The vi­a­bil­ity of a bi-cam­eral leg­is­la­ture? The bed­room wall­pa­per? We’ll never know.

The im­por­tant thing for us to re­mem­ber, 200 years later, is that he changed his mind. Many times. He was a great mind-changer on all sorts of is­sues through­out his ca­reer. At first, for in­stance, he’d op­posed the Bill of Rights, but later be­came one of its great­est cham­pi­ons.

Flawed but fluid

Advertise with us

Our found­ing fathers had many flaws. They were elite men of the 18th-cen­tury mind­set, which is to say most of them were rac­ist and sex­ist. But they also had many vir­tues, in­clud­ing one that should not be un­der­es­ti­mated: They were flex­i­ble think­ers. They had ep­i­ste­mic hu­mil­ity, and of­ten changed their minds when pre­sented with new ev­i­dence or rea­son­ing.

Now­a­days, chang­ing your mind, es­pe­cially when it comes to po­lit­i­cal opin­ions, is seen by many as a weak­ness. What are you, a flip-flop­per?

Studies sug­gest that cur­rent Amer­i­cans — both pol­i­ti­cians and or­di­nary cit­i­zens — are much less likely to change our minds than in de­cades past. We’ve be­come en­trenched.

We are stuck in our tribal mind­sets about al­most ev­ery topic — the econ­omy, cli­mate change, iden­tity and for­eign af­fairs. So­cial me­dia has helped to cre­ate and in­ten­sify echo cham­bers where our be­liefs are rarely chal­lenged, and where the other side is of­ten de­mo­nized.

While it’s our cur­rent nor­mal, this in­tran­si­gence is not a tra­di­tional Amer­i­can stance. The found­ing fathers, at their best, were pro­foundly flex­i­ble in their think­ing.

Advertise with us

You can see it in Madi­son’s notes on the Con­sti­tu­tional Con­ven­tion, where so much was fluid. Should the pres­i­dent be a sin­gle per­son, or should there be a coun­cil of sev­eral co-pres­i­dents? Should sen­a­tors’ terms last for two years, six years or for life? Where should the gov­ern­ment be lo­cated?

The del­egates had read widely, ab­sorb­ing ideas from phi­los­o­phers of all stripes, both an­cient and mod­ern.

At the Con­sti­tu­tional Con­ven­tion, the in­di­vid­ual votes of the del­egates were counted but not recorded by name. The found­ers didn’t want the del­egates to feel locked into a po­si­tion. They wanted them to be able to change their minds in the fu­ture with ease.

Flexible then, fixed and static to­day

As all in­sti­tu­tions do over time, Amer­i­can gov­ern­ment has be­come much more fixed and static. But while we’ve gained sta­bil­ity, we’ve lost our thirst for fresh solu­tions. We should re­turn to some of the flu­id­ity that marked our birth.

Advertise with us

Ben­ja­min Frank­lin was per­haps the pin­na­cle of this mind­set. At the Con­sti­tu­tional Con­ven­tion, he said, “I have ex­pe­ri­enced many in­stances of be­ing obliged, by bet­ter in­for­ma­tion or fuller con­sid­er­ation, to change opin­ions even on im­por­tant sub­jects … It is there­fore that the older I grow the more apt I am to doubt my own judg­ment.”

In his au­to­bi­og­ra­phy, he ad­vised read­ers never to use the words “cer­tainly” or “un­doubt­edly” when stat­ing our be­liefs. In­stead say “I imag­ine it to be so; or it is so, if I am not mis­taken.”

Frank­lin liked to tell a short par­a­ble. There was a “French lady, who, in a lit­tle dis­pute with her sis­ter said: ‘I don’t know how it hap­pens, sis­ter, but I meet with no­body but my­self that is al­ways in the right.’”

Frank­lin’s point was that we are all that French lady. We all be­lieve we have a mo­nop­oly on the truth. I know I feel that way most of the time. But I fight that in­cli­na­tion.

I try to re­mind my­self: What are the odds that I, one of 8 bil­lion hu­mans on earth, hap­pen to be that sin­gu­lar per­son who has dis­cov­ered the cor­rect take on pol­i­tics, lit­er­a­ture, the en­vi­ron­ment, re­li­gion and all other top­ics? Prob­a­bly two to one. Maybe even three to one.

Advertise with us

We need to go back

There have been oc­ca­sional in­stances in mod­ern pol­i­tics of lead­ers bravely chang­ing their minds — though they al­most never put it that way. They usu­ally say their be­liefs have “evolved.” I don’t much care what they call it, as long as their shift in views is based on rea­son, ev­i­dence, and what’s best for the coun­try.

Pres­i­dent George H.W. Bush made a fa­mous cam­paign prom­ise: “Read my lips. No new taxes.” As pres­i­dent, he changed his mind and agreed to a com­pro­mise that raised some taxes to re­duce the bud­get def­i­cit. That con­trib­uted to his de­feat for a sec­ond term, but it was the right thing to do for Amer­ica. Pres­i­dent Barack Obama also made the right choice in chang­ing his mind on le­gal­iz­ing same-sex mar­riage.

Flex­i­ble think­ing is part of Amer­ica’s DNA. We need to re­turn to early Amer­ica flu­id­ity.

A.J. Ja­cobs is a jour­nal­ist, pod­caster and au­thor of “The Year of Liv­ing Con­sti­tu­tion­ally.” His previous article is “The executive branch has become too powerful.”